Sitka Gear
Do you get the flu vaccine?
Community
Contributors to this thread:
Two Feathers 16-Dec-14
Mike in CT 16-Dec-14
Hunting5555 16-Dec-14
tonyo6302 16-Dec-14
Dave G. 16-Dec-14
Jim Moore 16-Dec-14
Joey Ward 16-Dec-14
TwoDogs@work 16-Dec-14
BlueDog 16-Dec-14
The Old Sarge 16-Dec-14
DaleHajas 16-Dec-14
Jim in Ohio 16-Dec-14
Jim in Ohio 16-Dec-14
Joey Ward 16-Dec-14
tonyo6302 16-Dec-14
Dave G. 16-Dec-14
BIGHORN 16-Dec-14
Shuteye 16-Dec-14
Amoebus 16-Dec-14
Joey Ward 16-Dec-14
Jimbo 16-Dec-14
Bowfreak 16-Dec-14
Mint 16-Dec-14
Jim Moore 16-Dec-14
HA/KS 16-Dec-14
Jim in Ohio 16-Dec-14
Hawkarcher 16-Dec-14
BowSniper 16-Dec-14
Hammer 16-Dec-14
70lbdraw 17-Dec-14
Deflatem 17-Dec-14
joshuaf 17-Dec-14
Yendor 17-Dec-14
Hammer 17-Dec-14
Pat C. 17-Dec-14
Anony Mouse 18-Dec-14
Anony Mouse 19-Dec-14
Heat 19-Dec-14
TD 19-Dec-14
From: Two Feathers
16-Dec-14
I don't get them!

From: Mike in CT
16-Dec-14

Mike in CT's Link
Spike,

I chose this link for reasons that should quickly become obvious; there are far too many documented cases of the effectiveness of a vaccination program to ignore.

There are a lot of points brought up in the link you provided and to really address them all would take quite a bit of time.

A few main points though are:

1. There will always be cases of ineffectiveness of any vaccine for a number of reasons. Among those reasons are the immune status of the recipient may be compromised (age, illness, on immunosuppressive therapy due to conditions such as lupus, psoriatic arthritis, eczema, etc or organ transplant), the fact that vaccines are made on the "most likely" strain thought to be prevalent for the coming flu season. Viruses have a number of mechanisms of evading treatment or vaccines and it doesn't take much in the way of antigenic structure (what antibodies target; vaccines are designed to induce an immune response) to the point where the effectiveness of the vaccine is diminished.

2. Flu is spread via aerosols; even if 1 in 10 people are effectively vaccinated that 1 person will not be spreading virus. Think of the number of people you come in contact with on an average day and you get a sense of the exponential benefit derived.

3. Hospitals can be the best and worst place in the world to be for the sick. Google "Hospital acquired infections" and you'll quickly see the downstream benefit of preventing hospitalizations. Additionally hospitalization(s) cost money; to the patient and if the elderly who are on Medicare/Medicaid, the taxpayer.

I do agree with your link's reference to doing all you can to boost the performance of your immune system.

Hope this was helpful!

From: Hunting5555
16-Dec-14
Nope!!!

Like a doctor told my mother last year: "There are this many variations of the flu every year (Held his arms out stretched). Flu shot covers this many (held two fingers about a 1/4 inch apart).

From: tonyo6302
16-Dec-14
I get one every year.

Most in my work place do not. And every year they get the Flu. Flu spreads faster in a work place than Strep Throat or Pink Eye.

I have not had the Flu in over 10 years.

From: Dave G.
16-Dec-14
I've gotten mine every year for the last 10-12 years. (since I became what I consider to be "an old phart")

Personal experience: Most years were great and I made it through the flu season without even a sniffle. But there were a couple of years that were a true curse. Maybe just coincidence, but those years that both me and the wife suffered through the flu were also the years that we spent a lot of time over Thanksgiving/Christmas with our young (grade school/middle school) nieces and nephews. I blamed those little "germ sponges" for giving us the creeping crud. :^)

From: Jim Moore
16-Dec-14
Never have had a shot. Wife either. Cannot remember having the flu in recent memory. I know of a couple of people who insist on getting them yet wind up with the flu.

I think some peoples immune systems can actually be degraded by too much preventive medicines. Course I am not a doc, just and observer.

From: Joey Ward
16-Dec-14
I lose way too many sick hours every year to get a flu shot.

Besides, it gives me a chance to watch Jeopardy, Judge Mathis, and The King of Queens marathon. And other than being in a treestand or working a trolling motor, it keeps my family away from me for that "re-charging" of my battery. :-)

I keep a bottle of Nyquil and a 5th of Jimmy Beam stashed away for the occasion.

he he he

:-)

From: TwoDogs@work
16-Dec-14
I got my only flu shot about 15 years ago. Within a week I came down with the worst case of flu I have ever had. I probably should have received medical treatment, but did not. I was barely able to get off the couch for the next four or five days, which I barely remembered.

Did the flu shot have anything to do with it? I don't know, but it seemed a very unlikely coincidence to be totally unrelated. When I told my doctor about this later I was informed that I simply caught a strain of the flu that the shot did not prevent. I have not had a shot since and have only had minor colds in that time. I do not plan to get another shot anytime soon.

From: BlueDog
16-Dec-14
"a 5th of Jimmy Beam stashed away for the occasion."

I consider that preventive maintenance..... don't save it for treatment Joey.. damn..

16-Dec-14
When I was active duty, flu shots were mandatory. A lot, if not most, of us still got the flu. Since retiring from active duty in '91, I've not had a single flu shot and have not had the flu at all.

From: DaleHajas
16-Dec-14
No flu shot. 1tsp of Elderberry syrup, leftover from jelly making, added to a slug of Blackberry Bird Dog or Knob Creek keeps it away. Once daily. Now you can buy elderberry syrup OTC under the name Sambucol which is the chemical name for elderberry. This stuff you can take straight but I like to dilute it with a shot or 2:)

From: Jim in Ohio
16-Dec-14
My wife and I get one every year since we got old. Went for years without getting sick. This year we did come down with cough, cold but so did everyone around us. Will still get one every year.

From: Jim in Ohio
16-Dec-14
My wife and I get one every year since we got old. Went for years without getting sick. This year we did come down with cough, cold but so did everyone around us. Will still get one every year.

From: Joey Ward
16-Dec-14
Dog, I consider a regular maintenance of beer to be the preventor.

Too, I can say I've never a had a kidney stone. I believe it to be because of the cleansing use of the beer.

;-)

From: tonyo6302
16-Dec-14
Joey Ward,

For a good "Guffaw" recommendation for when you are sick, try the "Maury" show, when they are doing the "You are not the Father" episodes.

I swear, some women have had 20 or more guys on the show for DNA tests, and still cannot find their "babydaddy".

It is hilarious.

From: Dave G.
16-Dec-14
WARNING!!!

Flu shots cause double posts. :^)

From: BIGHORN
16-Dec-14
My wife and I got flu shot three years in a row and both of us came down with the flu within a week each time. They keep telling us that the shot doesn't give you the flu. Bullsh.t. For the last two years and so far this year we have not gotten flu shots nor the flu.

From: Shuteye
16-Dec-14
I never had a flu shot and have never had the flu. My wife has never had a flu shot and has never had the flu. We ain't taking any chances so we still don't plan on getting a shot. Wash you hands and stay away from crowds. I had eye surgery today and hated going in for surgery with all the people. A friend drove me since when they got done I wouldn't be able to drive. He go a laugh out of the big red sticker they put over my right eye. He said that was great because when he went in for the removable of a lung they asked him which lung was coming out. He said, "Damn I was hoping you guys knew."

From: Amoebus
16-Dec-14
Yes.

Statistically, the flu shots help. Individually, results may vary.

From: Joey Ward
16-Dec-14
Tonyo, watched enough of THAT in highschool. ;-)

Speaking of shots, how do y'all feel about the "shingles" shot? Worthwhile?

I've had chicken pox and both parents have had a bout with shingles. I figure it's just a matter of time......

From: Jimbo
16-Dec-14
Yes. Every year. And will from now on.

Also, you cannot get the flu from a flu shot.

From: Bowfreak
16-Dec-14
I am lukewarm on the flu shot. I didn't get one this year but both of my children did. They both got the flu(confirmed). However....both only ran fevers for about a day and were pretty much normal after that. I can't swear that the flu shot was the reason but my feeble mind tells me it may have helped?

From: Mint
16-Dec-14
I ride the LIRR everyday to work in NYC and every year idiots with the flu get on the train. Every year I get the flu shot I don't get the flu. When I skipped getting the shot a couple of years I always got the flu.

From: Jim Moore
16-Dec-14
Damnn Joey, its only 1:40 PM here. Had the day off so already had a 12 can of preventative. Y'all have me scared so bad, I'm thinkin' that one more dose isn't out of the realm of possibility.

I think the "snick" of the pull tab helps scare the flu debbils away.

From: HA/KS
16-Dec-14
Most of the "flu" that goes around is a viral infection, but not the influenza. There are apparently hundreds or thousands of these, so you can always catch another one.

If you get the actual flu, you are generally VERY sick with fevers, aches, etc.

I have never had a flu shot. I considered it this year due to a new job that will expose me to a large number of new people.

One thing that I have read is that the older you are the less effective the vaccine may be. If you have the shot and still get the flu, it will probably be much milder.

From: Jim in Ohio
16-Dec-14
They have a special "High Dose" shot for us old people. We need all the help we can get.

From: Hawkarcher
16-Dec-14
I don't get the flu shot. Last week I was bragging I haven't had the flu since 1998. This past weekend I got the flu. So I'll change my ways and stop bragging. But I still probably won't get the shot.

From: BowSniper
16-Dec-14
Not getting any flu shot. Primarily because there are so many different variations the chance of getting it exactly right is remote. And why pout poison in your body gambling on a longshot? There was also some ruckus about different "grades" of flu shot, where in Germany the elite got a higher quality shot than the common masses. Probably happens here too. And no sense risking exposure to sloppy medicine and possible side effects.

From: Hammer
16-Dec-14
Never! Rarely get the flu. About every 15 years if that.

From: 70lbdraw
17-Dec-14
Nope! Can't remember the last time I had the flu. I seldom ever get as much as a cold. I hardly ever wash my hands outside of using the restroom, and I never use that hand sanitizer crap that you find in every public place these days.

I spent about 5 years as a contractor for Intel. I got sick more often when I was there. Everyone spends most of their day in a cleanroom and it causes your immune system to weaken. The second you leave work and step out into the real world you catch every germ known to man. It's amazing how many people there were always sick.

It seems that the "clean freaks and germ-ifobes" are always sick, so I tend to keep a bit of a slob element in my life for protection!!! It's worked pretty well so far. LOL!

From: Deflatem
17-Dec-14
If you weren't sick as a dog with fever, severe aches & perhaps some serious chest symptoms , you likely did NOT have the Influenza. I had it once. Lost 25 lbs, was in a bed for 2 weeks.... Yes , I get the shot !

From: joshuaf
17-Dec-14
Nope, never have had one, and I can't remember the last time I got the flu, either.

From: Yendor
17-Dec-14
Never have never will. I was a health care worker also. This years vaccine is somewhere near 65% ineffective. There are hundreds of different flus and the do a crap shoot or throw darts at the board to see which three they will include in this years vaccine. Nonsense.

From: Hammer
17-Dec-14
70,

That sounds like as good excuse as any to me bro

From: Pat C.
17-Dec-14
Yes because wife has had a kidney transplant and her immune system is very weak! Can't bring bugs home.

From: Anony Mouse
18-Dec-14
Funny...haven't bothered with the flu shot in the past two years and never gotten sick. Monday, woke up with a full blown case.

I used our family (science based)treatment:(Vernors/Kessler hot toddy), raise core temp and go to bed and sweat it out.

Today, almost completely cured...slight residual cough.

My wife, who gets her flu shot every year at work came down with it yesterday and has it worse than I did.

What this means, YMMV.

And...an article of some relevance:

Guest Blog: Five Flu Myths Busted

If you’re sick, stay at home.

It’s that time of the year again. You probably think I mean Christmas, but as a virologist the sight of glitter, fairy lights and mounting pine trees immediately makes me think of the flu season. And if there’s one thing that can ruin your family’s Christmas, it’s the arrival of that particular unwanted guest.

There are lots of myths around about flu. So, here’s a quick guide to some common knowledge that actually turns out to be wrong.

I’ve got the flu

You probably haven’t. Four or five weeks ago, I would have said that you definitely hadn’t, but the first laboratory confirmed cases of the 2014-15 season are now with us, so if you have those familiar symptoms, you may well be one of those unlucky enough to have a preview of the coming epidemic. However, the balance of probabilities right now is that you don’t have the influenza virus but one of the many other things that regularly inflict similar misery on us – like respiratory syncytial virus, a coronavirus or an enterovirus.

This last trio give you severe doses of what we generally call the common cold. Real flu, however, is caused by a different group of viruses. Symptoms of flu are more severe, including high temperatures, aches and pains, lethargy and can also include feeling nauseous. If you have a bit of a headache and feel sniffley, it’s more likely to be a cold.

But the flu will muscle all of these things out of the picture as the winter’s epidemic builds. More and more of us are likely to be having real flu rather than just bad colds.

I can’t avoid it

OK, there is no foolproof method of protecting yourself. If somebody does give vent to a hurricane-force sneeze on that crowded bus, then the air could well be loaded with aerosolized virus, and that virus may linger long after the sneezer has left the bus. But there are ways you can minimize your risk.

A lot of people catch flu, not from inhaling sneeze-aerosol, but from touching surfaces that have been sneezed on, or have had hand-caught sneezes wiped on them – such as the bell the sneezing passenger pressed to leave the bus, or the hand rail near the door. This is called fomite transmission, and you can minimize the chances of you picking up a virus this way by simply remembering not to put your fingers in your mouth, nose or eyes while you are out of the house.

“Hands down” is the motto, and then wash your hands when you get home. This way the flu virus goes down the drain instead of into your body. Carry a bottle of hand-gel in your pocket for those occasions when you are eating out.

It doesn’t really matter

Yes, I know, you’ve had worse, stiff (if wet) upper lip and all that. But such macho attitudes do no favors to other people. While the vast majority of younger people suffer for three days and then gradually return to the Christmas spirit, for many elderly people a bout of flu can mean their last Christmas.

So do them a favor – if you feel unwell, stay at home, get a hot drink and some DVDs and wait until you are better before returning to the outside world. Thousands of vulnerable individuals die every year because tough young people insist on battling though. And at the very least, your fellow travelers and colleagues might appreciate it too.

Vaccination isn’t an option

Yes it is. Vaccination is for everybody. Not just to protect yourself, but to prevent you spreading it to others. There are three types of flu virus: A, B and C. As the first two occur most often, these are the ones covered by seasonal vaccines, developed each year.

Some people are particularly vulnerable to flu – those in older age but also pregnant women, adults and children, those with underlying health conditions and those with weak immune systems. These groups should certainly go for an annual flu jab. While your local health center will probably turn you away and tell you to come back once high-priority cases have been dealt with, they are doing that because they have limited time and public money.

But there are plenty of private providers – pharmacies and supermarkets – that will vaccinate you much sooner for as little as the cost of a cinema ticket.

We can catch it by eating infected chickens

Flu is fundamentally a disease of birds, meaning that at any one time, most of the world’s of flu virus particles are in ducks, geese and seagulls rather than humans. If television ancestry show “Who Do You Think You Are?” ever gets round to featuring a human seasonal flu virus as a guest, then the ancestral trails would all eventually lead back to birds.

But the flu viruses we suffer from are rather specialized beasts, that have journeyed a long way from their duck pond origins and adapted especially to the task of living and breeding in us. So it is very difficult for us to catch a bird flu and conversely difficult for the birds to catch one of ours.

The recent arrival of bird flu strain H5N8 in the UK poses no risk to humans as consumers of poultry. So enjoy your turkey. It is perfectly safe. But please, please, first wash your hands.

From: Anony Mouse
19-Dec-14
Article today from BioTechiques:

Why So Many Middle-aged Adults Catch the Flu

From: Heat
19-Dec-14
No Way!

From: TD
19-Dec-14
Nope, rarely get sick, get well quickly. Just lucky that way I guess, but then again I'm short and bald.... Coach OTOH catches everything that comes down the pike... and she gets shots every year.

Honestly I think it's a combo of being a disciple of Joey Ward and always being stressed by work, my system is always set on high. I ain't got time to be sick....

  • Sitka Gear