Sitka Gear
Education today's world??
Community
Contributors to this thread:
Ole Coyote 22-Feb-15
orionsbrother 22-Feb-15
bluedog 22-Feb-15
bluedog 22-Feb-15
Joey Ward 22-Feb-15
orionsbrother 22-Feb-15
bluedog 22-Feb-15
bluedog 22-Feb-15
Cazador 22-Feb-15
Shuteye 22-Feb-15
bluedog 22-Feb-15
Jim in Ohio 22-Feb-15
absaroka6 22-Feb-15
HA/KS 22-Feb-15
Anony Mouse 22-Feb-15
HA/KS 22-Feb-15
Salagi 22-Feb-15
Pat C. 22-Feb-15
Jim in Ohio 22-Feb-15
Owl 22-Feb-15
HA/KS 22-Feb-15
Pat C. 23-Feb-15
HA/KS 23-Feb-15
Mint 23-Feb-15
Joey Ward 23-Feb-15
Anony Mouse 23-Feb-15
Sage Buffalo 23-Feb-15
HA/KS 23-Feb-15
Amoebus 24-Feb-15
Joey Ward 24-Feb-15
Amoebus 24-Feb-15
itshot 24-Feb-15
HA/KS 24-Feb-15
HA/KS 24-Feb-15
SB 24-Feb-15
HA/KS 24-Feb-15
CAS_HNTR 25-Feb-15
LINK 25-Feb-15
bad karma 25-Feb-15
tonyo6302 25-Feb-15
Bowbender 25-Feb-15
Dave G. 25-Feb-15
Mike in CT 25-Feb-15
gflight 25-Feb-15
gflight 25-Feb-15
BowSniper 26-Feb-15
From: Ole Coyote
22-Feb-15
Over thelast few years I have talked to many young college folks that speak well and appear to be extremely intelligent the problem I see is they re book smart but have no common sense! Anybody else notice this?

22-Feb-15
I think that there's always been an "absent minded professor" sort of phenomenon. What I seem to be noticing more recently is the highly educated, high income individual who wears their practical ineptitude like a red badge of courage.

Where they seem to express pride over the fact that they lack rudimentary skills or practical knowledge, because they've attained some social level that is above mundane maintenance or repair.

"I wouldn't know which end of a hammer to hold!"

"I don't even know where the spare tire is!"

"I pay people to do things like that."

I suspect it's rooted in insecurity. The proudly inept, nouveau riche, trying to advertise that they are in a different economic strata.

From: bluedog
22-Feb-15
Agree ... it isn't just the highly educated and higher income people though...

Self sufficiency is becoming a lost art... was only a generation or 2 ago where it was the standard.

Not so anymore..People taking their chainsaw chains in to be sharpened, calling an expert to fix a leaky faucet, fixing their furnace or appliance.... painting a room, staining a deck.. call the professionals..

It has become difficult for the shade tree mechanic to fix some things on the newer vehicles.. much can still be do it yourself however. It's an opportunity to learn..

Sometimes my wife gives me "that look" when she sees a new tool. I just assure her it will go good at the auction.... ;)

The acceptance of shoddy work is a whole topic in its own. Oil pan drain plugs over tightened...lug nuts needing to be re-torqued properly after buying tires or you'll never get the wheel off when you get a flat..... too many "repairmen" are just parts changers.. keep putting in new parts until it works..

Sounding like a grumpy old man... LOL

From: bluedog
22-Feb-15
.. even in internet discussions.... it's common to cut and paste instead of having an original thought.. who can find the best editorial or "news".. The best "Jog Blogger" rules dont ya know...

People who've never elk hunted can assure us how it's done..people who were never in Vietnam can correct and explain how it really was.. how combat really is...

They've read it... it is so..

Damn .. fun to bitch.. ;)

From: Joey Ward
22-Feb-15
"Common sense" and "home cooking" are a couple things learned from one's upbringing, IMO.

There are just not enough teachers these days. ;-)

But, thank goodness for youtube "how to" videos. Thanks to folks that put them up. You've saved this old poor boy more than a dozen times. From work to play. :-)

22-Feb-15
The truly delusional ones are the kids that express that they want to be professional gamers. There's a lucrative career for anyone who wants to pursue it. No long shot odds there.

From: bluedog
22-Feb-15
You tube is a wonderful source for "How To"... you have to sort them though.. Seen some that make me shudder..

" they can afford the things that make them happy."

Pat leaves me a little nonplussed..... the things in my life that made me the happiest were all free or nearly so..

I see his meaning though, his perspective has some merit. I'm taking a fragment of what he said and judging it by itself..

From: bluedog
22-Feb-15
" they re book smart but have no common sense! Anybody else notice this?"

To Ole Coyote's original post......

I think it's more the innocence and naivety of youth rather than no commonsense.. Experience and wisdom is earned over time.

(then you get old and regress.) ;)

From: Cazador
22-Feb-15
First of all, we're talking about 18-23ish year old kids so really, what do you expect? What grand life experience do they have to fall back on? Give them a break.

Pat, the problem with your scenario is University study is big business. They don't care if someone blows 250K on a liberal arts/humanity degree. This is where the parent comes into play to offer some sort of direction.

It gets worse, how about committing kids to D1 Schools (sports) when they're 15. Did you know what you wanted to be at 15?

From: Shuteye
22-Feb-15
Too many people confuse intelligence with education. The more intelligent you are the more you get from a good education. However, I have had PhD's working for me that didn't have sense enough to pour piss out of a boot. I have a college educated friend that has plenty of money, left to him by his father. He doesn't even know how to charge a battery, change a tire or change oil in his truck.

From: bluedog
22-Feb-15
A person with any common sense would know not to piss in a boot.... ;)

22-Feb-15
Pat,

So true and thanks for making me laugh. You are spot on about all of them wanting careers in game development.

I give them the 'saving $25 a week for the rest of their lives'and they will be set. I also tell them that happiness can be bought??

Been teaching community college for 25 years and the kids continue to impress me. Sure they are different, but it is a different world than what we grew up in. They are sharp, and it is a pleasure working with them.

Don't believe everything written on the CF;)

From: Jim in Ohio
22-Feb-15
I like the common sense and skills of my neighbors. My 14 year old neighbor a few years back designed and built a milk parlor for a man down the road.

I had a 10 year old kid help me side my garage and knew more about it then I ever knew.

I had an 18 year old install three big sliding garage doors for me, complete with latches. He measured them up, we went to the lumber yard to get what he said we needed and in a half a day we had them installed.

Another 12 year old rebuilt my riding lawnmower and installed a new engine on my rototiller. He also tears down antique tractors, engine and all and helps his dad rebuild them.

I let you guess what kind of people they are.

From: absaroka6
22-Feb-15
I hate to admit this but, my middle daughter, when it comes to book smarts, she's as sharp as a straight razor. When it comes to common sense, she's as dumb as a fence post. Some days I think the post has one up on her.

From: HA/KS
22-Feb-15
Remember that from birth to HS graduation, a kid is in school for less than 10% of the time.

From: Anony Mouse
22-Feb-15
"If I was a college professor I would spend half my class explaining the realities of life to these stupid kids."

LOL...Pat, far too many of the college educators have little if any real world experiences and base their reality upon theories. Sometimes I think that a high school grad would do better flipping burgers or working as a stock/sales person for a couple years before entering post high school education.

Dan...with the sub zero temps last week, I could not get the hood of my truck open to even attempt putting a battery charger on it. Thank goodness for YouTube...found a video and a solution.

From: HA/KS
22-Feb-15
You are correct, Mouse. One problem for teachers is that the college instructors teaching teachers how to teach often have little or no recent classroom experience.

From: Salagi
22-Feb-15
"One problem for teachers is that the college instructors teaching teachers how to teach often have little or no recent classroom experience."

The same is true for many of the administrators at the Department of Education - at least here in Arkansas. Hence many of the rules that make teaching tough and don't benefit the students.

If I had started teaching when I graduated college, I would have enough years to hang it up this year. And with the paperwork hoops we have to jump through to satisfy the higher ups, I probably wood. On the other hand, having sat out for 15 years (due to circumstances beyond my control), and working in "the real world" has made me a better teacher.

From: Pat C.
22-Feb-15
My nephew wanted to go to the cabin a couple weeks ago and we showed him on a map how to get there. He looked at the map and asked what good is that going to do me? I told him it will show you how to get there, he told me he couldn't read a map if he had to. And besides he has GPS on his phone. I asked him what if it don't work or your phone dies.

From: Jim in Ohio
22-Feb-15
The kids I know only go to the 8th grade. Their teacher never went to high school. Yet they are far smarter and prepared for life then our high school grads. Their unemployment rate is 0.0. They are Amish.

From: Owl
22-Feb-15
This is the result of the failed construct that is "adolescence."

-This piggybacks Jim in Ohio's post.

From: HA/KS
22-Feb-15
"I asked him what if it don't work or your phone dies." Not to be difficult, but they used the same argument about horses and cars.

From: Pat C.
23-Feb-15
Well there a lot of places that don't have phn signal. And is knowing how to read a map that far gone?

From: HA/KS
23-Feb-15
Pat, my son is a cartographer. I hope maps are still important. So are horses in some places.

From: Mint
23-Feb-15
I think there is rampant grade inflation going on in these colleges now days. We hire some interns every summer and these kids are straight A's at good schools but cannot handle the basic tasks that a high school kid should be able to do.

From: Joey Ward
23-Feb-15
And sports.

;-)

From: Anony Mouse
23-Feb-15
Pat...most certainly correct.

A large percentage of students today that enter college take remedial courses in basic English (reading and writing) and math (pre-algebra)before they can even register for a college level course. Further, more and more nonsensical degree programs have been created leading to degrees that lead to nowhere.

From: Sage Buffalo
23-Feb-15
Kids are smarter now than ANY generation before them. Don't for one minute think that's not the case.

The technology and ability to teach is just better. It will be like that for the next generation as well.

Cazador nailed it - these are 18-23 yo. No common sense until they have a wife and kids. Until then, they are just "know-it-alls".

The big difference between this generation and previous generations is they have decided they don't want to waste their life working and have challenged the status-quo.

That's been the biggest challenge because if the entire work force says no - threats are meaningless.

So they are getting what they want. Work/life balance.

Hmmm. Maybe they have more common sense than I thought.

From: HA/KS
23-Feb-15
"Its harder to be a kid today than any other time. That's for sure."

I mostly agree, but it is a different kind of difficult. Remember that 100 years ago, half of all kids were still losing their lives to childhood diseases.

From: Amoebus
24-Feb-15
Define common sense.

If I am living in a city, make 500k, don't hunt and get my oil changed at the jiffy lube, why would it make 'common sense' to learn those things?

They may look at you and have the same discussion about your lack of common sense for not knowing the light rail schedule or managing a hedge fund or sending a photo on your smart phone.

I suspect there are no older generations in the last 2000 years that didn't have the same lament - and there are many more examples of the same phenomena.

Pat - from your first post I assume that you got a Computer Security - emphasis IT/management degree? No? Something like Computer Science/Business that taught you how to think, rather than teaching you a trade that would be out of date in 3 years? There aren't many jobs out there that you couldn't learn in 6 months of on-the-job-training. Finding out if you have the learning capacity to do that is how an employer looks at a college degree - the more well-rounded the better.

From: Joey Ward
24-Feb-15
It's better to know how to do it and not have to than not know how and need to.

Common sense?

;-)

From: Amoebus
24-Feb-15
Jack - "Sometimes I think that a high school grad would do better flipping burgers or working as a stock/sales person for a couple years before entering post high school education."

I did both out of high school (college and flipping burgers). My daughter is taking a 'gap year' as she calls it and is flipping pizza dough. I don't see it as a positive thing, but we each have to find our own path. I will report back in 20 years if she says it was beneficial...

From: itshot
24-Feb-15
tic

24-Feb-15
Pat,

You must have went to a crappy college:)

My first managerial position I did not use my economics undergraduate degree per se, but learning how to organize and balance a challenging schedule amongst competing valuable goals, learning to accept different view points and debate respectfully, learning to think strategically,critically and analytically-these are all skills that are developed not by accident and were very beneficial to me personally in my career development. They would not have happened if I stayed at the factory upon high school graduation. Nothing wrong, understand, with not going to college, just strongly disagree that college develops little that is useful for most people.

Amazes me how we have so many foreign students clamoring to gain access to our "worthless" university system in America. I will be the first to say we need to and must get better by adapting quicker to the changing skills needed by employers, but some skills will always be needed, and colleges still do a pretty good job of it. I have only 3 years left, so I am not inclined to say anything but how I see it.

From: HA/KS
24-Feb-15
"I have only 3 years left" Wow, condolences. Must be sort of a slow-moving disease. Buy a big insurance policy before the company finds out - we could even pitch in for part of the premiums. Name the regulars here as beneficiaries and we will go on some major hunt in your memory.

24-Feb-15
I bet you didn't finish college HK:) Just kidding-3 years to retirement. Lot of folks can't wait to go in whatever career they are in by that time, but not me. I just want to go before I become one of those "too old" professors that is not making a difference any more.

Instead of the regulars going on a major hunt, maybe just have a major change in tactics-deal with the position taken, don't attack personally. Something else we try and teach:)

From: HA/KS
24-Feb-15
I knew exactly what you meant, but sometimes finding humor is important.

From: SB
24-Feb-15
A lot of us traveled after graduation.....many came home in a box.

From: HA/KS
24-Feb-15
Too true, SB

From: CAS_HNTR
25-Feb-15
I do agree with Pat that there are FAR too many people that chose a career path that they "like" with little to no forward thinking and end up barely making enough to live on.

My sister really likes art and decided that art education was her "path".....well, she works at a high school teaching several art classes and really likes it, but she makes almost nothing and has lost her job or quit 3 other schools because the first thing that goes is art when budgets get trimmed. She also has a difficult time with some of the leadership as the expect her to structure her class as a "show up and pass" type class.....many cases she has failed slacker students which ended up not graduating....parents and principals weren't happy, but she refuses to pass kids that don't do squat. She also makes them do push-ups for misbehavior and cussing is class.

I chose a technical degree and got my BS and MS in Civil/Structural Engineering....I design bridges, retaining walls, large culverts, pretty much anything that is needed to build a roadway/highway system.....that being said, there is no real money in my position either. The position is underpaid and under-appreciated when compared to my friends (classmates) that chose either chemical or environmental engineering routes.....90% of what they do is fill out reports/log data to report to the federal government for pollution monitoring! They don't do anything technical at all, but the perceived value of not getting fined by the EPA is greater than if bridge collapses during your daily commute (at least that's how it seems). They all make ALOT more than me (and don't get me stated on friends that work for Exxon, BP, Marathon, SHell, etc) and likely will always will!

I just keep hoping the older guys retire and that bridges keep crumbling.....my stock should be going up in future years! Haha!

From: LINK
25-Feb-15
I'm 30 and I do pretty much all the tasks that have been mentioned on my own. I'm hoping to build my own house in the next 5-10 years even though my construction knowledge is limited. Why? Because I'm too poor(wife would say tight) to pay someone. You can bet if money was plentiful I wouldn't do near as much. Some will ask me why I do these things and I reply poor people have poor ways. Or someone might say how did you know how to do that? My answer is tear it apart and figure out how to put it back right. I've got a business degree that for the most part is useless, I wish I would have went to a tech school. Thank god there are still good jobs that could care less about a college degree.

From: bad karma
25-Feb-15
We'll have to have a betting pool on when the word *POOF* reappears.

The idea that someone who works in the financial world produces nothing meaningful for mankind is more corral dust. Helping others make enough money to retire early, or pay for their kid's college, or buy a suitable home, is meaningful work. One more example of him just regurgitating what came from some other imbecile.

From: tonyo6302
25-Feb-15
"I had the good fortune to travel after high school. I was not ready for college, I was antsy, rebellious, angry and needed to blow off steam. I travelled (thanks to a small inheritance) and saw Europe, Asia and the Middle East. I came back a focused student, a better human and I wouldn't change that experience for the world. Gap years can be productive so long as he or she isn't sitting on a couch with a bong with little or no direction."

So then, HoytVector, how did you become involved in ROTC, as you stated on the stolen valor thread?

ROTC Instructors are either active duty Military, or retired Military that receive a stipend from the College they teach at.

Care to re-register under your real name?

From: Bowbender
25-Feb-15
"So then, HoytVector, how did you become involved in ROTC, as you stated on the stolen valor thread?"

Don't forget he served in the first Gulf War at age 13 or 14....

From: Dave G.
25-Feb-15
When Hoytvector (et al) said ROTC, he didn't mean Reserve Officer's Training Corp, his version of ROTC is Reaching Out To Communities - a grassroots Obamabot program.

From: Mike in CT
25-Feb-15
So worried about little ol me?

Between worrying about iridium exposure from my diver's watch and trying to figure out how many grains of salt on the average McD's fry you're not making my top ten "things to worry about" just yet. (If I finalize my count of the number of globules in a snow globe tonight though you'll crack the top ten.....)

Your getting pushed aside by progressives.

Darn it, I thought we'd straigtened this sort of thing out! "Your" denotes possession as in "the ball is yours" while "You're" refers to an action directed towards you (can be a single person or the collective "you") are, as in "You are (You're) the mambo king."

I'll start worrying about progressives when they can "progress" beyond the "See Spot Run" vocabulary and accompanying grammatical proficiency level.

Boehner and McDonnel

I think you meant "McConnell"; perhaps you were typing this brilliant reparte on your iPhone while asking a customer if they wanted anything else with their Happy Meal?

From: gflight
25-Feb-15
Ol hoytvector seems to be living in the past. Does he not realize that hardly any of us just propagate the GOP line but use our brains.

Just when you think he has an intelligent post he shatters his credibility....

From: gflight
25-Feb-15
Happy meal? ROTFLMAO...

From: BowSniper
26-Feb-15
If HoytVector was living in the past he would still be using his old alias of Doc/HunterBrad/CactusJack, etc.

  • Sitka Gear