How Well do you know your birds?
General Topic
Contributors to this thread:
I know to some of you must be asking what the heck do birds have to do with bowhunting, unless its a turkey? But sadly I learned way too late in life, that bowhunting is an adventure in nature education and gives us a chance to learn a lot about a lot of different animals and birds.
With that said, I am going to post some photos, of different birds, for those that want to play or learn their names.
For many years I over looked all that was going on in nature. It took a camera for me to get interested in a lot of different critters and birds, which I now look back on with deep regret.
I know there are a lot like me, but I also know there are others that do see bowhunting as a learning opportunity in every direction!
So if you know the bird, name it and tell us a bit about its habits and way to ID it if you can.
I will post 10 and once they are identified correctly, I will post 10 more if there is any interest.
I also encourage any of you with bird photos to post them, put a different number to them and see who can ID it. We all can learn our birds better if you do. Thanks in advance.
This is bird no. 1 Western Tanager-male.
Bird no. 2-Immature Red Tail Hawk.
Bird no. 3 Stellar's Jay, taken very near Big Dan's old cabin on POW 2006 Dan not only knows birds, but each bird I guess. Ha Ha
Bird no. 4 Adult Red Tail Hawk.
First bird Western Tanager Bird #2 Goshawk is my guess
Bird no. 5 American Kestrel
wilbur bingo on the western tanager (its the male) but 2nd is not a goshawk.
Bird no. 6 Yellow Rump Wabler
Don;t know my western birds to much . . . so not sure of bird 1. - maybe Western tanger??? Bird 2 apprears to be a Red-tailed hawk.
Michael
Bird no. 7 Western Screech Owl.
Bird 5. - American kestrel . . .
Michael
Bird no. 8 Sage Thrasher.
Bird no. 9 Western Scrub Jay.
Bird no. 10 Sage Sparrow.
Bird no 2 is an immature red tail hawk. Good job string maker.
If any of you have some bird photos and want to post them and have Bowsiters ID them please feel free to do so. Then we can all learn a bit more about birds.
I have to run now but will check back in later. And thanks to all who respond.
Have a great bow hunt. BB
#9 indigo bunting? 5 is a kestrel. 4 a retail hawk. 7 great horned owl. My best guesses.
1. Western tanager
2. Swainson's hawk
3. Stellar's jay
4. Red-tail hawk
5. American kestrel
6. Golden winged warbler
without consulting Sibley's. 1 western tanager 2Coopers hawk (haven't really learned raptors) 3 Stellars jay 4 red tail 5 Kestrel 6 Audubon warbler 7 great horned 8 Thrasher sp. would prefer side of head view- Mocking bird. 9 scrub jay 10 Canyon wren.
Great photo's, I think birds are the most difficult to capture, especially small ones.
patdel, no on no. 9, it not an indigo bunting. 5 is a American Kestrel, and 4 is a mature red tail hawk. 7 is not a great horned owl.
Zeik you right on 1, 3, 4, 5, but wrong on 2 and 6.
I have to run but will check in later. Again thanks for participating.
Have a great bow hunt. BB
7. Western screech owl
8. ?
9. Mountain blue bird
10. ?
Before I run I will make one final post. No. 1 has been correctly ID as a Western Tanager (it's a male, the female is much different.)
No. 2 correctly ID as a Red tail hawk (its immature)
No. 3 correctly ID as a Stellar's Jay
No. 4 Correctly ID as a mature Red Tail Hawk.
No. 5 Correctly ID as an American Kestrel.
No. 6, no correct ID on those birds yet.
No. 7 Correctly ID as a Western Screech Owl.
No. 8 is a Thrasher, but what kind?
No 9 Correctly ID as a Western Scrub Jay.
No. 10 no correct ID yet.
And here's a side view of the Thrasher, Bird no. 8.
Is #10 some type of Junco? My guess without consulting my books.
Z2 is an American Coot. I had one on my door step last spring. Crazy deal.
I love this thread! I'm glad I'm not the only one who brings a bird book in my pack.
Bird number 3 is an Alaskan Steller Jay from POW Island
#8 is a sage thrasher, Z3 is the northern flicker....
Edited after consultation! Ha!
Z2 is a coot, and Z3 a northern flicker.
Here's a close up of Z1.
Z1. Nope.
Z4. Here's a strange one. Found dead on top of a ridge in the northern CO front range. No idea how it got there.
Bird 8. Sage thrasher.
Michael
Bill:
#6. Yellow rumped warbler
#8. Sage Thrasher
??
10#. Sparrows are tough, and I had to look - but knowing your affinity for the prairie I'm going with Sage Sparrow?
Z1 Sharp Shinned Hawk
Z4 looks like a Western Grebe
#10 is a sage sparrow...I think
Those ain't my birds so I didn't recognize many of them. The split tail hawk that ziek posted is a bird I have seen lately and a newcomer to out area. We didn't have geese until 5 years ago and now I hear some almost every morning.
#6 - Tazmanian Monkey Bird
I went back and after they were correctly ID ed I placed their name after their photo number. I will do the same and ask the others who post bird photos to do the same once correctly ID.
Here's No. 11 Chipping Sparrow
No. 13 Female Western Tanager.
No. 15 Long Eared Owl.
Got to go walk my dog, but I will check in when I get back. Let's see if you some of you can get these last five correctly ID before I get back. BB
BB your bird quiz on Facebook helped pass the time in the turkey blind the other day with a fellow bowsiter. Keep em comin'.
Interesting thread,
Z4 - I would think it may have been dropped by a hawk or something - the reason I say that is, a good friend of mine was driving along and a squirrel came falling to earth right in front of his car - no trees, no nothing around - looked around and the only thing he saw was a hawk flying. Didn't mean to hi-jack thread - just idea.
11...rufous crowned sparrow
14...dark eyed junco
BB, still say #6 is Audubon's warbler, due to yellow throat latch.
"Yellow-rumped Warbler 5-6" (13-15 cm). Breeding male dull bluish above, streaked with black; breast and flanks blackish. Rump, crown, and small area at sides of breast yellow. Western male ("Audubon's Warbler") has yellow throat, large white patch in folded wing."- http://birds.audubon.org/birds/yellow-rumped-warbler
14 dark eyed junco 15 great horned owl 12 already named- Spotted towehee 11 chipping sparrow -?
13...pine warbler? That's a tough one, many of the warblers look very similar!
11. Chipping Sp? What time of the year did you take this photo?
13. Female Bullock's Oriole?
14. Dark-eyed Junco
15. Long-eared Owl
Mine should be a lot easier - my camera skills only allow pictures of large, slow birds...
PA1 (Northern MN) Great Gray Owl
PA2 (Northern MN) Spruce Grouse
Bad picture - but the posture should give this away...
PA3 (Nebraska) Upland Sandpiper
Wetter birds...
PA4 (CA coast) Heermann's Gull
Yell when you are tired of ocean birds.
PA5 (CA coast) Short-billed Dowitcher
PA6 (20 miles off of CA coast) Black-footed Albatross 84" wingspan
PA7 (CA coast) Black Oystercatcher
PA8 (CA coast) Caspian Tern
Bill - hurry back from your walk...
PA9 (CA coast) Sanderling
Outdoorsdude, you may well be right on Bird No.6. I always thought, once I checked it out that it was a Yellow Rumped Warbler. Can you find and post one of each so we can see the difference, if possible. I am no bird expert. Like I said I never really paid much attention until I started taking photos, then I gained a great interest, but old minds don't learn very fast or very often.
I want to thank all of you who are following and adding to this thread. When one is out, its pretty easy to see quite a few birds and it adds to our experience if we get to learn a bit about what we are seeing.
As of yet no one has got number 13. Here's a hint. Its the female of its species.
Amoebus thanks for contributing to this thread. That owl photo is fantastic. I love owls!
Ending up with easy ones...
PA10 (Central MN) Ring-billed Gull
PA 4 is a gull of some type, just don't know my gulls, or many shore birds.
BB - There is one species of Yellow-rumped Warbler. In the west, there is the Audubon's sub-species with the yellow throat and the Myrtle sub-species in pretty much in the rest of the country. Both of you are right.
PA11 - Cedar Waxwing
Bird no. 17 Northern Male Harrier sometime called a Marsh Hawk.
Bird no. 18 Great Horned Owl.
16...horned lark
PA11...cedar waxwing
Bird no. 19 Loggerhead Shrike.
Bird no. 20 Northern Mocking bird.
19...loggerhead shrike
13...Baltimore oriole..or Bullock's oriole
How about a female W. Tanager for #13? The bill is throwing me. Looks too big for a warbler. Looks a little longer than my picture of a W. Tanager.
PA6 is not a boobie (hehe).
PA10 isn't a California Gull. Close, but no red on the bill (if my pictures were as good/near as yours, it would be easier to see that).
I don't know the western birds, but #20 appears to be some type of mockingbird.
17 looks like a N Harrier.
18 is a wonderful picture. I think it is a GH Owl.
Bird no. 21 Vireo ( I was sitting in a tree stand some years back, and just happened to be holding my camera in my hands, after taking a deer photo. And this guy landed right in front of me. I had my camera up to my eye, just getting ready to look at the deer photo I had just take. So I just pointed my camera and shuttered it, but when the shudder cleared the bird was gone. I thought I had missed it. But that was the photo I got. Its the only time I have ever seen one of these birds in our area. It took my a long time to find out it was a Vireo and I still don't know what kind. If anyone can shed light, please do.
Bird no. 22 Northern Flicker (woodpecker)
Bird no. 25 Gray Jay ( many call them a Camp Robber)
Thanks for starting this thread, BB! Great pics!
Last summer, I had a trail cam out in hopes of getting deer pics, but I mostly got a bunch of "accidental bird pics" instead. It was amazing how many different species perched on the very strand of barbed wire right next to the camera even though that fence is about 3/4 of a mile long. They are trail cam quality instead of the professional type shots in this thread, but are pretty cool nonetheless. If only the camera had been turned just a bit more to the left . . .
Here's a link to those pics: Accidental Bird Pics Link
Greg - that was a neat camera angle. I identified 14 species and could narrow down 2 others to 'Flycatcher sp' and 'Finch sp'. (In no particular order: American Goldfinch, Female Grosbeak - Rose-breasted?, Northern Flicker, Baltimore Oriole, Northern Cardinal, Eastern Bluebird, Common Yellowthroat, Gray Catbird, Eastern Kingbird, House Wren, European Starling, Loggerhead Shrike, Eastern Phoebe, Song Sparrow, Cow Butt.) I could tell you are in the midwest because all those birds are summer birds in MN also.
BB - 21 still has me working. 22-25 are best left so someone else can play. 25 actually took me way too long since we have those in MN also. All I could think about was a aging Chickadee with a receding hairline. It is hard to estimate size because your bird pictures actually fill up the screen...
24 looks like what we always called a killdeer when we were kids.
22 is a Flicker (type of woodpecker), likely the western variety...
23 is a chucker...
Yep, 24 is a killdeer
Your "Bird no. 5 American Kestrel" is a female, and your Z1 is a Sharp Shinned Hawk, what some refer to as Shinny Hawks...
Greg Kush, thanks very much for posting that link. It is very interesting to see so many different birds land in exactly that same spot. There is a reason they did that. Did you ever find out why? It would be interesting to know.
Again thanks for the great post. BB
Bird no. 26 Red-Breasted Nuthatch
Bird no. 27 Yellow-headed Black Bird
Bird no. 29 Clark's Nutcracker
Bird no. 30 Sage Grouse (spring time at lek strutting)
26...Red-Breasted Nuthatch 27...Yellowheaded blackbird 28....Starling 30....Sage grouse
PA2...ruffed grouse?
Bill, here is a couple to add "know your birds"
Common Merganser Paul?
Thanks for posting these guys, one of my favorite threads. After seeing this I'm going to make a conscious effort to photograph more birds in the woods this year.
Paul #2...Harris Hawk
Paul #4...Scaled quail?
Paul;
Caracara
Avocet
Western Grebe
Bird 25. Gray jay Bird 29. Blue Gray tanager . . . maybe, it's the only bird I could come up with.
Paul - this is a family forum!
PA2 - not a ruffed grouse.
28 is a Starling...
Paul's first raptor is a Harris Hawk, the one after is an African raptor, but can't remember the name, but I know it begins with a "C". They spend a lot of time on the ground....
Boy, you guys have been busy while I was gone.
Z4 is a western grebe, and I also figured it was dropped by a hawk or eagle.
No one got Z1 yet. It's a merlin.
BB Number 21- some flavor of Vireo (Philadephia?). Number 25 - Gray/Canada Jay Number 26 - Red breasted Nuthatch Number 27 - Yellow headed Blackbird Number 28 - Starling Number 29 - Clark's Nutcracker (not positive on that one) Number 30 - Sage Grouse
Oops, had to look at Z1 a little better... It is a Merlin, or Hobby, a smallish falcon... Merlin native to North America, and Hobby native to Europe/Asia... Basically same raptor, different locations, popular with some falconers...
Z7. White-tailed Ptarmigan.
I'll try some of the PA ones: PA1 - Great Gray Owl PA2 - Spruce Grouse PA3 - Upland Plover PA6 - Skua PA7 - Oystercatcher PA8 - Caspian tern
Paul, thanks for playing. I love your hawk photo. That is great and they are neat birds. BB
Bird no. 32 House Sparrow
Don't mean to hog all the names, but BB 31 is one I saw this morning at our place. Pine Grosbeak
Bird no. 33 Female Northern Harrier (female Marsh Hawk)
Big Foot it might look like a Pine Grosbeak, but its something else.
31..house finch? 32...house sparrow
Bird no. 34 Western Meadow Lark (Wyoming State Bird) (go Pokes)
Z9. Light color-phase red-tailed hawk.
Bigfoot - PA6 is not a Skua, but you are getting very close! The rest are good.
Think bigger. Think Monty Python!
34. meadowlark
35. mourning dove
Bird no. 36 Ruffed Grouse
Z6 - Red-crested Cardinal
Bird no. 37 Mountain Blue Bird
34 meadow lark, western? -can only tell by voice.
Bird no. 38 Immature Cooper's Hawk. They look a lot like a Sharp-shinned Hawk at this age.
Bird no. 39 Robin's nest, eggs and hatchlings.
Bird no. 40 Long-billed Curlew
Amoebus - correct. Also called a southern cardinal.
37. mountain bluebird.
PA6...immature Albatross?
39....Robin
40...Curlew
Number 31 - got it wrong! Well darn! Should have looked closer. I've got guesses on a number of the others, but I'll let someone else play a little.
Z10 - tricky one. The mark a Mourning dove made when it hit a window at cruising speed.
Z69 - Double Breasted Matress Thrasher or DBMT
Try PA6 again - Albatross BB 33 Female Northern Harrier BB 36 Ruffed Grouse BB 38 Cooper's Hawk (bit of a guess here - one of two I think and I am leaning towards the Cooper's)
Z8 looks like a Hungarian partridge
BB 33 is definitely NOT a Goshawk, not enough visible to tell for sure, but I'm guessing as Bigfoot, some species of harrier or kite...
BB Bird no. 38, IS definitely a immature Coopers Hawk.... Goshawks, Coopers and Shinnies are Accipiters, (genus or type of hawk)...
Z9 looks like am immature Red Tail to me, but again, not enough exposed, but its definitely a broad wing buteo, if not young Red Tail, maybe a Ferruginous or Rough-legged hawk...
z10 dusty-headache side-flyer
BB...is 33 a female Harrier?
I took the Crested Caracara picture when I was hunting in northern Mexico.
This bird is the Mexican National Bird.
BB, great thread and pictures.
Here is my last one titled, "what's for dinner".
My best, Paul
BB21 Looks like a Warbling Vireo. Most of the Vireos are slower movers and snatch bugs from the tree-tops. Best identification is hearing them.
NO Comments on the DBMT? Man you guys are serious about your birds.
When I was a kid we raised an American Kestrel that fell from a nest in a storm. Ate all sorts of raw meat like crazy. Amazing how much he could eat. Let him go when he could fly. He stayed around for a while.
Paul@thefort, thanks for your nice photos and participation.
A couple of years ago I was in an antelope blind and had been taking photos of a cottontail rabbit. It got a bit too far from the blind, so I quit taking photos and just began to look for antelope out a different peak hole. When I looked back, to where I last saw the rabbit, here is what I saw.
I took a few more photos of this female Northern Harrier and she did not like the shutter noise at all.
She soon took off, carrying a small piece of the rabbit with her. This is a poor photo but shows the white ring behind her butt on her tail feathers. Its one of the ways you can identify one in flight.
And she had no more than left when this scavenger came to share in the feast.
Bird No. 41 Magpie (Lost Elk Finder)
Bird No. 43 Vesper Sparrow
Bird No. 45 Brewer's Blackbird
44 is definitely a type of sandpiper in my opinion. A stilt sandpiper seems likely.
#43 Vesper Sparrow (I should add that it is similar to a Lincoln Sparrow, but there is no yellowing on the breast. Also superficially similar to a Savannah Sparrow, but it has a stronger eye-ring and no coloring in the streaks on the breast. A lot of the sparrows are really distinctive when you hear the call.)
#44 Willet - Was this a pretty tall bird - 14"? When it flew, did it have strong white/black coloring on the wings?
Edit: Brotsky - When I look at BB's pictures, I find it hard to get a relative size because they all fill up the entire screen. Stilt Sandpiper is pretty close to the picture, but it usually has a much more spotted belly than the Willet and the bill is noticably thinner. If you saw them together, there would be no mistaking them. The Willet would be a tank and the Stilt would be the mini-van.
Paul, your last one looks like is a Sharp Shinned (Shinny Hawk) by the size of the bird it is eating. Either a Shinny or a small male Coopers, but it's definitely a Accipter, or what falconers call short wing hawks...
BB bird 41 is a Magpie, 42 a Bald Eagle, and 45 a Grackle...
Being sort of a birder, and messing around with falconry as a younger man, I know raptors pretty good and upland gamebirds, but a lot of the little tweedy birds I'm not sure the names, or how to identify those closely related.... Some birds are closely related, yet different species or subspecies, although some of the hard core birders may be able to identify....
We had a yellow colored tweedy bird desperately trying to get in the house a couple springs ago and I'd never seen one before (that I can remember). But anyhow, it was very pretty and had a pretty song, yet I wasn't ever able to identify it via books and internet... It hung around a couple days, then disappeared never to return, and haven't seen one like it since....
I updated some of my gulls and shorebirds above. They are tough.
For Gulls, I have to get a good look at the bill for colors and spots. Some gulls are hooded and leg color is important.
For Shorebirds, I need to need to divide them into small, medium and large. The bill length and curve then further differentiates them. The 'peeps' (small shorebirds) are VERY tough without a spotting scope.
Both Sparrows and Warblers too small to regularly identify visually without binoculars. The best way for both is to learn their calls.
BB; Super pics, thanks for sharing! The backlit meadow lark is really cool. You should come to the arctic in July where I guide fishermen. Amazing amount of birds (many rarely seen) and other wildlife, 24 hour daylight, "golden" dawn and dusk lasts about 2 hours each. I've taken hundreds of critter photos right in camp. You'd have a blast and fill some memory cards. Keep the pics coming, great work.
Rob - Baby Ptarmigan? I'm guessing Rock Ptarmigan?
Speaking of birds, checked my Bluebird nest boxes yesterday (I have 5 nest boxes out) and found one active with 5 eggs in it... Also have a Robin incubating eggs for the fifth day now on my bathroom window sill. She's annual, been nesting on that window sill the past 5 years... I assume it's the same bird, but don't know.... Every year I remove the nest after they fledge and every spring they build a new... It's amazing how quickly they build a next, less than two days...
One year I had 3 active Robin nests on my little acre and half of paradise. The annual one on bathroom window sill, another one on a window sill on the other side of the house, and another in a shrub bush up the hill. Had baby Robins bouncing around everywhere, except hard to keep the neighbors cats from killing them...
Currently all together, I have 1 squirrel nestbox (always active), 1 screech owl nestbox (grey squirrels have taken it over), one Kestrel nestbox (Starlings have taken it over), a bat box (never been active) 5 Eastern Bluebird nestboxes, (1 active), and half a dozen or so wren boxes, which usually all are annually active.... Been a bunch of baby wrens come from my yard...
Shortly after I took the chick pic Momma flew in and came right after me. She looked mighty proud when she scared me away fom her babies.
Curious Rob - Is that Rock, Willow, or White-tailed? I don't know how to identify the difference. The only one I know were the Whitetailed Ptarmigan in the mountains of Colorado...
41 unofficial name, 'lost elk finder'
Zbone, I really think no. 45 is a Brewer's Blackbird. They look a lot like a Grackle but are smaller. Here's the female of bird 45 if that will help any.
Rob Nye, that sounds like I would be in heaven up there. Thanks for your contribution and kind words. BB
Bird no. 47 Vesper Sparrow
Bird no. 48 Osprey (The fish eagle)
Bird no. 50 American Avocet
Some incredible pictures in this thread.
Although we have already IDed this bird as a Great Horned Owl, I thought I would just post it for those that like to look at photos. I have hundred of photos of Great Horned Owls, but this is one of my very favorites. I hope others will like it too. BB
46- Raven
47- Sage Sparrow
48- Osprey
49- Red Tailed Hawk
50- Avocet
Rob - where were you when you took the ptarmigan pictures?
The picture of the adult looks like a dude to me. If you look closely, you can see an orange stripe above the eyes. None of the females have this.
I was curious when you said that she flew in to scare you off. I found this blurb in the Sibley Guide to Bird Life and Behavior:
'Ptarmigan tend to be monogamous, forming a pair bond prior to copulation and maintaining it through the nesting cycle. During this period, males watch for predators while females forage.'
Besides thinking it is a male, I don't have a good guess as to what kind it is. I have looked for the White-tailed in CO about 10 times and haven't found one (yet).
Amoebus, you seem to know your birds very well and have the ability to check things out. elkmtngear thinks 47 is a sage sparrow, but I think its a different kind of sparrow. What's your take on that bird? Again thanks to all of you for your contributions in guessing and or posting birds.
Have a great bow hunt. BB
Bird no. 51 Swainson's Hawk (Dark Morph)
Bird no. 52 Ferruginous Hawk
Bird no. 53 Red Tail Hawk
Bird no. 55 Immature Western Meadow Lark
Yeah BB, I'll go along with 45 being a Brewer's Blackbird, (not familiar with them) if other photo is that of the female... If I remember correctly, both sexes of Grackles have yellowish colored eyes, with the males being brighter....
I concur with elkmtngear on:
46- Raven
48- Osprey
49- Red Tailed Hawk
51 is some sort of a kite. Am not up on the species though...
52 and 53 is likely either Ferruginous or Rough-legged hawk depending on the size...
54 is a Goshawk... They're bad mofo's...
BB - I have actually looked at this one quite a while. I can narrow it down, but am not sure. First off, here are the sparrows that are regularly in WY:
Sage|American Tree|Brewers|Clay-colored|Chipping|Grasshopper|Savannah|Vesper|Lark|Harris|White-throated|White-crowned|Fox|Song|Lincoln
The ones that can be quickly eliminated are Am Tree (only in winter), Clay-colored (no breast streaking, stronger white stripe above eye), Chipping (red cap, no streaking, black eye bar), Grasshopper (rufous on back, buffy yellow on breast), Lark (red on cheek, no streaking), Harris (black on face, breast), WT & WC (white patches on throat or head), Fox (red on back & breast streaking), Song (not a strong white eye ring and strong belly streaking) and Lincoln (buffy yellow on throat/breast).
Remaining:
Sage|Brewers|Savannah|Vesper
It doesn't look like an adult Sage, but the juvenile (May-Aug) doesn't show the strong dark cheeks and throat stripe. The juvenile also shows a lot of breast streaking. My guess is it isn't a Sage.
The Savannah in all ages show more breast streaking and darker crown. Also, they don't seem to have a strong of white eye-ring as your picture. Probably not a Savannah.
Both the Brewer's and Vesper have strong white eye rings. The adult Brewer's doesn't have breast streaking, but the juvenile does. The female adult Vesper has a lot of coloring similar to your picture.
To make things more complicated, each bird can have individual slight differences in coloring and patterns. Also, the colors soon after their spring molt will be brighter than after a couple of months of wear/tear.
So, I think I would narrow it down to those Brewer's or Vesper, but could be argued into a young Sage or Savannah. I think its call would have to be the determining factor.
What do you think it is?
BB - where did you take #51? The only Kite that looks similar is the Mississippi Kite and it doesn't have the yellow at the base of the bill.
There is a Gray Hawk that has the yellow base of the bill but is usually south of you. Do you have any pictures of the tail for that bird?
I am also impressed by Zbone and the other hawk experts. We have mainly RT Hawk here in MN and I have seen them from almost all white to black - well, belly anyway.
As others have mentioned, this is a wonderful way to spend a slow part of the hunting season for me. Save some for next year. I might have to dust off the camera and see if I can get a shot or two of warblers.
Amoebus, Great analysis on the sparrow. They can be tough and knowing size and hearing the call can both be critical parts of identifying. My initial thought is as yours - either a Brewer's or Vesper, with leaning towards a Vesper. If I had my bird books handy I might be able to make a better determination, but I've enjoyed trying to label all the pictures without any help (so far).
Hawks are another tough one in pictures, as size can be important. Also, there can be many color variations within each species which makes it even more challenging. Having said that here are my latest guesses: Number 51: Harris' Hawk (a total guess as I am not familar with that one, but the name comes to mind when looking at it) Number 52: Rough-legged Hawk Number 53: Redtailed Hawk Number 54: Goshawk
Missed number 55! Looks like an immature Western Meadowlark.
Amoebus: willow ptarmigan I believe, Thelon Game sanctuary, Nunavut. Here is a shot of 2 males and 2 females, I will crop the pic to show them better. I think the females also have some red above their eyes. Lots of them living in the camp.
Same pic of ptarmigan cropped.
I wouldn't know the difference between Willow, Rock or Whitetail Ptarmigan... May have to do with distribution, but I believe there are areas where they overlap. If that's the case, wonder if or could interbreed?
Bird 51's photo was taken near Hennifer, Utah which is on the highway between Ogden, Utah and Evanston, Wyoming.
I personally don't believe bird 49 is a red tail, but rather the same kind of hawk as bird 51 with just a different morph. Both photos taken in Utah.
I took this photo just yesterday. Look close and you can see what yellow-headed black birds like to eat.
Have a great bow hunt. BB
Boy, I don’t know BB… Red Tails come in a lot of different color phases but that grey #51 sure looks like a kite to me…. What species, I wouldn’t know, but viewed in flight would identify, for kites have long thin shaped wings but Buteos such as Red Tails have broad wings…
I think #49 is a pretty color phase Red Tail though… He’s just fluffed up to keep warm, giving him a different appearance…8^) When I get a chance, I’ll post a pic I took of a Red Tail long distance with my cell phone…
Question – Is 52 and 53 the same bird?
That last picture, I’m gonna say is some species of blackbird. Which species, I couldn't say, but looks similar in shape and similar colors to a Baltimore Oriole which is a species of Blackbird…. I know it’s not and oriole, just saying looks similar…
Keep’m coming, I enjoy…
No right guess on 51 and 52 yet. Took a stab at 51, but a guess at best. Another guess - maybe a dark phase Swainson's Hawk? Harlan's Hawk is also another name that comes to mind - but, again, a total guess as I've never seen one. Just a name that pops in my head when looking at the photo.
Thought 52 was a Rough-legged hawk, based on the color band on the breast. As that wasn't right, I will venture another guess of a Ferruginous Hawk. Hard to tell at that angle, but that would be my next best guess.
Nice to see all the pictures - terrific pictures too. Hope you keep them coming. We haven't seen many migrants yet where I am at (Canada). Snowing pretty hard here today - end of April and we have a snowfall warning! Sooner or later Spring might come!
I also think 49 is a Swainson's Hawk, typical morph, but that is strictly a guess. Almost 40 years ago, there was a little neighbor boy who played in my yard all the time and chased and tired to catch every bird he saw. He's a man now, and really knows his birds and especially his hawks. He lives in Montana and I only see him once or so a year, when he comes to visit his folks, who still live down the street. I will contact him, if I can and find out what type of hawk he thinks bird 49 would be.
Its the weekend and the wife and I clean the house on Saturday's. so I better get cleaning, but will try to add a few more birds later today.
Just to add a photo, I will post this bald eagle, whose photo I took last winter.
Have a great bow hunt. BB
Sat next to a woman on an airplane years ago that was a birding expert for sure. She could identify over 200 different bird species by their singing! Amazing feat! Makes me feel very limited in my understanding of nature! Thanks as always for posting! C
I'm still thinking 49 is Red Tail...
Pulled these off the internet...
You guys might be right with 51 being a dark phased Swainson's... Haven't ever seen that color phase before until I looked it up.... Good stuff...
BB..........Really Neat Thread! Kinda ironic, as a sat this AM while Spring Gobbler Hunting, and studied a Pileated Woodpecker, or as we mountain folks in Virginia call them, "Wood-Hen". Hadn't even seen this thread, but for some unknown reason I took the time to just sit there and watch the bird blister an old rotted tree in search of his/her breakfast! And the Naysayers say hunting is a Bloodthirsty sport! Anyway your picture of the Robins nest/eggs reminds me of an old 56' Chevrolet....Robin egg Blue over Cream! Great Idea, I have enjoyed looking at the pictures.
PS: Anybody got a picture of a Canadian Whiskey-Jack as I love to watch these birds come to the bait barrels while Spring Bear Hunting.
PA12 (MN Fall) Juvenile Ruby-throated Hummingbird
The hint below about seeing a Hummingbird in MN narrows it considerably because we have ONE regular Hummer. You guys in the West are lucky (for Hummers, not Warblers). Interesting that the adult Ruby-throats raise the young and then migrate leaving (mainly) only juveniles for a month.
PA13 (MN May) Golden-crowned Kinglet
PA14 (MN May) Ruby-crowned Kinglet
PA15 (MN Winter) American Robin
This one was easy, but I will always find some Robins that overwinter here in MN - even in the coldest weather. As long as there is some open, running water over mud, they will survive on berries and worms?
PA16 (CA Coast) Western Gull.
PA17 (CA Coast) Hopefully a little closer... Western Gull
st8tman See BB25 for a picture of a Whiskey Jack (aka Canada Jay/Gray Jay) PA13 Golden Crowned Sparrow PA14 Ruby crowned Kinglet PA14 (15) American Robin I'll let someone else take a stab at PA12. I have a guess, but not certain.
PA18 (CA Coast) Ruddy Turnstone
PA19 (CA Coast) Turkey Vulture feeding on seal.
Bigfoot PA13 - We don't have GC Sparrows here in MN. The rest are good. The Hummer location is a good hint also.
PA13 Interesting - I'm curious to know what it is but I have no other guesses on that one. I'll let someone else try.
PA19 is what we call a Buzzard here in Ohio...8^)
I know, I know, its a turkey vulture, and termed Buzzard here, when they call a bird of prey much like our red tails over in England/Europe/Asia a Buzzard... Kinda like them calling a moose an elk,,, go figure...8^)
Many here also term Kestrels, as sparrow hawks, which is inaccurate for they a truly a small falcon, and a sparrow hawk is much like our Cooper/Shinny hawks over in the old countries...
Amoebus - You post some hard ones... I know PA12 is a species of hummingbird, and go out on a limb and say juvenile, Ruby Breasted....
Since we don't have many around, never could distinguish the difference in gulls, nor shorebirds, but those little tweedy birds look familiar, just never knew what they were called.... Thanx
Bird no. 56 Sandhill Crane.
PA16-17 - Not really up on gulls, but the only one that comes to mind with the red dot on the bill is the California gull, but I know there are lots of other species that I am not familar with. PA19 - Ruddy Turnstone BB 56 - Sandhill Crane Still curious to know about BB52 and PA13
Bigfoot - PA16-17; good guess, but no. I will try to get a better picture of PA13. The yellow cap usually appears wider on the head - this picture seems a little narrow.
Bigfoot I took that photo after the hawk flew off a rock outcropping. I have one of it sitting on the rocks, just before it flew. I will try to find that tomorrow and post it. I do know what hawk it is. Its really hard to tell a lot of hawks when they are flying and especially in small photos like that.
Here's another shot of Bird no. 52. Perhaps this will help a bit more.
And one more in flight of bird no 52.
Might have to change this to BIRDSITE.com
56....ribeye of the sky! Sandhill crane. I saw two whooping cranes last fall in the area I hunt. Only the 3rd pait of whoopers I've seen in my lifetime. Wish I would have had a camera!
number 56: Sandhill crane. I see 8-10 of them as I drive to and from work in the spring and early summer...
Still guess BB52 as either a Ferruginous or Rough-legged hawk depending on the size. (Ferruginous are huge) Notice the feathering down to the feet, it doesn't look huge, so guess Rough-legged hawk ...
Amoebus - PA13 is a tweedy bird...8^)
This is some super photography. Very interesting thread. BB you have been at the right place and the right time- lots of times. Nicely done.
Bird no. 57. Golden Eagle (Jeff that didn't take long.)
57- Golden Eagle...magnificent!
Work has made it tough to post the past couple of days. Still drawing a blank on BB52, aside from my guesses of a Roughlegged or Ferruginous. My bird books would help, but that would be cheating, so I'll wait to see if someone else can put up a guess.
Edit: My buddy just looked at it and figures it is a Toronto Raptor!
Say! That #58 looks like a Phoebe - 8^)
PA20 (MN May) Chipping Sparrow
PA21 (MN May) - Bad picture, but should be do-able. Swamp Sparrow
PA22 (MN May) Song Sparrow
PA23 (MN May) White-throated Sparrow
PA24 (MN May) American White Pelican
PA25 (MN May) Broad-winged Hawk
PA26 (MN May) - BB this is for you - Yellow-rumped Warbler (Myrtle)
BB - you are right. I mentioned somewhere in this thread that western version of the Yellow-rumped (Audubon) has the bright yellow throat. The Eastern version (Myrtle) has the white throat.
PA27-A (MN May) Same bird as PA27-B. Hermit Thrush
PA27-B (MN May) Hermit Thrush
PA27-C (MN May) Hermit Thrush
Amoebus I would still say that PA26 is a Yellow-rumped Warbler .
Bird no. 59. Great Blue Heron
BB#59 - Great Blue Heron.... There is a rookery about 5 miles from where I sit right now in Ohio's only national park. Drove by there the other day and there and herons nesting everywhere. Next time I'm by, will try to take a picture...
Amoebus - Would have to get a better look at the head and back of your PA25 flying raptor, but it is not an eagle, falcon, vulture, kite or harrier, but the silhouette is that of the classic soaring broadwing or Buteo's type hawk. As said before, raptors come in different color phases, so it is hard to tell without a better look, but it is definitely not a Red Tail...
BTW... Here is a picture of the window sill Robin’s nest taken through my bathroom window back on April 24th... I keep a piece of cardboard up on the inside of the window to keep from disturbing but I checked yesterday evening and a couple of the eggs have now hatched.
I was out taking photos the other day and ran into an interesting situation. At least I thought it was.
A pair of Flickers had made a nest in an old oil barrel. Since we have already done that bird, I won't post pictures for identification, but here's a couple of the the photos I took. I thought it was quite unique where they chose to nest.
The male went inside the barrel and could hardly make it. Here's a photo I took as he tried to come out!
Have a great bow hunt. BB
Bird no. 60 White Crowned Sparrow
The End!
Have a great bow hunt. BB
BB#60 is a tweedy bird...8^)))
Its been fun BB, thanx for sharing....
NOOOOOoooooooo! Please take a lot of pictures next year, BB and start this again when winter has worn out its welcome.
Better yet, come to MN for the next 3 weeks and you will become a warbler expert.
I will update my last pictures in case anyone wants to learn the LBJs (Little Brown Jobs).
BB60 looks like a White-crowned Sparrow.
Thanks for posting the pics. Great pics and enjoyed flexing my birding 'muscles'. Bill - you have an ID on #52?
Last time I posted on Friday, check to Robin's next that evening and baby birds and eggs were gone... Suspect blujays or crows got them...8^(
Bigfoot, 52 is a Ferruginous Hawk.
Thanks to everyone who participated. Hopefully a few of us learned a bit about some birds we had seen but didn't know its name.
It would be good for someone to start a thread on vegetation that the critter we hunt eat, along with a photo of each so we can find out some of their favorite foods. I know hunting mule deer and bear, and elk, can be far more successful if you learn what they eat and where its at.
Have a great bow hunt. BB
Photo taken today, any guess...8^)
Here is the photo I spoke of earlier that was taken November 4, 2013... It's the white spot near the center of the photo. It hung around the area for about a week...