Help with score, please
Contributors to this thread:Whitetail Deer
From: wvbowbender
21-Sep-16
I'm not good at scoring, so I need your help!
From: wvbowbender
22-Sep-16
ttt
From: Sage Buffalo
22-Sep-16
My Guess = 135
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
Very difficult answer with that pic. I bet he's 135 (I shot one very similar) but could be a bit bigger.
That pic is very deceiving.
From: Pyrannah
22-Sep-16
My Guess = 140
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
From: TC
22-Sep-16
My Guess = 135
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
Weak spread.
From: wvbowbender
22-Sep-16
Another angle
From: pawpaw
22-Sep-16
May hit 140 ... still not a great pic to judge
From: wvbowbender
22-Sep-16
Another pic
From: Medicinemann
23-Sep-16
Pretty buck. Tines are almost touching.
From: Shawn
23-Sep-16
My Guess = 144
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
He is not wide but good tine length and pretty good mass. I would say 140 all day and like my guess a bit higher!! Shawn
From: sticksender
23-Sep-16
My Guess = 166
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
brows 5.5
2nds 10
3rds 12.5
4ths 7
beams 23
circs 17
2nds 10
3rds 12.5
4ths 7
beams 23
circs 17
Gross per side 75
spread 16
Gross frame = 166
These guesses may be a little low.
Kill him and let us know.
From: HerdManager
23-Sep-16
My Guess = 155
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
From: stick33
23-Sep-16
My Guess = 158
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
Spread is the only thing that hurts him. Tines are long... 155"+ Easy.
From: pawpaw
23-Sep-16
I will go with the 155 to 160 now. I thought he was an 8. He is definitely a shooter no matter the score.
From: Jack Harris
23-Sep-16
My Guess = 154
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
154 on the buck and $275 for the feeder? That's a solid 10, with mass beam and tine length - so what if he's not 22" wide he is 16" wide so instead of 160 he is 154... The beam length sweeping around and in make up for the more narrow spread.
From: bowmex
23-Sep-16
My Guess = 155
Average Guess = 148
Average Guess = 148
From: wvbowbender
26-Sep-16
Update on this deer. I hunted him the 24th, first day, he came in just like clock work, right at daylight. I had to watch him for 10 to 15 minutes until it was light enough and/or he would give me the angle I needed. Things were going perfect, until I took the shot (uhg) I was sitting down when I shot and my bow string hit left pant leg, putting the shot right over his back. He just ran off, hopefully not forever. This is the biggest deer I've ever hunted, so I'm praying for a better result the next time? Thanks for all the answers on the score. Bob
