Bowsite.com on Facebook
  • Deerbuilder Food Plot Website
  • Trail Cam Photos
  • Bowsite.com Elk Section
  • Mathews Solocam
Summit Treestands Mathews Solocam Carbon Express Arrows Moultrie Game Cameras Sitka Gear LaCrosee Footwear 3RiversArchery
Whitetail Deer Section Elk Section Black, Brown, & Polar Bear Section Moose Section Mule Deer Section Sheep Section Bowfishing Section Mountain Goat Section Pronghorn Section Mountain Lion Section Wild Turkey Section Caribou Section Hogs & Exotics Section Small Game Forum Africa Section Food Plots on DeerBuilder.com Bowhunting / Archery Equipment

Antler repair vote yes or no

PRINTABLE VERSION

EMAIL TO A FRIEND

Messages posted to thread:
droptine101 16-Mar-10
mrelite 16-Mar-10
crazymaez 16-Mar-10
city hunter 16-Mar-10
GAFFER1 16-Mar-10
Fields 16-Mar-10
arctichill 16-Mar-10
TURKEY STALKER 16-Mar-10
midwest 16-Mar-10
Ty 16-Mar-10
Candor 16-Mar-10
INbowdude 16-Mar-10
Trapper 16-Mar-10
Kodi 16-Mar-10
Bigdan 16-Mar-10
bow assassin 16-Mar-10
Spanky 16-Mar-10
guidermd 16-Mar-10
Gold Miner 16-Mar-10
4W 16-Mar-10
Matt 16-Mar-10
JUSTHUNT1 16-Mar-10
13 points 17-Mar-10
arctichill 17-Mar-10
13 points 17-Mar-10
Earl E. Nove....mber 17-Mar-10
DorityCrk 17-Mar-10
4406v 17-Mar-10
Davy C 17-Mar-10
Pat Lefemine 17-Mar-10
rooster 17-Mar-10
T Mac 17-Mar-10
hoytcountry 17-Mar-10
carbonarcher 17-Mar-10
Foodplot 17-Mar-10
Northwoods 17-Mar-10
The Old Sarge 17-Mar-10
Buffalo 17-Mar-10
Elkhunter - Home 17-Mar-10
longhunter 17-Mar-10
Show-Me Greg 17-Mar-10
Grunt-N-Gobble 17-Mar-10
acornhollow 17-Mar-10
Ben Farmer 17-Mar-10
wilhille 17-Mar-10
TKrets 17-Mar-10
Bou'bound 17-Mar-10
dbboss2 17-Mar-10
TREESTANDWOLF 17-Mar-10
longboman 17-Mar-10
tonyo6302 17-Mar-10
BO-N-ARO 17-Mar-10
Ryanw 17-Mar-10
droptine101 17-Mar-10
droptine101 17-Mar-10
droptine101 17-Mar-10
droptine101 17-Mar-10
Big Lefty 17-Mar-10
LKH 18-Mar-10
arctichill 18-Mar-10
writer 18-Mar-10
MaBow 18-Mar-10
B4LITE 18-Mar-10
Ki-Ke 18-Mar-10
tcosmic 18-Mar-10
tcosmic 18-Mar-10
archer 18-Mar-10
Adventurewriter 18-Mar-10
HerdManager 18-Mar-10
CAS_HNTR@UC 18-Mar-10
gobbler 18-Mar-10
TheIceman 21-Mar-10
4406v 22-Mar-10
Videos

CT 9 pt
by nehunter


Opening Day Bow Kill!
by Catchdog


Big Buck Hit List
by TrophyPursuit


187inch Giant!
by TrophyPursuit


Put Your Video Clip Here!


From: droptine101 Date: 16-Mar-10
Would you repair broken tines?

From: mrelite Date: 16-Mar-10
No

From: crazymaez Date: 16-Mar-10
Depends if its a point yes.If its a main beam no.

From: city hunter Date: 16-Mar-10
no never ...

From: GAFFER1 Date: 16-Mar-10
I've glued a couple tines back on, but I would never reconstruct one.

From: Fields Date: 16-Mar-10
No

From: arctichill Date: 16-Mar-10
I think I would only repair it if it broke after I shot the animal. I personally like to preserve the animal the way it looked when I chose to harvest it.

From: TURKEY STALKER (mobile)Sent from Mobile Phone Date: 16-Mar-10
No

From: midwest Date: 16-Mar-10
Naw, it is what it is.

Wouldn't think anything less of someone who did, though. Personal choice.

From: Ty Date: 16-Mar-10
no

From: Candor Date: 16-Mar-10
Not for me. Can totally understand someone that wishes to do so though.

Now...if I shot a buck that busted his horn in a death run, I would probably repair it. The second deer I ever shot w/ a bow was a spike that ran into a tree and knocked both of his horns off. I'd of had a conniption if it happened with larger buck (though less likely).

From: INbowdude Date: 16-Mar-10
Nope unless the tine was broken when the deer was running after the shot.

From: Trapper Date: 16-Mar-10

Trapper's embedded Photo

Repaired one that broke last year after the shot with its original. I wouldn't have reconstructed though.

From: Kodi Date: 16-Mar-10
No I did once and taxi did a poor job anyways and it looks bad. Never again. personal choice.

From: Bigdan Date: 16-Mar-10
no

From: bow assassin Date: 16-Mar-10
had one fixed once about the last inch of the main beam broke.looks ok from a distance but up close you can tell because the color doesnt match very well.havent had another fixed after that.

From: Spanky Date: 16-Mar-10
YES!

From: guidermd Date: 16-Mar-10
repair never..............would i add 100 inches to a basket rack............anyday!!

From: Gold Miner Date: 16-Mar-10

Gold Miner's embedded Photo

I guess I will go against the grain here and say yes. I had a third pt fixed on a 6x6 bull that I wanted mounted up. It was broke but had the same diameter and shape as the other side. I figure the pt. was there at one time it just broke off. Just had it repaired to match the other side.

From: 4W Date: 16-Mar-10
NO

From: Matt Date: 16-Mar-10
I am in the extreme here, but I wouldn't repair a rack that was broken pre-harvest (post-harvest is a different story), nor would I mount an animal with a different cape or even inentionally strip velvet. Mount what you shot, and if you aren't happy with what you shot, you may as well buy it on Ebay as start swapping out parts after the fact.

From: JUSTHUNT1 Date: 16-Mar-10
I agree with Matt, although I had a set of sheds mounted on head, not an animal I hunted.

From: 13 points Date: 17-Mar-10

13 points's Supporting Link

Well, I guess I will be cursed by all of you....shot a buck in '07 and couldnt find it. Finally, 5 days later, we found him and he was all chewed up by coyotes.

He was a cool buck because his G2's were forked but one was broken.

Well, I decided to get another cape and had his point reconstructed. It was worth it to me.....can you tell which point was redone?

From: arctichill Date: 17-Mar-10
I think it was the 13th point. From now on you will be known around here as 12 points! JK Nice deer.

From: 13 points Date: 17-Mar-10
Thanks.........actually my handle is for how many elk points i have...hopefully, it will be reduced to 2 points in a couple of weeks......8*)

From: Earl E. Nove....mber Date: 17-Mar-10
It depends.. Is a mounted head a trophy of your accomplishments and a memory of the hunt? Probably not.

Is the mount a representation of Mother Nature's art work, such as a pair of sheds, a recovered winter kill etc.. Then probably yes, but never in such a manner as to enhance the score beyond what was originally there.

From: DorityCrk Date: 17-Mar-10
Yes, I would. Just make sure to find a taxidermist that does a good job. I've seen some fixed tines that looked terrible.

A question to some that wouldn't fix the tines. What if you had trail camera pictures of the buck before his rack was busted up? Would you fix them then?

From: 4406v Date: 17-Mar-10

4406v's embedded Photo

I had a decision to make after killing what would have been a beautifull 7x7 herd bull.Two broken tines on the right side almost to the main beam.No doubt he was awesome with full head gear,and no doubt he's still an awesome first bull.My decision was to leave him as he was when killed.

WHAT WOULD YOU HAVE DONE???

From: Davy C Date: 17-Mar-10
I had a buck mounted with 2 broken tines. To me that's just part of the story and shows that he was a fighter. The buck I'm mounting this year has a big gouge out of one ear. Probably got pinched between the antlers while fighting.

From: Pat Lefemine Date: 17-Mar-10
I am the same as Matt. Not only will I not fix a broken tine, but I wouldn't use a different cape either, even if the original got ruined. I know it means nothing to anyone other than me but when I look at the trophy it needs to be exactly the animal I shot right down to the imperfections.

I did have one of my biggest bucks fall from the wall and get busted up, and I did repair those horns, but that's a different situation.

My 2c.

From: rooster Date: 17-Mar-10

rooster's embedded Photo

My best buck to date is mounted exactly as taken. MO

From: T Mac Date: 17-Mar-10
I do not but to each his own.

From: hoytcountry Date: 17-Mar-10
nope

From: carbonarcher Date: 17-Mar-10
I wouldn't fix the tines unless they were somhow broken by something I'd done. IE: broken tine while loading buck in the truck, or took a spill while packing out a set of elk horns and broke a tine, in that case then yes, I'd repair a tine. Otherwise I'd mount the buck/bull as he was when I released the arrow.

From: Foodplot Date: 17-Mar-10
Yes.

From: Northwoods Date: 17-Mar-10
I've never considered repairing broken tines. I don't think I would do it, as I think it takes away from the character of the deer as you shot it.

But like almost anything, there is usually an exceptional situation where I might change my mind - but only if I could replicate almost exactly what was there when the animal grew it.

From: The Old Sarge Date: 17-Mar-10
If it's broken in my possession and I have both pieces, sure, I'd repair it. But if I killed an animal with broken antlers, he'd stay just as I killed him.

The Old Sarge

From: Buffalo Date: 17-Mar-10
Yes I have.

From: Elkhunter - Home Date: 17-Mar-10
I let a very nice buck walk the last day of Alabama's season this year. He was 3.5 or 4.5 years old and had 4 points still intact on each side. But, he had several broken off including a third of his main beam on the left side. I hope I will be able to catch up with him earlier next year. He should be a toad!

I haven't repaird one yet, but I would if he broke it off after I shot him. Assuming I could find it.

From: longhunter Date: 17-Mar-10
Yes

From: Show-Me Greg Date: 17-Mar-10
No.

This years buck is at the taxi with a broken (flush with the main beam) & missing G2.

From: Grunt-N-Gobble Date: 17-Mar-10
Yes....... I've had a busted-up 10pt repaired by my taxidermist and I did an 8pt with a broken point myself. I had a couple trailcam pics of the 8pt before I shot him, so I had a real good idea how long his point was. He broke off around 7 inches, so I rebuilt the point with a repair kit from VanDikes using another tine from a shed antler I found.

But you know what???????? To each their own. Do what you want and don't worry about what others think. I could care less if someone doesn't like my decision. I'm the one who looks at the mount everyday and no one else. Heck, most people don't even know it was repaired when they see them.

From: acornhollow Date: 17-Mar-10
I had one repaired that was busted during the truck ride out. It was a small kicker point and was the first thing I noticed on his rack before I shot him. Luckily we found the point. I think each circumstance is different. I wouldn't add anything that wasn't there when I shot it. I would repair if it was broke during moving or something.

From: Ben Farmer Date: 17-Mar-10
No. Unless broke after i killed him.

From: wilhille Date: 17-Mar-10
Why would you shoot it if you werent happy the way it looked at the time of the shot?

If I broke it, maybe.

From: TKrets Date: 17-Mar-10
Repair-yes, Reconstruct, no.

From: Bou'bound Date: 17-Mar-10
yes, but only if the broken time is more than 3/8" in length. hey, a guy has to have standards.

From: dbboss2 Date: 17-Mar-10
Doubt it. Would depend on the situation & the animal.

From: TREESTANDWOLF Date: 17-Mar-10
If it walks in front of me, and I decide to take it, it will get mounted as it was when I shot. Battle scars, broken tines, maybe even one eye!

Also, if the trophy is perfect when harvested, better yet. Don't want make them something they are not.

But, to each his own, just my beliefs.

Just hunt.....

From: longboman Date: 17-Mar-10
I like them the way they are when killed but caribou are a different animal. I get the velvet off, especially if its close to coming off naturally. To much stink to take the chance.

From: tonyo6302 Date: 17-Mar-10
For any that would repair/reconstruct one, make sure if it is a Pope'r, you get it officially scored prior to the repair.

I would not repair/reconstruct one, but have no problems with those who do.

Tony

From: BO-N-ARO Date: 17-Mar-10

BO-N-ARO's embedded Photo

I think maybe if I shot a late season buck and the antler popped off when I grabbed him I would attach it to a mount............ maybe if I shot a buck and he fell, busting a tip or two and I found them I would repair it........... or even if I had a mount fall off the wall and busted a tine or horn I would fix it, but I dont think I would repair a trophy if I shot it the way he was. I, as a taxidermist, have rebuilt busted tines and remember one that I actually was asked to "fix" a rack from a guy one time. I "fixed" it by rebuilding about 12 inches of missing main beam and the G4 from it.

This buck has a missing G1 that kept him from making B7C, but .... thats OK with me, I shot him this way and I like him this way.

To each is own.

From: Ryanw Date: 17-Mar-10
Nope

From: droptine101 Date: 17-Mar-10

droptine101's embedded Photo

Wow! Appreciate all the opinions. Well I repaired the rack and have no regrets. They guy that fixed them did a great job. I was nervous but after getting it done I am glad it turned out so well. To each their own. I did not realize he was busted until after I shot him. I had deer cam pics before he broke so I had him restored close to original. Enjoy the pics.

From: droptine101 Date: 17-Mar-10
Wow! Appreciate all the opinions. Well I repaired the rack and have no regrets. They guy that fixed them did a great job. I was nervous but after getting it done I am glad it turned out so well. To each their own. I did not realize he was busted until after I shot him. I had deer cam pics before he broke so I had him restored close to original. Enjoy the pics.

From: droptine101 Date: 17-Mar-10

droptine101's embedded Photo

Harvest shot.

From: droptine101 Date: 17-Mar-10

droptine101's embedded Photo

All fixed up.

From: Big Lefty Date: 17-Mar-10
I'd leave it, but that's just me. You're the one that get's to enjoy the trophy for the rest of your life, so do whatever makes you happy. BTW, if looks very nice. Great deer!

From: LKH Date: 18-Mar-10
Antlers, no.

Cape, yes. Most guys wouldn't know theirs from the original in many cases.

I've sold enough caribou capes to know that many are lost due to poor care and other causes. There are more than a few guys who don't know the animal they have on the wall has someone else's cape.

From: arctichill Date: 18-Mar-10
I think some of mine have somebody else's antlers? They seem a lot smaller now, than when I drew down on those beasts!? Just Kidding. Great deer droptine.

From: writer Date: 18-Mar-10
Yep - have on a once-in-a-lifetime permit Kansas elk. Two points shot-off, I think, by another hunter. I tell everybody when they see the bull and show them which points.

Since, I've about decided I'm done with mounts other than Europeans or skull caps.

It's personal choice with no wrong answers. Some guys get mounts of deer shot over bait though it's unnatural in the woods. Others wouldn't even shoot such a buck, let alone get it mounted or fix a broken point.

Amazingly respectful thread - cool.

From: MaBow Date: 18-Mar-10
Yes but only if I had the broken off piece then I would reattach it.

From: B4LITE Date: 18-Mar-10
Shot a ten pointer with all points and when he ran off somewaere along the way he broke off the G3. I looked everywhere the nxt day and couldn't find it. slso couldn't find the the arrow and he only went about 75-100 yards. I'm thinking about fixing it. I'd say yes if that is how you saw him when you shot him.

From: Ki-Ke Date: 18-Mar-10
Here is another, though rather unique scenario;

I killed a jumbo New Mexico bull a few years ago that I had hunted for 11 days DIY. Sometime between the time I saw him and finally killed him he busted his 5th & 6th (entire whale tail) off at the main beam just above the 4th point. Had he matched, he would have grossed in the low 370's.

Two winters later, an outfitter buddy was lion hunting in a canyon close to where I killed that bull. His hunter picked up a broken piece of antler. My friend immediately recognized it as the missing piece from my bull! He shipped it to me and it fits, right down to the splinters. Other than being a bit sun faded, it has no other wear or bite marks.

What would you do? No theoretical or hypothetical design work needs to be done, I have the antler!

I simply stuck it in place without any permanent attachment. The story is so cool to me that restoring the rack would take something away from the telling.

Otherwise, I don't fix broken antlers.

From: tcosmic Date: 18-Mar-10
In alot of customers eyes if you can repair an antler without it being noticable that makes you an excellent taxidermist.If you want it to look nice as it did before the rut ,I say why not.I had a guy bring me a scrub 8pt. one time and every point on it was busted.Because it was the first buck he ever shot he insisted on mounting it and wanted every point reconstructed.I tried talking him onto a horn mount because this was a sad looking deer,but he insisted.You talk about a before and after picture.I would say its about 50-50,some say leave it while others say fix it.

From: tcosmic Date: 18-Mar-10
I tell ya what I would do 4406v.I would sit down to a nice elk steak and cold beer and then go to bed and dream about goin back this season to take care of the bad boy who he was fighting with that broke those tines off.Either way thats a fine bull.Was that a rifle kill,I see the date as october 10th?

From: archer Date: 18-Mar-10
Why not, as long as you restore it to it's original condition.

From: Adventurewriter Date: 18-Mar-10
Sure why not....to each his own but these amazing animals "Gods expression" in a wild male animal....works of art really in my eye why not bring it back to is finest for viewing. So what if it got busted off,,,,Was watching some hunting show (rare for me) and they were after an amazing Bull....he broke a tine overnight and he instantly became garbage,,now adding extra from what it would have been originally....thats a different story

From: HerdManager Date: 18-Mar-10
If it was like that when you shot him, fine, but not adding to what he was when you shot him.

I mean, what's the limit? If you have trail cam pics of a 200" buck, kill him and one side is broken off, do you just replace it because that's what he "was"?

What if you kill him when BOTH sides are broken off, do you "fix" him back to what he used to be?

I couldn't do it, knowing that the deer on the wall was not what I chose to harvest.

From: CAS_HNTR@UC Date: 18-Mar-10
Keep him as you shot him....if he ran into a tree or fell off a cliff after the arrow and snapped some stuff off, I would likely fix him.

I don't understand why you would fix an animal that you chose to shoot....if you were unhappy with the broken tines and whatnot when you saw him...don't shoot him IMO.

From: gobbler Date: 18-Mar-10
I leave them as they were when I shot them. My stone sheep had a broken horn when I shot him and I left it that way. My Mt. goat broke his when he fell and I had those repaired.

From: TheIceman Date: 21-Mar-10
I say no.

droptine-no offense but the title of your thread is repair. You are not repairing you are adding inches.

I have a half racked 6 on the wall that would meet P&Y minimum with a matching left side. He broke his rack at the base. I left him as he was.

I think it is an ego thing with most who would repair.

Then again I'm agaisnt shooting coyotes.

From: 4406v Date: 22-Mar-10
I shot a beautiful 10 point one year with a rifle.I had two guys move in on me while in a treestand within 40 yds.Just as they realize I'm there here comes the buck up through the valley.I start shooting the buck and they are trying to see it.I knew I had to put him down or they were going to shoot him too.In the process of planting the buck for good I shot the whole right side of his rack off within 1-1/2 inches of the skull.I picked up the shattered pieces and reconstructed the right side although I never tried to paint or match the fixed parts of the rack.The rack is mounted on a plaque and I tell the story when asked "what's up with this rack?"


Reply to Thread

Subject: RE: Antler repair vote yes or no

You are not registered - please click here to register now.

 
Copyright © 1996-2013 Bowsite.com
No duplication without expressed written consent of the author and Bowsite.com.

Privacy and Registration Policy