Sitka Gear
Will you tag out this sept ?
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
cityhunter 17-Jul-15
KJC 17-Jul-15
cityhunter 17-Jul-15
MathewsMan 17-Jul-15
Jaquomo 17-Jul-15
huntabsarokee 17-Jul-15
Cottonwood88 17-Jul-15
Ron Niziolek 17-Jul-15
Will 17-Jul-15
Z Barebow 17-Jul-15
Destroyer350 17-Jul-15
sfiremedic 17-Jul-15
R. Hale 17-Jul-15
oake 17-Jul-15
LUNG$HOT 17-Jul-15
Charlie Rehor 17-Jul-15
Bake 17-Jul-15
midwest 17-Jul-15
Willieboat 17-Jul-15
T-Rex 17-Jul-15
Mad_Angler 17-Jul-15
trkyslr 17-Jul-15
wyobullshooter 17-Jul-15
IdyllwildArcher 17-Jul-15
cityhunter 17-Jul-15
BowCrossSkin 17-Jul-15
Cheesehead Mike 17-Jul-15
cityhunter 17-Jul-15
BowCrossSkin 17-Jul-15
greg simon 17-Jul-15
mnbowhunter 17-Jul-15
huntmaster 17-Jul-15
Danno 17-Jul-15
bigmart 17-Jul-15
bradbear 17-Jul-15
Gutpile 17-Jul-15
never2sharp 17-Jul-15
smarba 17-Jul-15
LUNG$HOT 17-Jul-15
cityhunter 17-Jul-15
cnelk 17-Jul-15
400 Elk @Home 17-Jul-15
Bowfreak 17-Jul-15
elkmtngear 17-Jul-15
drycreek 17-Jul-15
YZF-88 17-Jul-15
BackStraps 17-Jul-15
coelker 18-Jul-15
BULELK1 18-Jul-15
BIG ERN 18-Jul-15
cityhunter 18-Jul-15
cityhunter 18-Jul-15
txhunter58 18-Jul-15
ryanrc 18-Jul-15
Bogey PA 18-Jul-15
NJ Elkhunter 18-Jul-15
Paul@thefort 18-Jul-15
Start My Hunt 18-Jul-15
Bowboy 18-Jul-15
From: cityhunter
17-Jul-15
For all those hitting the elk mountains will u punch your tag ?

From: KJC
17-Jul-15
No doubt in my mind!

From: cityhunter
17-Jul-15
Dead elk walking !!!!

From: MathewsMan
17-Jul-15
Sure hope so, 21 years to get this elk tag. Will be looking to put it on something special though.

From: Jaquomo
17-Jul-15
Yes, not passing up bulls this year since I want to help a great older couple who both drew moose tags.

17-Jul-15
This is the year that it all comes together.

From: Cottonwood88
17-Jul-15
I feel confident with at least one of our group will tag out.

From: Ron Niziolek
17-Jul-15
That's the plan.

From: Will
17-Jul-15
That is the plan.

Last year was my first time out to CO for elk.

Missed a couple of times due to elk fever and hit a giant directly on the shoulder and only got a couple inches of penetration.

This 50+ year old easterner wants revenge in the worst way.

Killed around 20+ WT's but never had a screaming elk in my face.

From: Z Barebow
17-Jul-15
That is the goal! And I have spent 11.5 months thinking about it, planning and training to make it happen.

From: Destroyer350
17-Jul-15
Absolutely. I keep wondering what my bull is doing right now....

From: sfiremedic
17-Jul-15
No question...I'll fight off the satellites until I get a biggin.

From: R. Hale
17-Jul-15
Going to shoot the first 400 net bull I see.

From: oake
17-Jul-15
what Z said

From: LUNG$HOT
17-Jul-15
Yup, any legal elk to cross my path will bite the dust. 7 mouths to feed so not picky.

17-Jul-15
Expecting a punched tag is a bow hunter requirement! Good luck all! C

From: Bake
17-Jul-15
I'd say the odds are ok. Not great, not poor. I'm gonna be a little picky, so that notches the odds down some.

We'll see.

From: midwest
17-Jul-15
No doubt in my mind!

From: Willieboat
17-Jul-15
Its a given !!

From: T-Rex
17-Jul-15
X2 Z

From: Mad_Angler
17-Jul-15
I don't know. I've never even seen an elk before...

But I'll work hard and will take the first legal elk I see.

So, yes. I will fill my tag this year (I don't think it will be a monster but I will be VERY happy with any elk.)

From: trkyslr
17-Jul-15
YES!

17-Jul-15
God willing and the creek don't rise!

I'm running low on summer sausage meat, so like Jaq, I'm not going to be real picky this year. I'd say there's an elk out there that doesn't know it yet, but he's in trouble!

17-Jul-15
1 or 2. Zero is not an option.

From: cityhunter
17-Jul-15
Best of luck to all with a tag !

From: BowCrossSkin
17-Jul-15

BowCrossSkin's embedded Photo
BowCrossSkin's embedded Photo
YES!!! And here he is!!

17-Jul-15
That's the plan!

I was a little more selective last year after killing a big one in 2013 and I didn't punch a tag. The freezer is getting pretty bare and I won't be as selective this year...

From: cityhunter
17-Jul-15
Paul nice pic it shows the age diff on them 3 bulls the left one would be my choice big mature body and good mass wide curved rack ,center bull is nice but younger and lacking compared to other bull , right bull needs a few more yrs !

From: BowCrossSkin
17-Jul-15

BowCrossSkin's embedded Photo
BowCrossSkin's embedded Photo
Cheesehead Mike thats what I'm worried about, I'm trying for the guy above or this one. He's the last one in the back.

Either would be difficult and I'm scared I will not tag out.

From: greg simon
17-Jul-15
When I kill an elk I will punch my tag!!! Hunting Wyoming on general tag, Got high expectations but also understand reality. I'm not to picky so I sure hope to cut that notch!

From: mnbowhunter
17-Jul-15
It would be a bonus. Going to enjoy my time with awesome companions

From: huntmaster
17-Jul-15
My time has come!! One will die this year!

From: Danno
17-Jul-15
You bet! 2 in Colorado and 1 New Mexico and 24 days to get it done. Wife says freezer is empty and don't come home empty handed :)

From: bigmart
17-Jul-15
No doubt about it, Oregon for the season.

From: bradbear
17-Jul-15
Heck ya, Killing a stud in AZ!!

From: Gutpile
17-Jul-15
The success stats don't support the confidence you all have, but go getem boys.

From: never2sharp
17-Jul-15
Sounds like " first one in ...loses" for a lot of us.

From: smarba
17-Jul-15
So average success rates are 10-20% for archery, yet 100% of Bowsiters say they'll tag out.

We're either the elite of all bowhunters or delusional...

From: LUNG$HOT
17-Jul-15
I'd like to think "the elite" ;)

From: cityhunter
17-Jul-15
the power of positive thinking !!!!!

From: cnelk
17-Jul-15
In the past 15 years of archery elk hunting, only 3 times I haven't punched my tag.

I'm sticking with my odds

Confidence kills.

17-Jul-15
Yes...If a 350 + bull give me a shot. I have waited a long time and want a great hunt. Filling the tag will simply be icing on the top IMO

From: Bowfreak
17-Jul-15
I don't care if I do or not. I will be happy just to chase elk BUT if its brown its down. :)

From: elkmtngear
17-Jul-15
Yep...if it's brown...it's down!

And who knows...it might finally be my Year to kill a decent public land bull...

Either way...I'm eating elk!

From: drycreek
17-Jul-15
I'm loving the optimism guys ! Hope you all score !

From: YZF-88
17-Jul-15
Nope. No chance...no tag. Drew a limited entry rifle tag for Oct 1 in the area I always bow hunt. Will scout all of September and it will feel very weird packing a spotting scope instead of a bow. I just couldn't afford a 2nd $430 tag to archery hunt otherwise my answer to the question would be "absolutly"!!!!

From: BackStraps
17-Jul-15
Yep. Freezer full of cow meat come September.

From: coelker
18-Jul-15
Going by stats.. 11 bulls in 13 years and one of those no kill years was because I was holding out! So yes I will tag something.

With my wife hunting for her first kill it might be her, but we will get at least 1.

From: BULELK1
18-Jul-15
I am more interested in the fellow's coming out to share my Wyo & Utah bow elk camp to harvest an elk more than me---

Good luck, Robb

From: BIG ERN
18-Jul-15

BIG ERN's embedded Photo
BIG ERN's embedded Photo
Absolutely!!,AND ATTACH IT BEFORE I TAKE PICTURES. So no one is offended

From: cityhunter
18-Jul-15
Some of us will eat our woeds !!!

From: cityhunter
18-Jul-15
some of us will eat our words!!!!!

From: txhunter58
18-Jul-15
"Absolutely!!,AND ATTACH IT BEFORE I TAKE PICTURES. So no one is offended "

Of course that depends on which state you are in. In Colorado, you must attach the tag to meat. Especially for those that quarter and pack out. :)

As far as the question at hand. I will absolutely guarantee that some of us here will tag out! Hopefully I am in that group! Trying New Mexico for the first time ever this year.

From: ryanrc
18-Jul-15
I highly doubt it! Hopefully i will at least put more pieces of the puzzle together though. I know i will enjoy thr mountains and have fun either way. If i actually see an elk while hunting i will be pumped. Last year, my first elk season, i never saw an elk while hunting. Saw one while driving. ....

From: Bogey PA
18-Jul-15
If I fill my tag I vow to manscape for the next year.

From: NJ Elkhunter
18-Jul-15
No Doubt that well take 1 out of 2. If we catch them talking consistently its over as the 2 man talk & stalk will get the job done. BTW those that have not taken one yet don't get greedy, take that first one that's legal and like my late father Stash used to say to me "You Can't eat the horns" as there is not much out there better than Elk Meat.

From: Paul@thefort
18-Jul-15
Ok, 50% odds based on my past success. Will be solo hunting 30 days in a new area with good concentrations of elk and the archery success is 23%. Fingers crossed for sure and I will give it 100% as usual.

My best, Paul

18-Jul-15
Cow for sure. Nice bull, with any luck. It would be nice to have to buy a big chest cooler to store two elk and maybe a muley.

Mike

From: Bowboy
18-Jul-15
There's an elk out there with my name it! Hopefully I do my part correctly.

  • Sitka Gear