Mathews Inc.
2015 AZ Elk Success Board
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
azrod 04-Sep-15
midwest 04-Sep-15
ohiohunter 04-Sep-15
midwest 04-Sep-15
azrod 04-Sep-15
Heat 04-Sep-15
ohiohunter 04-Sep-15
azrod 17-Sep-15
Florida Mike 18-Sep-15
jdee 18-Sep-15
Ward's Outfitters 19-Sep-15
Ward's Outfitters 19-Sep-15
Bill in MI 19-Sep-15
loopmtz 19-Sep-15
azrod 24-Sep-15
derbyhunter5 24-Sep-15
azrod 25-Sep-15
jdee 25-Sep-15
midwest 25-Sep-15
bradbear 25-Sep-15
derbyhunter5 25-Sep-15
derbyhunter5 25-Sep-15
azrod 25-Sep-15
azrod 28-Sep-15
Bill in MI 28-Sep-15
str8arrow 30-Sep-15
str8arrow 30-Sep-15
Bill in MI 30-Sep-15
ki-ke 30-Sep-15
6x6 bull 30-Sep-15
wildwilderness 30-Sep-15
derbyhunter5 30-Sep-15
Heat 30-Sep-15
6x6 bull 30-Sep-15
HANS1 30-Sep-15
HANS1 30-Sep-15
AZBUGLER 30-Sep-15
str8arrow 01-Oct-15
jdee 01-Oct-15
Bowboy 01-Oct-15
6x6 bull 01-Oct-15
Heat 01-Oct-15
Castle Oak 02-Oct-15
BigRed 02-Oct-15
GRBowman 02-Oct-15
AZBUGLER 03-Oct-15
jdee 03-Oct-15
Ward's Outfitters 09-Oct-15
willliamtell 09-Oct-15
Bill in MI 09-Oct-15
Bill in MI 09-Oct-15
Hoot 09-Oct-15
Ward's Outfitters 10-Oct-15
WillPower400 10-Oct-15
AZBUGLER 13-Oct-15
elkcrzy1 15-Oct-15
elkcrzy1 15-Oct-15
huntmaster 15-Oct-15
pav 16-Oct-15
elkcrzy1 19-Oct-15
alce 19-Oct-15
Nesser 17-Nov-15
Unit 9er 17-Nov-15
midwest 17-Nov-15
Nesser 18-Nov-15
From: azrod
04-Sep-15
Lets see those Pics for 2015! Good Luck to all!

From: midwest
04-Sep-15
already an elk meat pole thread.

From: ohiohunter
04-Sep-15
azrod...How many meat pole threads do we need? You know there are 50 states ;)

From: midwest
04-Sep-15
azrod, you have a tag this year?

If so, good luck! Hope to hunt AZ soon!

From: azrod
04-Sep-15
Ohiohunter never enough luv looking at Elk

Midwest No I don't but my grandson does 2nd in a row last year he held out on a big one and came home empty this year he says i'ts going to be different, we'll see he still wants one bigger than grandpa's 336 though 5Bs

From: Heat
04-Sep-15
Archery elk doesn't start for another week. Just saying.

From: ohiohunter
04-Sep-15
Its a one stop shop here at bowsite on the meatpole.

From: azrod
17-Sep-15

azrod's embedded Photo
azrod's embedded Photo
Grandson Tanner Ragen 1st Archery Bull 5BS 2nd morning Bowtech 100 Muzzy 49 yds dropped in 20 yds

From: Florida Mike
18-Sep-15
Congrats to your grandson! Mike

From: jdee
18-Sep-15
There might already be a elk meat pole and there might be 50 states but Arizona elk are good enough to have their own !!

Tell Tanner congrats.

19-Sep-15

Ward's Outfitters's embedded Photo
Ward's Outfitters's embedded Photo

19-Sep-15

Ward's Outfitters's embedded Photo
Ward's Outfitters's embedded Photo

From: Bill in MI
19-Sep-15

Bill in MI's MOBILE embedded Photo
Bill in MI's MOBILE embedded Photo

From: loopmtz
19-Sep-15
Sweet!

From: azrod
24-Sep-15
Right on jdee and I will. Love all them elk but as you said ARIZONA ELK and HUNTS are special! Lot of great looking animals, taste good too.!

From: derbyhunter5
24-Sep-15
I had a awesome hunt in 5bs. I was in elk every morning passed at least 8bulls. Missed 2 330plus bulls(rushed and buddy told me wrong range on other) before i shot a nice 5x5. i dont regret settling for a lesser bull i focused on bringing meat home.

From: azrod
25-Sep-15
Congrats Derbyhunter5, wheres the pics

From: jdee
25-Sep-15
Congrats Bill in MI. If I remember right you drew an ok tag (as compared to AZ top unit's ) and went DIY ??? You done good son.

From: midwest
25-Sep-15
azrod, Congrats to your g'son!

From: bradbear
25-Sep-15

bradbear's embedded Photo
bradbear's embedded Photo
Not the giant I was chasing, but on day 7 decided it was time to harvest my first elk

From: derbyhunter5
25-Sep-15

derbyhunter5's embedded Photo
derbyhunter5's embedded Photo
This is my bull by far not the biggest I had a chance at but I was more than happy with the experience.

From: derbyhunter5
25-Sep-15

derbyhunter5's embedded Photo
derbyhunter5's embedded Photo
This is my buddies bull it was his first ever elk.

From: azrod
25-Sep-15
Nice!! Bet he was thrilled. Congrats to all! It's not the size but the experience that lives within us!!!

From: azrod
28-Sep-15
Bill in Mi Congrats and a heck of a good story. What did it score?

From: Bill in MI
28-Sep-15
Derby, heck of a nice family photo there. Very cool

Yes, my tag was a so so 4A DIWF (Do it with friends) hunt.

I'll have it scored by P&Y in November. I'm guessing between 315-325" but what do I know? TBD

Congrats to all.

Bill

From: str8arrow
30-Sep-15

str8arrow's embedded Photo
str8arrow's embedded Photo
AZ Unit 7 West bull: tradbow kill on 9/17/2015.

Gross score: 378+ Green score NET: 372+

From: str8arrow
30-Sep-15

str8arrow's embedded Photo
str8arrow's embedded Photo
Second photo of above bull, with lucky hunter.

From: Bill in MI
30-Sep-15
Oh man that's massive! Congrats!!

From: ki-ke
30-Sep-15
That last bull is wow! Would love to hear the story....

That 6x5 that Derby buddy killed is a tank!

Please share some of the stories behind these Bulls.......

From: 6x6 bull
30-Sep-15
I have 11 points in AZ and could have 12 if I go and take the hunter safety class. My question to you guys could I have drawn any of those units that you guys got your bulls in as a non-resident. MY friend in AZ lives on the border of 1 and 3A-3C and I don't think I will ever draw those units so I am always trying to find a new option.

30-Sep-15
str8arrow, that first pic of the dead elk really shows how hard it is to guess a score ore judge an elk from only a picture! Looks like nothing special, but the second picture with the hunter in there really gives it perspective! Awesome trad kill!

From: derbyhunter5
30-Sep-15
My buddy got his bull on second evening of the hunt. He was still hunting through the woods with my dad and another buddy when they spotted the bull. They slipped into position wind was perfect had a narrow window between trees at 44yds. He shot and they thought it hit in the money. Giving the. Bull sometime they started tracking and ended up jumping the bull so they backed out until mysel and other friend was able to help track. After a very stressful hr long track we found the bull expired. We had a 1/4 mile uphill pack to the truck so it wasn't bad.

My hunt in arizona was great and definitely a learning experience.

After passing bulls every day and a miss I finally connected on day7 . We got back to the area to hear bulls bugling. Trying to get the wind in our favor we made a move on the herd. Hiding in patch of brush we could see the herd heading towards us a spike iled the way followed by a dozen cows couple smaller bulls then a nice 6x6 (330) if they will stay on track they are going stay upwind and be easy 25yard shot. They go left catch are wind but holdup at 40 yards. The big bull stops vitals right behind a tree if only he took another step. He angles away towards a cow then comes back in front of us a buddy was ranging and told me 60 I shoot and it flies right over his back frustrated I said to my buddy the next bull that cones in and just bugles right in our face I'm shooting. Hour later we had that chance 3 cows a calf and my bull came in around 35 yards bull just screamed. And I decided Im shooting. I drilled right behind shoulder but got little penetration (I think the xexcuetioner hit a rib). Watched the bull stand hunkered over for 30 mind until another started fighting him. He walked off we backed. Out ate dinner and went back to recover him only to find a short blood trai And no bull. Searched for 2hrs in dark nothing. Went back next morning and can't find anything. My buddies were looking further out and found him still alive bedded down at noon the next day. Finally meeting up them we slipped up where bull was bedded and find him dead hr later. I'm glad. I didn't loose any meat and it was only. 5mile back to 4wheelers.

From: Heat
30-Sep-15
Congratulations to all the successful Arizona hunters in 2015! All excellent trophies.

6x6 bull,

Based on last years draw odds you would have a 100% chance on the 3 units mentioned on this thread with 12 points. If I had to rank them in order of hardest to easier to draw I would say 7W, 5BS, 4A. All good units!

One thing that has been talked about a lot is that the Department is going to change the NR allocation in the Bonus Only round to only 50% of the total NR tags, so if that does go through all this is out the window! Might still have a pretty decent shot to draw but no more guarantees in the bonus round like now. However you would have a shot at any tag in any unit besides a few sheep hunts if they do change it.

Good Luck!

Nick

From: 6x6 bull
30-Sep-15
Thanks Nick. I appreciate the info. I just need to convince my friend that I don't think I will ever have enough points to draw those two units.

From: HANS1
30-Sep-15

HANS1's embedded Photo
HANS1's embedded Photo
My 2015 not the best photo selfie by stacking rocks and setting my phone on it

From: HANS1
30-Sep-15

HANS1's embedded Photo
HANS1's embedded Photo
Upright

From: AZBUGLER
30-Sep-15
6x6 Bull, you should draw 3C next year! granted that is if the changes don't take effect yet.

It took 11 points last year for 100% draw as a non-res.

You're still a couple off of unit 1 (it took 14 for a guarantee). My $.02, I would stick with the units you have chosen since you have waited so long. Easier said then done, I'm at 9 points and I'm having a real tough time thinking about doing that.

From: str8arrow
01-Oct-15
ki-ke — Those two photos of mine are of the same bull, one without body attached. Taken in Unit 7 West. As a N-R, I had accumulated 16 points before drawing.

From: jdee
01-Oct-15
11 points didn't get me a 3c early archery tag for the 2015 season.

From: Bowboy
01-Oct-15
Str8arrow that is a toad of a bull congrats. I'd like to hear the story!

From: 6x6 bull
01-Oct-15
AZBUGLER if I am that close I think that you are right that I should wait. He keeps sending me trailcam photo's that are unbelievable!!! I would almost feel bad if I went to AZ now and didn't have him help me but he keeps thinking just one more year or so and I should draw. At 59 I just hope that I am in as good of shape as Paul@fort is when I do draw.

From: Heat
01-Oct-15
My reading of the 2015 Bonus Pass report does not yield the same results that AZBugler is reporting. 16-13 points was pretty sure to get a tag 3a/3c in 2015. With 13 points, 90% of those applicants drew a tag. With 12 and 11 points respectively around 12% of each of those two groups drew. 1 person got a tag with 10 points in the bonus pass. I would suspect those were residents. Technically you needed 14 points as a Non-Resident to get a guaranteed tag in the Bonus Pass in 2015 if I am reading things right.

From: Castle Oak
02-Oct-15
I suspect the draw odds changed significantly with many folks burning points prior to the non-res draw change. I had 11 and did not draw my first choice 3A/C. Burned my 11 on a lesser unit and well, the hunting quality was less than hyped.

From: BigRed
02-Oct-15
6x6 - Listen to what Heat is saying. You could be several years off if 3A/3C is your goal. Believe me, I've been chasing unit 9 for what seems an eternity, and with 18pts I'm still not guaranteed a tag. I'm not telling you to give up on your goal, but there are big bulls in all the units. Put 3A/3C as your first choice, and one of the other units you're considering as a second and go hunt.

Like me, you're not getting any younger... If I had to do over again I'd have hunted a lesser unit years ago, and probably drawn the same unit again. I know a guy (NR) who's shot a 315 and a 340 in unit 6A, the most heavily trafficked unit, while I have yet to hunt Ariz. You tell me who's had more fun...

From: GRBowman
02-Oct-15

GRBowman's embedded Photo
GRBowman's embedded Photo
My friends bulls from unit 8

From: AZBUGLER
03-Oct-15
My stats were from 2014, not the 2015 results as Heat pointed out. The draw odds will very from year to year. The problem is that once you've invested so many years, it seems like kind of a waste to give up on it. Not that it by any means would be a "waste" of a hunt, but a waste of waiting a few more years. I could've 100% drawn an early bull tag in several units last year and the year before. But.... Since my points are getting up there, I've started to hold out. Part of me says I'm nuts and I should just get drawn and go hunt! The other part says, "then why did I sit the last few years out"! This will probably be the only time in my life I will hold out this long. After my next draw it's going hunting as often as I can.

From: jdee
03-Oct-15
Your right AZB. In 2014 11 points would get a non res a tag in 3c but not 2015. Some years they change the amount of tags allotted in a unit and that makes a big difference too. Myself, after putting in for points and tags in AZ for so many years and spending so much money on it and then they might change things after all of the years and $$ invested I know for a fact as soon as I draw a tag in AZ I'm not doing it again.

I killed as good a bull in another state as I could of hoped for in AZ (well almost ) and it only took putting in once plus all the otc states and land owner tags. AZ is a great elk state but it's one and done for me.

09-Oct-15
Quit wasting all those years applying for those 9 and 10 tags, we kill giant bulls in units that only 6-8 points get you in. We killed a 391 in a 8 point unit this season and a 393 in the same unit two years ago, contact me and put down a deposit and we will tell you what units to apply for. sorry guys no deposit not information , we have made that mistake a few times, if you don't draw you can either get the deposit back or roll it over to the next year.

From: willliamtell
09-Oct-15
Bill in MI measure that bull. Bet you're way low.

From: Bill in MI
09-Oct-15

Bill in MI's embedded Photo
Bill in MI's embedded Photo

From: Bill in MI
09-Oct-15

Bill in MI's embedded Photo
Bill in MI's embedded Photo
I don't have the antlers in my possession now, please tell me what you think it might gross.

I can score whitetails pretty dang close with a glance, but I have zero experience scoring elk.

FYI my bow measures just over 42" end to end.

From: Hoot
09-Oct-15
336''

10-Oct-15
351

From: WillPower400
10-Oct-15
344

From: AZBUGLER
13-Oct-15
Has the frame of a 340-350 bull all day.

From: elkcrzy1
15-Oct-15
345-350 Is right on id say

From: elkcrzy1
15-Oct-15

elkcrzy1's embedded Photo
elkcrzy1's embedded Photo

From: huntmaster
15-Oct-15
Bill I was going to say 340-350 before I saw the other posts. Shot a 320 gross bull this year and yours has better thirds and better tops. Great bull for sure!

From: pav
16-Oct-15
Bill, put a tape on my WY bull and he is going to gross close to 330". Frames appear to be similar, but your bull has better tops for sure.

From: elkcrzy1
19-Oct-15
Mine above is 330

From: alce
19-Oct-15
Bill,

I think 340-350 is a good guess too. However, I wouldn't be surprised if your bull hit 360-370 with the added width and the way the main beams curve (and all the points for that matter), bulls like yours can be deceptive in their score because of their character.

Do you know the main beam length? If they are 50" or over, I think your bull is over 350.

Your bull is probably my favorite of any I've seen this year, even of some that probably score higher. The point curvature and the character of the curves is fantastic. Love the sweeping 6ths and the forward arching daggers. Absolutely beautiful bull! Congrats!

From: Nesser
17-Nov-15

Nesser's embedded Photo
Nesser's embedded Photo
Late hunt this weekend....so much good luck my head is spinning

From: Unit 9er
17-Nov-15
Can't count 'em all Nesser! Nice bull

From: midwest
17-Nov-15
Amazing, Nesser....I thought all those late season bulls were supposed to be all busted up.

Congrats! Gun or bow?

From: Nesser
18-Nov-15
Thx guys....it's a bow kill Midwest. The late bow seasons kicked off Friday. The late rifle seasons start the Friday of thanksgiving weekend.

  • Sitka Gear