IN 10 Pt, Age/Score
Contributors to this thread:Whitetail Deer
From: INDBowhunter2
02-Nov-14
I passed this buck last year on Nov. 3, day before my twins were born. Wasn't sure if he made it, didn't get any pics of him until about Oct 15 or so. He was a 9 point last, this year he has a tenth point. I will post another pic from this year, and try to find a pic from last year. How old and how big do you think?
From: INDBowhunter2
02-Nov-14
From: INDBowhunter2
02-Nov-14
From: CD
02-Nov-14
My Guess = 137
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
From: SteveB
02-Nov-14
My Guess = 141
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
3.5 years
From: Jack Harris
02-Nov-14
My Guess = 141
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
nice tall rack, my favorite attribute.. no clue on age, gun to my head, 4.5... Hope you get him!
From: Rayzor
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 143
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
He looked 3.5 in the pics. I assume the date isn't right.
From: INDBowhunter2
03-Nov-14
Date is incorrect
From: LINK
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 144
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
4.5
From: Duke
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 137
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
3.5 Y/O
From: greg simon
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 145
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
3.4
From: greg simon
03-Nov-14
WTH I meant 3.5. Don't pretend to be that good at aging from a photo!
From: drycreek
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 137
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
I'm swaggin' at 4.5 also.
From: XMan
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
yeah, I agree with everyone here, 4.5 and 137-142 range. you know the history of this deer so you probably have a better idea on its age. Good luck getting it.
From: MoBowhunter
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 139
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
From: MoBowhunter
03-Nov-14
How do you post one of these guess the score threads?
From: ndbuck09
03-Nov-14
My Guess = 136
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
From: Medicinemann
04-Nov-14
My Guess = 144
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
3.5 years old
I use Charlie Rehor's formula.....G4 X10 +100 (gross score). The right G4 is about 5 inches long. So I started at 150". The left G4 is shorter, so I deducted three inches dropping score to 147". The brow tines look like shorter than 3" per side, so I dropped another 3"....giving me 144". I didn't make an adjustment for mass or spread.
From: INDBowhunter2
04-Nov-14
Yes, camera date is incorrect, these pictures are from about a week ago.
I can't find a trailcam pic of him from last year, all I can find is a couple fuzzy pictures I got of him from my Iphone the day I passed him up.
From: bill brown
04-Nov-14
A good looking deer. Shoot and measure.
From: Heritage
04-Nov-14
My Guess = 137
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
From: williejames
04-Nov-14
My Guess = 135
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
From: mainbrdr
04-Nov-14
My Guess = 143
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
From: elkmo
04-Nov-14
My Guess = 141
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
3.5
From: INDBowhunter2
05-Nov-14
Is this the same buck? These pics were taken 2 miles apart, on the two farms we own. This pic was taken on September 12, only about 300 yrds from my house, and the pics above are 2+ miles to the north, thru a bunch of different properties, but in the same creek drainage.
From: INDBowhunter2
23-Nov-14
Is this the same buck? These pics were taken 2 miles apart, on the two farms we own. This pic was taken on September 12, only about 300 yrds from my house, and the pics above are 2+ miles to the north, thru a bunch of different properties, but in the same creek drainage.
From: Jack Harris
23-Nov-14
The "new" buck looks a little different and bigger, but probably very close to same gene pool. There is no evididence of the "junk" on the first postings.. GOOD PROBLEM TO HAVE! good luck
From: INDBowhunter2
23-Nov-14
Junk is velvet in the September pics.
From: Redman
23-Nov-14
Same deer for sure!
From: Bowhunter#22
23-Nov-14
Browtines says it all
From: Cornfed 77
24-Nov-14
My Guess = 138
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
Weak brows and shorter 4's I bet hes just shy of 140. I'm sure I would shoot him though :-)
From: Tattooed Hunter
28-Nov-14
My Guess = 137
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
Great deer......
From: HerdManager
28-Nov-14
My Guess = 138
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
From: jwhittaker
28-Nov-14
My Guess = 136
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
Absolutely the same buck
From: Keadog
29-Nov-14
My Guess = 139
Average Guess = 140
Average Guess = 140
I have a 132 on the wall that looks very similar, but my deer's tines are a bit shorter.
