3Rivers Archery Supply
Best arrow for fixed blade heads
Equipment
Contributors to this thread:
Lee 17-Aug-17
ohiohunter 17-Aug-17
jstephens61 17-Aug-17
Brotsky 17-Aug-17
greg simon 17-Aug-17
ScottTigert 17-Aug-17
Lee 17-Aug-17
wild1 17-Aug-17
Willieboat 17-Aug-17
Trial153 17-Aug-17
Buglmin 17-Aug-17
Barrera 17-Aug-17
venison 18-Aug-17
Ermine 18-Aug-17
Bowfreak 18-Aug-17
12yards 18-Aug-17
carcus 18-Aug-17
elk yinzer 18-Aug-17
bowhunter55 18-Aug-17
ARROWONEPY 18-Aug-17
XbowfromNY 18-Aug-17
APauls 18-Aug-17
ARROWONEPY 18-Aug-17
ahunter55 18-Aug-17
Lee 18-Aug-17
razorhead 18-Aug-17
From: Lee
17-Aug-17
All, What is your favorite arrow shaft for fixed blade broadheads? I'm shooting 125 grain vented VPA's. Love the head and want to build a great shooting arrow around it. I see some advertisements for arrows specifically made for great broadhead flight. Hoping to narrow down the selections so I don't break the bank.

Thanks,

Lee

From: ohiohunter
17-Aug-17
I haven't seen those ads yet, but regardless of arrow brand/model choice I would err on the stiffer side and I always shoot helical. Buyer beware based on a very recent LBS fletching job, not all arrow builders are equal, nor are all jigs. Needless to say I had to refletch a dozen for a friend.

I prefer easton axis, thinner but not micro.

From: jstephens61
17-Aug-17
I added the 5mm FMJ for my elk (larger than whitetail) set up. Got the weight I was looking for and they tuned great and flight with ViperTricks spot on. Very happy with them. May have to try them out on WT this year.

From: Brotsky
17-Aug-17
The one that is the right spine for your set-up! No other single thing with your arrow is as important as this!

From: greg simon
17-Aug-17
What Brotsky said. I love my Easton Full Metal Jackets.

From: ScottTigert
17-Aug-17
Elk-340 Easton FMJ. Slick tricks, Exodus, Magnus 4 Blade Stinger, 4 blade Hornet all fly great. A Rage Trypan will be on my deer arrow this October. They look pretty tough.

From: Lee
17-Aug-17

Lee's Link
All, Here is one that advertises broadhead accuracy. $90 for 6 arrows. I agree on the spine but am sure there are better arrows/brands than others. When I see ads like these I wonder if they're worth it?

Thanks,

Lee

From: wild1
17-Aug-17
I love the Carbon Express Maxima Red (they're also a sponsor). I tip them with a SlicktTrick Magnum 125 grn. Zero complaints.

From: Willieboat
17-Aug-17
Easton ACC.....have tried others but always end up back here

From: Trial153
17-Aug-17
second ACC's, far and away the best shaft I ever used.

From: Buglmin
17-Aug-17
Carbon Express Red SD.... small diameter with a steel half out outsert.

From: Barrera
17-Aug-17
Been a fan of my 475gr fmjs for years. Tried the black eagle rampage with stainless half outs weighing at 430gr. Black eagle continously out penetrates the fmjs by 2-3" at 40yds. Black eagles shoot great with exodus heads out to 100yds no prob.

From: venison
18-Aug-17
I saw on you tube where Black eagle is the straightest arrow . Some arrows need to be cut on both ends to find straightest part of arrow, Black eagle only need to be cut on one end because they are straight all they through shaft . I shoot Gold Tips now , bot if I was going to switch , I would try Black eagle .

From: Ermine
18-Aug-17
Goldtip Pierce

From: Bowfreak
18-Aug-17
Many great options out there. The two best arrows all things considered are Easton and Gold Tip, IMHO. I believe CX are overpriced and I believe BE are somewhat fragile. I am not worried about shooting a Gold Tip or an Easton through my hand.

From: 12yards
18-Aug-17
The arrow isn't as important as a well tuned bow. Any quality arrow will do if your bow and your form are good. I get good flight out of my Beman ICS Hunters and GT XT Hunters.

From: carcus
18-Aug-17
fmj

From: elk yinzer
18-Aug-17
Count me in the FMJ camp and I use vpa 125s also. But I always chuckle at these threads that ask what is the "best" piece of gear as that is purely a subjective determination and no one ia testing all these objectively.

From: bowhunter55
18-Aug-17
FMJ Injexion with Slick Trick D6 or Ramcat D6 broadheads.

From: ARROWONEPY
18-Aug-17
ACC 300 OR FMF340 WITH THE RIP300 ALUMINUM INSERT with a 125 slick trick

From: XbowfromNY
18-Aug-17
Victory Gamer RIP 400 V3 with 100 gr Slick Tricks for me.

From: APauls
18-Aug-17
if your setup doesn't shoot fixed blade heads, the brand of the arrow isn't the problem. It is elsewhere.

That being said, I like the Easton FMJ's I have been shooting for what seems like eons. Prior to that I shot a number of different brands and never had issues with any of them.

From: ARROWONEPY
18-Aug-17
shoot a 4 Fletch helical helps a lot! i prefer feathers

From: ahunter55
18-Aug-17

ahunter55's embedded Photo
ahunter55's embedded Photo
Easton Aluminum XX75s & Gamegetters with 3 blade Rocky Mountains. Mostly 2216s & 2219s but I also have 1913s (use for Deer sometimes 395 total grn arrow). I have 2217s & 2213s also I shoot for various things. Woodies for my Longbow & 3 blade Rocky Mountain Razors on them. Did Carbons 2 years (5 animals) & went back. Aluminums better arrow in my opinion for half the price.

From: Lee
18-Aug-17
Quite a few posts since I last checked!! Bow shoots well and is new so was looking to get a new dozen arrows. Thought I'd see if I could get a concensus before I bought them. I've shot Goldtip for a lot of years but thought I'd try something new. Looks like FMJ had the most followers - I'll take a hard look - thx!

Lee

From: razorhead
18-Aug-17
I just bought a new recurve yestesterday, at trad shop in the UP,,,, he was making up arrows for a friend, going elk hunting, using a compound, and we talked him out, of his thin wall arrows, and Rage bh's..... My friend got him to shoot fmj's 4 inch vanes and a 125 VPA, he was astonished how well they shot,,,,,,,,

I shoot Gold Tips Trads for my recurve, and fmjs for my compound,,,,,

For the recurve I shoot DRT 125 and Compound I shoot the 125 Wasp Boss SST

  • Sitka Gear