onX Maps
3rd Time The Charm?
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
Darrell 30-Aug-23
sticksender 30-Aug-23
goelk 30-Aug-23
smarba 30-Aug-23
Scoot 30-Aug-23
LUNG$HOT 30-Aug-23
ND String Puller 30-Aug-23
Tracker 30-Aug-23
Grey Ghost 30-Aug-23
Darrell 30-Aug-23
Darrell 30-Aug-23
Old School 30-Aug-23
APauls 30-Aug-23
smarba 30-Aug-23
Grey Ghost 30-Aug-23
buckeye 31-Aug-23
Big John 31-Aug-23
jordanathome 31-Aug-23
WYelkhunter 03-Sep-23
Glunt@work 03-Sep-23
greenmountain 03-Sep-23
Jordan 05-Sep-23
SteveB 05-Sep-23
Darrell 12-Sep-23
Jordan 12-Sep-23
Nyati 12-Sep-23
SteveB 14-Sep-23
From: Darrell
30-Aug-23
The past two years I've had incredible bad luck combined of course with my own mistakes. However, it has been exciting, at least for a few moments each year. Anyway, I've been hunting a pretty crowded OTC area so opportunities are rare.

One morning in 2021, I got up late (screwed up my alarm the night before trying to give me 15 more minutes sleep as i was too early the previous day) and practically ran up the big hill to the meadow I wanted to be at first light. I made it but just barely. However, my mistake was I that had my binos & range finder inside my jacket instead of outside. I gave a cow call at first light and then a minute or two later saw a 320ish 6 X 6 coming down the 1/2 mile long meadow. I pulled out my range finder to try to get a distance on something in the meadow as a reference and it instantly fogged up. Bull keeps coming towards me on a steady walk. I finally get what I thought was a 50 yard reading on a brush just the other side of the main trail. (Literally was aiming the range finder and then holding it up to the sky to try to read the number) Bull hits the spot in front of said bush and stops broadside looking for the cow he had heard. I let the arrow fly and watched it skim right under his chest. (Range finder must have been on a bush this side of the trail, not the other so while I thought he was at 48 he was 55. Ugh!

He whirls and goes back from whence he came. I made a few pleading cow calls that I figured were in vain. However, while I'm kicking myself, I look back to the top of the meadow and now there is a 6 X 6 and a 7 X 7 walking down the same trail. (I'm starting to wonder if I am dreaming)

I quickly scurried on my hands and knees 30 yards to a couple pine trees on the edge of the meadow. This time they won't be 57 yards but under 30 and a chip shot. When they are 75 yards out I catch a flash of movement to my right and (Here is the bad luck completely out of my control) a stupid coyote comes trotting down the edge of the tree line and stops 5 yards in front of me, turns his head and stares at me. I thought, "I should just shoot you cause you are going to screw this up aren't you." Sure enough he whirls and runs straight at the two bulls which of course puts them on full alert. When they turn to go back to the private, I call at them, and while they stopped and looked back, they could tell where my calls were coming from and after staring a minute or two disappeared into the trees headed back to safety of the private land.

2022 was my second biggest mistake/bad luck experience. Same meadow at first light. Had been talking with a bull for at least 40 minutes. I had played it perfectly. Called just enough to keep him from going up to the private, but not enough to pull him in before legal shooting light which was 6:12. My watch finally said it was time, but I still couldn't see my pins clearly so I waited a couple more minutes. Finally could faintly see them so I gave him a pleading cow call and thirty seconds later he popped out of the oak brush broadside at 50 yards. I come to full draw ready to fill my tag, but to my horror, I can't find my pins.

What the Heck?

After a few seconds of confusion, I let down. Of course he sees the movement (and the lack of the cow he had heard) and heads back up through the oaks and into the private.

When I look down, I see the problem. I had fought my way through some nasty brush the evening before and my peep was now sideways in my string. Reason I couldn't see my pins at full draw was because I was trying to look through the plastic of a messed up peep.

Ugh!

So, now it is 2023 and once again I didn't draw any tags so guess where I plan to be 30 minutes before first light on Saturday? Wish me luck. I hope I'm due! (And yes, I have a new string and a new peep that I will be checking way too often. I've also measured the distance between the D loop and the peep and have the ability in a pinch to replace it.)

From: sticksender
30-Aug-23
Good luck man you are due for sure. Nothing is sweeter than the success that comes after crashing and burning a few times.

From: goelk
30-Aug-23
I feel your pain. Been there , done that. Hopefully third time is the charm. Good hunting and be safe.

From: smarba
30-Aug-23
This is your year!

From: Scoot
30-Aug-23
This year is the year!

From: LUNG$HOT
30-Aug-23
Good luck Darrell! Shoot straight. I’m heading out September 9-19. Can hardly sleep at night already. It’s ridiculous. ;-).

30-Aug-23
Don’t sweat it Darrell, we’ve all had our share of screw ups. I could write a book on how to blow a golden opportunity. When it happens though and you walk up on him…for a second it feels like the world stops turning. That’s the rush we’re all after. Thanks for the post, and Good Luck Man!

From: Tracker
30-Aug-23
In an OTC area hunting a meadow I would plan on being at my spot at least a full hour before light especially early in the season. Most bulls will be heading to bed before the sun comes up and often bugle on their way there. getting there early lets you position yourself get ready, check all your gear and get composed. Plenty of time to take a nap come 10am on most mornings.

From: Grey Ghost
30-Aug-23
I suggest practicing range finding with your eyes (confirmed with your range finder) while in camp, or when it's slow while hunting. Then leave it in your pocket and trust your eyes if/when you have a close encounter.

Good luck, and I hope the third time is the charm.

Matt

From: Darrell
30-Aug-23
Tracker,

Exactly. That is what I have been doing. I have a small window to catch them before they get to the private but also have to stay below them so the morning thermals don't screw me up. It's a delicate dance that I'm hoping I have figured out. As for checking my gear, I'm pretty fastidious about that, just never had a peep move on me that way before. :)

From: Darrell
30-Aug-23
Matt,

Yes, I have hunted many years without a range finder and do pretty well. However, at first light, with nothing but grass, 50+ yards between me and the trail, and the intensity of the encounter, my guestimate likely would have been off as well. At least this way it was a clean miss.

From: Old School
30-Aug-23
Good luck Darrell - hope this is the year it all comes together for you!

From: APauls
30-Aug-23
Dang nebbitt!!!! Good luck man!! Kinda sounds like by the law of averages it could swing back soon!

From: smarba
30-Aug-23
If you know pretty much exactly where it's going to happen, any way to drag some logs and make a brush blind in advance?

From: Grey Ghost
30-Aug-23
Darrel, I've seen the exact range finding failures you described happen several times. Guys were so busy messing with their range finders that they missed legitimate shot opportunities, or they ranged the wrong distance and missed like you did. In your case, the range finder problems added to the anxiety of the situation, and ultimately caused your miss. Whether or not your eyes would have estimated the range better is an unknown, but I bet you would have been more focused on the shot had you not been fighting with your range finder.

I know I'm in the minority on this issue, but in my experience range finders can be more of a hinderance than an aide in a potential shot situation. I used to cringe when I guided clients who refused to take a shot until they had ranged the animal. I'm fine with using them to range markers ahead of time, I do it all the time, but not when an animal is within range.

I have a feeling the stars are going to align for you this year. I'm rooting for you.

Matt

From: buckeye
31-Aug-23
Good luck Darrell!

From: Big John
31-Aug-23
Best of luck Darrell!!!

From: jordanathome
31-Aug-23
I won't tell you this is your year, because many good folks on here have been telling me that since 2006 and guess what? LOL sigh sob

But I am pulling for you with fingers crossed and best wishes headed your way! In any case, have the best time ever!

Me, I'm sitting out this year. Fork it. Got no buddies coming out to hunt with me and I am way over going solo anymore.

From: WYelkhunter
03-Sep-23
hopefully it is your year. I read somewhere the average is 7 years for a public land DIY Bowhunter to get their first kill. mine was 5 years

From: Glunt@work
03-Sep-23
Good luck. In Colorado, success rate for archery is 12%.

03-Sep-23
I read the story with keen interest. If a bull had walked in to 30 yards broadside and you shot him it would be elk shopping. With all of your adventures it truly feels like a hunt. I hope you do get your bull knowing that hard work makes a kill sweeter.

From: Jordan
05-Sep-23
Well? Report in son!

From: SteveB
05-Sep-23
Can’t wait to hear how it’s going Darrell!

From: Darrell
12-Sep-23
Sorry guys, got home to my mother in the hospital (home now, doing ok), her hot water heater leaking (plumber wanted $1100 to just install a new one so that is what I did on Saturday) and our garage door opener biting the dust. (yesterday's main project.)

Anyway, third time was not "the charm," though I did have a great hunt and two really good opportunities at legal bulls plus a cool bear encounter. I'll post the stories when I catch up at work or maybe in October as I'm taking my wife and my 4 year-old granddaughter to Rocky Mount National Park this weekend to introduce her to bugling elk. :)

From: Jordan
12-Sep-23
SO sorry to hear about your challenges and mostly about your mom.......glad she is home and ok. I'd say that was 3 bad luck draws and you are due! Looking forward to your stories!

From: Nyati
12-Sep-23
I didn’t tag an elk until my 4th hunt. This was in the 80s when elk numbers weren’t as good as they are now

From: SteveB
14-Sep-23
Glad you had a good hunt Darrel, and as far as things go….one thing you can always count on is something will go wrong! Lol. I have a story of my own I’ll be posting soon.

  • Sitka Gear