Logan giant?
Contributors to this thread:West Virginia
From: wvmule
23-Oct-14
I received these photos this morning. I was told it was killed yesterday on Rum Creek in Logan County by Zach Marcum. We all know how photos like this fly around this time of year and end up being jokes. Do any of you know if the info I received is true? If so, big congrats to Zach Marcum!
From: wvmule
23-Oct-14
From: sundaynwv
23-Oct-14
That is a STUD!!!
From: wvbuckmaster
23-Oct-14
killed on rum creek yesterday.monster buck!
From: sundaynwv
23-Oct-14
Will this buck gross 180? 190? More?
From: wvmule
23-Oct-14
wvbuckmaster, glad to hear that it is authentic.
sundaynwv, I will be anxious to hear what the measurements are. If anyone hears, please update this thread
From: ken
27-Oct-14
165 gross 154 net
From: WV Mountaineer
27-Oct-14
In the words of David Blanton, "That thing was a 165 about 2-3 years ago."
Goodness what a deer. Congrats to the hunter. God Bless
From: gobbler
27-Oct-14
That was the official green score by a certified scorer. It suprised me, it looks bigger.
From: WV Mountaineer
27-Oct-14
Unless the photo is VERY, VERY, VERY misleading, that score needs to be remeasured. That pic makes it appear MUCH, MUCH, MUCH larger than that measurement. Just sayin... God Bless
From: gobbler
27-Oct-14
I know and I agree. IDK??
From: sundaynwv
27-Oct-14
Based on the bottom pic, I was guessing 180, 190 or even more. I guess I am wrong and obviously never killed one this big.
From: JayD
27-Oct-14
Was that score from one side???? LOL What a deer!!!
From: Babysaph
27-Oct-14
I smell a rat
From: ken
27-Oct-14
certified pope and young scorer
From: wvmule
27-Oct-14
Kenny, is that a typical or non-typical score?
From: WVM&M
27-Oct-14
He should get scored again by different scorer just to confirm. That brute is awesome...when i first saw it i thought 180's. 15 scorable points. Awesome mass and length.
From: CGBowhunter
28-Oct-14
When you look at the one that was harvested illegally in Romney and that supposedly green scored 161. How does this one score 165?
From: ken
28-Oct-14
typical only one non typical point 4 inches off the left g3 still a great buck the buck was killed last week so its dry time will be up in late dec for official scoring
From: babysaph
28-Oct-14
Don't doubt he was scored.
From: babysaph
28-Oct-14
Don't doubt he was scored.
From: Big-Otis-Jeff
28-Oct-14
I think it was scored by Stevie Wonder..
From: ken
28-Oct-14
He was scored by greg surber and an official scorer for pope and young and records chair for wv.
From: ken
28-Oct-14
JR you don't have to doubt it anymore and Greg is not blind
From: Big-Otis-Jeff
28-Oct-14
Ken---Just having some fun, i am sure Greg is a competent scorer...
But he does look way bigger
From: ken
28-Oct-14
we see them here like that all the time you ought to drive thru chief logan in the am and watch one walk out right in front of you especially now there starting to chase
From: Babysaph
28-Oct-14
You need to re read my post . I said I do not doubt it was scored. Not doubt that he was scored.
From: Babysaph
28-Oct-14
My xwife used to live in Chapmanville and I used to go through Chief Logan and see those nice bucks. Used to see a few in your development Ken that were nice.
From: Babysaph
28-Oct-14
My xwife used to live in Chapmanville and I used to go through Chief Logan and see those nice bucks. Used to see a few in your development Ken that were nice.
From: Babysaph
28-Oct-14
In fact there used to be a nice albino in Chief Logan
From: ken
28-Oct-14
there are still albinos in the park/and there are a lot more big ones in the housing area/I reread your post still says the same thing/don't live in the same area anymore
From: Babysaph
28-Oct-14
I am not sure why you don't understand. I do not doubt that he was scored.
From: WV Mountaineer
28-Oct-14
I just don't get it. I just can't grasp it and never will unless I see the rack in person. I set here and type this across the room from a 150"+ typical ten point that isn't in the same zip code that deer is in. At least from the pics. Not even close. It just blows my mind.
I too was in the 180-190 range guessing from the pics. Not doubting the score ken so, no need to feel that way. I just can't grasp it from the pics. God Bless
From: Babysaph
28-Oct-14
It's not important. Its a nice buck.
From: Bob Dunn
29-Oct-14
No disrespect, but I would want a second opinion on a buck that big. See you in a couple of weeks Ken. ###=====>
From: ken
29-Oct-14
now bob you know every time your down here we have had to give you oxygen every evening because you vapor lock
From: babysaph
29-Oct-14
Well regardless of what he scores he is a nice buck
From: gobbler
29-Oct-14
JR, here's another one of Kenny's Logan bucks.
From: WVM&M
29-Oct-14
Where are the deer legs in second pic? Not doubting authenticity just looks funny.
From: Babysaph
29-Oct-14
Wow . Amazing
From: L.S.
30-Oct-14
Looks to me, like he is in a sink hole, prob. why we can't see his legs. That is a nice buck and it scoring 154 does not make him a lesser buck. That is why I could care less what a buck scores. Anyone that would not shoot a buck like that would be foolish in any state. Congrats to the man that killed him, you have a fine buck.
From: Bob Dunn
31-Oct-14
Will never forget the first year huntin at the lease in Mingo co. The first time I saw an adult, mature, monster of a buck. Actually left me shaken. Wow!!!
From: CGBowhunter
31-Oct-14
Largest buck I have ever seen while hunting was about 100 in. Not sure I would have to have someone pinch me if I saw something bigger. I know they are out there. Get trail pics.
From: wvmule
01-Nov-14
Gobbler, Kenny got a picture of a ghost deer? Scary!
From: Jack Whitmrie jr
02-Nov-14
From: gobbler
02-Nov-14
WVmule, well it was Halloween weekend.
