Mathews Inc.
P&Y whitetail nonresident
West Virginia
Contributors to this thread:
Limbhanger 29-Dec-17
gobbler 29-Dec-17
babysaph 29-Dec-17
DBoice 30-Dec-17
Jack Whitmrie jr 30-Dec-17
Jim Casto Jr 30-Dec-17
jwc3 31-Dec-17
From: Limbhanger
29-Dec-17
How many P&Y whitetails have you killed in other states? How many years hunting them there?

1in Ohio in 24 years got to get 2 scored so maybe 2-3 0 in Kentucky in 1 year 1 in wv in 38 years

From: gobbler
29-Dec-17
I’ve never killed a PY buck. I’ve got 5-6 between 120-124. All my other bucks between 130-140 were out of state gun or Muzzleloader kills. 2 of mine in low 120s were from bow counties. I’ve seen a good number of big bucks down there bowhunting but no shot opportunities

From: babysaph
29-Dec-17
7 in other states. several in 120's. 20 years of hunting them in other states. But this is on 4-6 day hunts per year. not near the amount of time I hunt here in WV

From: DBoice
30-Dec-17
2 from Ohio and 3 in WV. Been bow hunting Ohio for about 10 years and WV for 20.

30-Dec-17
1 from WV 131" another than grossed 127 but netted 122 5/8 in 42 years . Never got one in Ohio but saw them every year .

From: Jim Casto Jr
30-Dec-17
Hunted 11 years in other states. That's for one week hunts--so... 11 weeks. Killed three P & Y bucks, with one making B & C.

From: jwc3
31-Dec-17
Its to depressing to even think about. 6- 7 other p&y bucks of different species, coues, mule,blacktail and other whitetail. Time spent hunting in wv 99.5%, other states .5%. 6-7 in other states, 2 in WV.

  • Sitka Gear