Sitka Gear
Mattis Fired!
Community
Contributors to this thread:
Your fav poster 24-Dec-18
scentman 24-Dec-18
'Ike' (Phone) 24-Dec-18
Thumper 24-Dec-18
TD 26-Dec-18
Your fav poster 02-Jan-19
slade 02-Jan-19
KSflatlander 02-Jan-19
TD 02-Jan-19
Your fav poster 02-Jan-19
gflight 02-Jan-19
gflight 02-Jan-19
slade 02-Jan-19
gflight 02-Jan-19
TD 02-Jan-19
gflight 02-Jan-19
slade 02-Jan-19
KSflatlander 02-Jan-19
KSflatlander 02-Jan-19
slade 02-Jan-19
ben h 02-Jan-19
slade 02-Jan-19
scentman 03-Jan-19
scentman 03-Jan-19
gflight 03-Jan-19
scentman 03-Jan-19
scentman 03-Jan-19
Your fav poster 03-Jan-19
gflight 03-Jan-19
TD 03-Jan-19
gflight 03-Jan-19
23-Dec-18
Announced he would be leaving January first.

23-Dec-18

Habitat for Wildlife's Link
Sorry, forgot link.

23-Dec-18
Agreed, and if he is needed I am sure he is patriotic enough to give advice when asked.

24-Dec-18

From: scentman
24-Dec-18
Just off base a bit but relevant... Bush painted portraits of those lost during his Presidency... that to me was just so weird, Bush had my love and respect at the beginning... i no longer respect or take him seriously.

24-Dec-18
Poor PUTZ...

From: Thumper
24-Dec-18
Mattis wanted to stay until the end of feb or match, he thought he couldn't be replaced. Well, Trump handed him his hat and showed him the door.

Battle causalities really hit GW hard as he was he felt responsible. I knew he regularly still visits our wounded in the hospital and greats returning troops at the Dallas airport. Didn't know he painted the portraits of our fallen heroes. Others may forget but he never will. Are the paintings given to the Families? I bet they are. GW will never have my respect for being a good president, but he sure as hell has it for the way he threats those who have served this country.

24-Dec-18
Doorknob,

Seriously, on Christmas Eve?

He resigned, effective February 28th. The news reported Trump was upset with the press stories, and moved his departure date up. That is being fired.

Merry Christmas.

From: TD
26-Dec-18
There is a big difference between "not a yes man" and quitting because your advice offered was not taken. Trump I'm sure has many advisers on foreign policy, not just Mattis...... and he has the final say on policy. People in his administration are not fired for disagreeing. Basically they are fired for insubordination. It is one thing to disagree on policy. Totally another to go public with your feelings about your boss..... there is only room for the flexing of one ego, like it or not. That the reaction is a slap in the back of the head and don't let the door hit you in the azz when you leave should come as no surprise.

Mattis was a good commander by all accounts I have read, and likely is a student of foreign policy, not just military operations and efficiency. He may prove to be right on this matter. Or not. He was leaving soon anyway...... always said so before accepting the position, all agreed upon. He helped put the military back on track instead of a cheap way to get gender reassignment...... of that it seems he did a great job, turning the military back into the machine it was intended.

In many ways it was a brilliant move on his part. His legacy and reputation remain mostly intact. If he was right he can come back and give em an I told you so and add to his legacy. If wrong...... nobody will remember he walked away. Because if he was wrong..... there will be no newsworthy event that will prove it, by definition no or few big/bad events would be success. And the media will never print news that everything went smoothly and the war to hunt down ISIS continues, that Trump had it right...... a win-win. Legacy and reputation fully intact. Leftists and media will see to that.

Posted on a different thread..... but fits here well....

02-Jan-19
Draft-dodger Trump says he ‘would have been a good general’ while trashing James Mattis in Cabinet meeting.

Do not call yourself a fan of our veterans if you continue to support Capt Bone Spurs while he trashes Mad Dog Mattis. Trump could t spit shine Mattis’ boots let alone compare to him.

And not a peep from the hard chargers on CF? Why because you’re torn between supporting your hero vs standing up for an ACTUAL hero? Pathetic

02-Jan-19

your favorite poster's Link
prove what claim? that he bad mouthed Mattis? Direct quotes: "“What’s he done for me? How has he done in Afghanistan? Not too good,” “I’m not happy with what he’s done in Afghanistan and I shouldn’t be happy.” As if trump would know what to do in Afghanistan? Mattis kept our guys alive and fighting. To disparage him is to disparage our militaries best and brightest.

Hang your head in shame if you support trumps words against Mattis.

From: slade
02-Jan-19

slade's Link

From: KSflatlander
02-Jan-19
Only in Trump world could a resignation be considered a firing. Oh the vanity...

02-Jan-19
Trump: "would I have made a good general? Maybe, probably, who knows?"

hahahaha General Bone Spurs!

From: TD
02-Jan-19
That wasn't a resignation. That was insubordination. Several of Trumps appointments have resigned and moved on. Nothing said but shake hands and have a nice life. But you mouth off about the boss like he did, you're gonna get a slap on the back of the head. You can't get away with having it both ways. Not gonna happen.

Some of you need to try it at work some time, see how it all shakes out for ya. Lets start with PutZ..... let us know how it works out.......... dum bass

02-Jan-19
You have no proof that Mattis was insubordinate. Oh you mean when trump tried to do something improper and his advisor advised him NOT TO?

Um that’s called advising and deferring to the experts.

Oh is this where you try to convince us that trump knows more about foreign affairs and defense of our nation MORE than Mattis.

Please do! I could use a good laugh.

From: gflight
02-Jan-19

gflight's embedded Photo
This was October and Trump's numbers were declining...
gflight's embedded Photo
This was October and Trump's numbers were declining...
Don't know what happened. Left is Trump. Right is Mattis....

From: gflight
02-Jan-19
Similar to past polls, Mattis has a favorable rating among troops of nearly 84 percent. Support among officers increased in the last year, with more than 89 percent voicing a favorable opinion.

From: slade
02-Jan-19
Hey Glie, you mean the same Mattis who is on the board of directors for the Center for a New American Security. You know the left leaning organization who are pro-gun control.

02-Jan-19
Has Mattis stated a gun control position?

Properly functioning boards are supposed to be populated with diverse opinions. If he is pro gun control, show proof. Being on a board does not necessarily prove he is of the same mindset.

From: gflight
02-Jan-19
I praised Trump for listening to his Generals about ROE.

He is apparently veering away from listening to the smart people now.

Mattis knows mission command Trump obviously doesn't.

This seems like a classic 0bama move...

From: TD
02-Jan-19
If you "resigned" your position and wrote what Mattis wrote..... fired is what you would be. As in escorted out of the building, don't come back on property. If you personally would keep someone who "resigned" to you in such a manner you'd keep em on anther 2 months..... just cuz you were such a nice guy...... you've never fired anyone....

Good grief. When is the last time you folks fired someone or took their resignation?

Mattis would have been summarily canned if this were done to a superior officer when he was a member of the military. Not toddled along until he felt like walking away. Tell me he wouldn't..... what would have been his treatment by the military?

02-Jan-19
TD,

I agree with you. Trump is the top guy, he must be listened to, right or wrong.

I separate with those suffering from CDS who now are willing to drag him through the mud though they once sang his praises.

Trump did what he had to, that doesn't mean Mattis is a flaming liberal. I would take him over Trump in my foxhole if the proverbial crap hit the fan. And I bet any sane person would as well.

From: gflight
02-Jan-19
HH would rather have a liberal loggie than a GO running our defense?

Pelosi really got to Trump cause he is out to please her like he did Fienstein....

From: slade
02-Jan-19
So tell us armchair commanders, how many more billions and worse, American lives is Trump supposed to keep giving for the shithole Afghanistan?

From: KSflatlander
02-Jan-19
The emperor has no clothes and he will surround himself with tailors of imaginary garments. Now that is a scary scenario.

From: KSflatlander
02-Jan-19
We aren’t armchair commanders, we are as informed as Trump. We get our info from the same place...Fox and Friends.

02-Jan-19
Nice diversion Slade, typical of your Trump like integrity.

From: slade
02-Jan-19
So in other words Maverick, nothing except your TDS. By the way, Mitt is calling and is looking for boot lickers like yourself.

02-Jan-19
Your neck must have snapped months ago from your god jerking people around as much as he does.

Sit by your mom's basement phone. Trump's new Chief of Staff will be calling you any minute to interview as Defense Secretary. You have about as much experience googling as will anyone who is willing to take the position now.

From: ben h
02-Jan-19
I've resigned from several positions due to disagreeing with higher-ups. In both instances I've offered time to transition a new person to fill my role. Each time they said, thanks for your time, please escort yourself out of the building, we'll send your personal belongings and I never went back to my office. That's a pretty standard approach for these types of things depending on your position. I wouldn't call that a firing; he resigned and said he'd stick around through Feb as I recall and they said no, December is fine.

From: slade
02-Jan-19
""President Donald Trump defended his decision to fire his Defense Secretary Gen. Jim Mattis, saying he was not pleased with progress on the war in Afghanistan. “What’s he done for me? How has he done in Afghanistan? Not too good, not too good,” Trump said. “I’m not happy with what he’s done in Afghanistan, and I shouldn’t be happy.”""

So tell us Commander Maverick, how many more billions and worse, American lives is Trump supposed to keep giving for the shithole Afghanistan?

02-Jan-19
Go ahead, keep diverting basement boy. You are licking more than Trump's boots.

02-Jan-19
Seriously Slade, a quote from Trump to defend your position? That is laughable. The guy took his first trip to visit troops just last week, and now he is an expert.

You really do have CDS.

03-Jan-19
So Mattis is willing to let more men die so his general buddies could make money? Is that not the definition of a traitor?

I guess we will have to see if it is a great strategy. I wonder what the Kurds think? Maybe they received some of the Kool-Aid by now?

Trump's ability to solve problems seems phenomenal. Wonder why he never applied it to his marriages?

Scratch that last question, pass the Kool-Aid please.

From: scentman
03-Jan-19
Let it play out...easy to be a keyboard world leader. Remember Rocky all bloodied, eyes swollen?... Yo Adrian, Trumps has taken 100x's more hits and he is as pretty as Ali.

03-Jan-19
I respect immensely your having been a high level NCO.

Here's my confusion, if you will. You are trying to sell us that a man who has displayed a lifetime of integrity, has the overwhelming support, 89%, of the officers he commanded, would flush that all down the drain for some consultant fees for his buddies?

Ok, if I accept that, then the leap to believing Trump has money/business connections that are affecting his decisions is just a little more credible than you trumpettes are willing to concede.

FTR, I don't think either of those have happened. I believe this is very disgraceful running a highly respected individual through the mud. It is what I have come to expect from Trump.

Yes, Mattis was out of line for commenting. But the president has to be the bigger man/leader. This is what Romney was referring to about his failure to act presidential.

Still too early to tell, and I am not making predictions, but look at Sieb's WSJ editorial today. My words here, but Trump fatigue is a factor that is going to play in the next election.

03-Jan-19
Scentman,

Rocky was a movie that only mimicked life;)

From: scentman
03-Jan-19
I guess my point was missed... but than I wouldn't expect you to come down to my level :0)

From: gflight
03-Jan-19
So are you saying it is the Russians there HH?

From: scentman
03-Jan-19
Most of you fella's I am sure have High I Q's and are very successful in life, it shows by your comments and the knowledge you put forth every day on this CF... I have learned so much reading these posts for about 7 yrs now and it has made me a bit more keen to politics and life... that being said I don't believe the smartest chap on this site could keep wits with Trump, the man is a genius... like I said before, he plays chess, they play checkers.

03-Jan-19
I believe he does play with chess pieces and is still trying to get them in the right order, just like with his cabinet;)

Scentman, I am not going to apologize for my style. I always assume I am the least tough and dumbest guy in any situation. That doesn't stop me from expressing my views, nor would I want you to.

I do have a question though. When Obama was president, I remember all of the critism on the CF about his lack of military experience, with Trump he seems to get a free pass because???? Bone spurs????

As I did my normal walk this morning, I reflected on HH's comments regarding the great strategy. Slade quotes Trump laying blame on Mattis for Afghanistan. Now, the latest is this is a great strategy for Syria. Which is it? HH, more plausible to me is Trump loyalists had enough time to put a great spin on what also has leaked out of the WH, Trump's impulsive decision making style.

That's what I believe at this point. Trump made another impulsive decision, Mattis's patience had already grown thin, and what we see is what played out.

I guess we might have to wait for a presidential library to know the full truth. They should be breaking ground for it in Moscow in a little over two years by my reckoning;)

03-Jan-19
You have to ask if I was serious about that? I had the wink. It was a shot at Dems.

From: scentman
03-Jan-19
Some yrs back I worked for a gentleman that was very crass and demanding of his people, he was disliked by everyone including the people that hired him as a Director. This guy was so disliked we all could not wait for him to get fired or quit... he demanded respect from his employees and vendors alike, and he got it... our dept. ran efficiently and smooth because we feared this boss. Well we all got our wish the day he retired, he left, a new tool took over with way less experience and spaghetti for a spine... place went down hill 80% from the day he left they have yet to recover from the poor decisions made by new management. Be careful what you wish for. Habitat, no apology necessary... just bustn your chop,s hence the face with a smile.

03-Jan-19
Spike, Obama didn’t make up a fictitious injury to avoid serving. Huge difference.

From: gflight
03-Jan-19
Scentman,

Sometimes it takes a toxic leader and sometimes you lose talent because of them.....

03-Jan-19
Textbook answer here, but effective leadership plans for succession. Both leaders failed, it just took time to realize it with the first.

Common problem when an organization has a strong leader on outside appearances.

From: TD
03-Jan-19

TD's Link
Obama just buried his college records, that's all..... if there was a draft in his time...... I'm guessing he would STILL be an Indonesian foreign student......

Facts matter. History matters. Obama himself fired Mattis, well, not personally of course, not even a phone call. He had a messenger tell him he was fired.... over Iran it seems, fairly similar reasons. Where was all that righteous indignation by you folks then? Surely wasn't a different Mattis then. But the outrage has obviously been saved for a different President.

Good grief..... PutZ I don't think I have EVER seen a bigger hypocrite. Surely not one who was as knowingly and blatantly so. You care nothing for facts, much less their equal treatment. All you have to live for is your hate....

03-Jan-19
Spike,

That is hilarious asking Paul if he inspected Trump's feet.

How about you "inspect" some of that whacko conspiracy stuff before you post it. LOL!

03-Jan-19
Yes, that's true Jeff. For Spike there is no proof for 80% of it. That puts Paul in a category by himself.

From: gflight
03-Jan-19
He is a circumstantial evidence draft dodger...

We only know that the draft record images online show that he was deferred for college, played sports those years and then for the last deferment then he suddenly had bone spurs.

Funny we can find Trump's stuff but not 0bamas.....

  • Sitka Gear