deer ribs
General Topic
Contributors to this thread:
PECO 23-Oct-19
Zackman 23-Oct-19
BTM 23-Oct-19
RogBow 23-Oct-19
FrigidArrows 23-Oct-19
cnelk 23-Oct-19
APauls 23-Oct-19
stick n string 23-Oct-19
JohnMC 23-Oct-19
PushCoArcher 23-Oct-19
PECO 23-Oct-19
Grubby 23-Oct-19
TrapperKayak 23-Oct-19
Dirk Diggler 23-Oct-19
Vonfoust 23-Oct-19
cnelk 23-Oct-19
PECO 24-Oct-19
WapitiBob 24-Oct-19
Quinn @work 24-Oct-19
cnelk 24-Oct-19
Woods Walker 24-Oct-19
greg simon 24-Oct-19
Inshart 25-Oct-19
Snuffer 25-Oct-19
Grey Ghost 25-Oct-19
bluedog 25-Oct-19
Shug 26-Oct-19
Quinn @work 26-Oct-19
Ben 26-Oct-19
PECO 26-Oct-19
Dirk Diggler 27-Oct-19
IdyllwildArcher 27-Oct-19
Huntiam 27-Oct-19
cnelk 27-Oct-19
From: PECO
23-Oct-19

PECO's embedded Photo
PECO's embedded Photo
My brother got a young mule deer buck (muzzleloader) and we saved the ribs. Yesterday I seasoned them, put on the grill for a few minutes, then put in crockpot. They were very tender and meat fell off of the bone, tasty. How many others ever save and cook up the ribs? This is the first time, I've tried it, the deer seemed to have a lot more meat in the rib area than any other deer I've butchered.

From: Zackman
23-Oct-19
Most of the time. Love them!

From: BTM
23-Oct-19
Always amazes me how many hunters won't take the ribs. I've grabbed as many as six rib cages left by others in camp. Their loss!

From: RogBow
23-Oct-19
I braise then smoke the ribs. Very good.

From: FrigidArrows
23-Oct-19
I tried once, but I must have done something wrong. Very nasty pasty aftertaste left in my mouth after every bite. This was a WT, don't know if that makes a difference? Pointers?

From: cnelk
23-Oct-19
Ive smoked antelope and WT ribs. Dont bother with the antelope..... :(

The WT ribs were tasty - doing the 3-2-1 method

From: APauls
23-Oct-19
I smoked some last year doing 3-2-1, and mine were still tallowy. Not doing it again.

23-Oct-19
Tallowy here too... i find myself trying to trim any fat/silver skin off which is impossible. But man do i want it to work. Maybe my PA deer dont have enough meat on their ribs?

From: JohnMC
23-Oct-19

JohnMC's Link
Hope Matt does not mind be sharing this but after seeing him post this a while back I always wanted to try.

From: PushCoArcher
23-Oct-19
I prefer to start them in the crockpot and then pull them out before they begin to fall apart (about 2 hours) and finish them on the grill with your favorite bbq sauce. Best way to make bbq deer ribs I've found believe I got that recipe out of my meateater cookbook. As for the meat quality argument I agree it's a waste to leave them but it's probably my least favorite cut on a deer usually just cut the meat out and grind it.

From: PECO
23-Oct-19
I have a few more in the freezer. I will boil/instapot them first next time.

From: Grubby
23-Oct-19
I like them, I crockpot first then on the grill.

From: TrapperKayak
23-Oct-19
FrigidArrows, THIS >>>------> Looks great esp. if you can skim off the hardened white fat from the crock pot by cooling it first, and reheat before eating it. The grease that sticks to your tongue otherwise, is not that healthy to consume. I bet they taste great! I'll have to try that.

From: Dirk Diggler
23-Oct-19
Save them when I'm close to the road, rarely. Crockpot till they begin to release from the bone, smoker with a little mesquite or hickory, into the oven with a little bbq sauce. Saved my antelope ribs this year. Cnelk, what didn't you like about em? Haven't tried em yet.

From: Vonfoust
23-Oct-19
Always tallowy here as well. Going to give it another shot with the 3-2-1 this year.

From: cnelk
23-Oct-19
@Diggler - Give them antelope ribs a shot. You may like them

From: PECO
24-Oct-19
3-2-1?

From: WapitiBob
24-Oct-19
Tried Elk ribs once. Gawd awful, like chewing on a block of bees wax.

From: Quinn @work
24-Oct-19
Anyone have any luck getting rid of the pasty chalky take from the fat? Elk can be ok by deer and antelope have the pasty chalky taste real bad. Any ideas? Maybe cook them off in a crock pot and remove to smoke where the fat has liquified and come off the meat in the crock?

Paste with beef fat prior to smoking? Looking for ideas because we’re going to be doing some young bull elk ribs soon.

From: cnelk
24-Oct-19
Google '3-2-1 Ribs'

From: Woods Walker
24-Oct-19
Pat: Bowsite needs a "Drool Thread" warning!!!

From: greg simon
24-Oct-19
My favorite deer ribs recipe involves throwing the ribs out and eating something else.

I’ve tried them enough ways that I leave the ribs on the carcass now.

From: Inshart
25-Oct-19
This is how my Mom (and Dad) did them from the farm. It's a bit time consuming, but well worth it!

I never actually watched her but this is how she said she did them. Mom used to cut them into 6 to 8 inch pieces then boil them in a big pot. Hold the ribs down and pour out the water, fat came to the top, pour that out as well. NEVER, NEVER let the ribs come up through the fat/tallow - that's where you get the disgusting flavor.

Same thing again - boil and dump. The boiling removes the tallowy flavor as well as tenderizes.

Then dad would do them on the grill - he always made his own BBQ sauce (sure wish I had his recipe). They were absolutely the best, fall of the bone, ribs ever.

From: Snuffer
25-Oct-19
Just by a bucket of lard at costco and smear it on toast.

From: Grey Ghost
25-Oct-19
All my rib meat goes into the burger pile.

Matt

From: bluedog
25-Oct-19
I like to hang them on tree limbs in the yard. The birds enjoy picking them all winter. By March they're just shiny bones.

From: Shug
26-Oct-19
I clean them considerably leaving mostly the meat between the ribs and just a small amount of the outer layer. The one thing I do is boil them first... I put a gallon of Orange Juice and water into a large pot It sweeten and breaks down the meat . I then cook them on the grill with BBQ sauce... really really good that way

From: Quinn @work
26-Oct-19
Ok this thread has pretty much confirmed I’ll leave the ribs for the coyotes and magpies.

From: Ben
26-Oct-19
I've tried whitetail ribs twice probably 40 years ago and I am still trying to get the tallow off the roof of my mouth. I'd rather kiss a Wookie! LOL

From: PECO
26-Oct-19
Quinn, I have in the past put them up in the woods behind my house, with a trail cam on them. Excited to get some great trail cam pix, I get a million pictures of magpies.

From: Dirk Diggler
27-Oct-19

Dirk Diggler's Link
Heres a link to the 3-2-1 method, I'd never heard of it. I just crockpot em till they're ready to fall off the bone, give em a quick smoke, and bake em a bit with some bbq sauce.

27-Oct-19
I love the tallow/fat. The Inuit prize caribou ribs more than the rest of the animal. They make a soup that is so fatty and the tallow on your palate is the gift that keeps on giving.

My kids love game ribs. The only meal they like more from game is slow-cooked shanks. I use cnelk's 3-2-1 method. They're delicious.

Animals that are covered in a layer of fat are not as good a choice as a slender animal.

Moose ribs are amazing. I've enjoyed a couple elk and lots of white tails ribs. I saved a few mountain goat ribs and I wish I'd carried them all out. The only problem with them is that they're really long like moose ribs and you have to cut them in 1/2.

Do yourself a favor and if you kill a fawn, pull the ribs. They're really good. There's not much meat, but if you slow cook them, you can just pull the bones right out and eat it like a candy bar.

It's like anything else in game meat. If you're hung up on your meat being as close to beef, pork, and chicken as game can be, then you'll be disappointed. Let go of that and enjoy it like it's all you've ever eaten and you'll love them. It goes the same for organ meats, slow cooked tendon, marrow, tongue, etc. Most people wouldn't like whale blubber either. But if you grew up with it, it's a delicacy. And it's delicious.

I was a picky kid and my grandpa told me that if I learned to like everything, then I'd enjoy my food and my life more because I'd like more things. He was always right.

From: Huntiam
27-Oct-19
Then look delicious .. I’ve tried WT ribs several times smoking them crock pot both I can’t get them right I don’t bother with them anymore ...

From: cnelk
27-Oct-19

cnelk's Link
Here’s the thread I did a couple years ago when I did some 3-2-1 ribs. See link

  • Sitka Gear