Summit Treestands
Who's killed NM Ibex or Oryx?
Hogs
Contributors to this thread:
midwest 10-Jun-11
flyingbrass 10-Jun-11
Ki-Ke 10-Jun-11
2NOLANS 10-Jun-11
medicinemann 11-Jun-11
flyingbrass 11-Jun-11
ABQBW 11-Jun-11
city hunter 11-Jun-11
midwest 11-Jun-11
Watts 11-Jun-11
Gus 11-Jun-11
Gus 11-Jun-11
AlexW. 11-Jun-11
Gus 11-Jun-11
midwest 11-Jun-11
Chronic 11-Jun-11
Watts 11-Jun-11
Watts 11-Jun-11
Watts 11-Jun-11
city hunter 12-Jun-11
Gus 12-Jun-11
2NOLANS 12-Jun-11
midwest 12-Jun-11
OregonArcher 12-Jun-11
DonVathome 13-Jun-11
city hunter 13-Jun-11
elkmtngear 13-Jun-11
'Ike' - Phone 13-Jun-11
nvbowhuntress 01-Mar-16
HDE 01-Mar-16
bradbear 01-Mar-16
flyingbrass 01-Mar-16
flyingbrass 01-Mar-16
JacobNisley 02-Mar-16
midwest 02-Mar-16
bradbear 02-Mar-16
HDE 02-Mar-16
TeamWarrior 02-Mar-16
TeamWarrior 02-Mar-16
BTM 02-Mar-16
flyingbrass 02-Mar-16
bentstick 02-Mar-16
bentstick 02-Mar-16
bentstick 02-Mar-16
EmbryOklahoma 02-Mar-16
jims 02-Mar-16
arctichill 02-Mar-16
midwest 03-Mar-16
HDE 03-Mar-16
flyingbrass 03-Mar-16
bentstick 03-Mar-16
From: midwest
10-Jun-11
Would love to see pics and hear the stories of any bow killed, free range Ibex or Oryx from NM.

From: flyingbrass
10-Jun-11
I don't think you will see any! Just saying. I shot a nice oryx in NM with a gun and there ain't no way in hell you could kill one there in 2 days with a bow especially since there is absolutely no pre scouting! They are alot wilder than you think. They have continued to cut tags. I'll be surprised to see one example of a free range once in a lifetime oryx but I have been wrong before.

From: Ki-Ke
10-Jun-11
I think I remember an article in Eastmans BH Journal a couple of years ago from a guy that killed an Ibex with a bow. I'm sure he's not the only one.

I would LOVE to do that hunt. Shot down in the draw this year....

From: 2NOLANS
10-Jun-11
I don't have pictures but a friend of mine from Alaska guides with a guy in NM for ibex.He has shot two with a bow!I'll try to get ahold of the pictures,but he is hard to reach because he works on the north slope and don't always return emails very quikly.This being said it obviously can be done!

From: medicinemann
11-Jun-11
I believe that Darren Collins killed an ibex with his bow....

From: flyingbrass
11-Jun-11

flyingbrass's embedded Photo
flyingbrass's embedded Photo
I still stand by my ruling. Almost impossible to kill an oryx in a place you can't scout, an animal you never hunted, and it's a once in a lifetime hunt and you are limited to only 2 days. Success rates were not that high last year on Rhodes Canyon so if they can't get it done with a gun it would be much harder with a bow. Not to mention the fee to access the gubberment land which was over $200 plus the high dollar tag of $1600 or whatever it is. Come to think of it I think they changed oryx to a 3 day hunt since success rates were so low with a gun. Anyway here is my 40.5" bull with a gun. I try not to post gun kills here but it seems ok in this instance since there won't be a WSMR oryx bow kill posted. LOL, I am really setting myself up to eat crow probably. I can't comment on Ibex but I'd like to hunt one.

From: ABQBW
11-Jun-11
Ibex isn't that hard with a bow. The success rate is at least 0.5%! It's going to go up to 0.51% after I'm done this winter. HaHa.

From: city hunter
11-Jun-11
The Ibex with bow would be a great feat , ABQBW see u on them mountains ,,

From: midwest
11-Jun-11
Very cool, fb!

From: Watts
11-Jun-11
Jake,

That is correct. Darrin Collins did kill one with a bow. He was a wealth of information to me when I went. I don't think there's anything Darrin has hunted that he hasn't killed though. He's a natural!

Another guy who killed a beauty while I was out there was a guy named Riley Manzonie. He is the owner of Currant Creek Outfitters in NV, and one helluva bowhunter. I know he's also taken an Oryx.

Don't have any pictures of ibex or oryx, but I think I do have a picture of a monkey washing a cat? ;^)

Watts

From: Gus
11-Jun-11

Gus's embedded Photo
Gus's embedded Photo
i killed this ibex in 2008. a great hunt. awesome animals.

From: Gus
11-Jun-11

Gus's embedded Photo
Gus's embedded Photo
here is another one that Bim killed while I hunted with him. at the time, this one was the world record persian ibex killed with a bow in 2008.

From: AlexW.
11-Jun-11
Gus,

Great Animals,

What happened to that second one, did it roll or fall? With both front legs/knees and back left side of belly and ham bloody, it just seems like that was quite the show of the wheels coming off the bus after the shot.

What an amazing accomplishment. Alex

From: Gus
11-Jun-11
Alex, we tried to clean him up the best we could for that photo. they had to sneak up on him for a second shot plus the terrain is rocky and very steep.

From: midwest
11-Jun-11
Gus,

Awesome animals is right. Unreal.

Watts,

Post it up! lol

From: Chronic
11-Jun-11
awesome thread. thats one of my dream hunts...and Ibex with a bow!!

I wonder if they can be hunted in the Alps...Id rather go to Europe than NM!

From: Watts
11-Jun-11
[IMG]http://i212.photobucket.com/albums/cc296/Laughing_Gull/monkey-washing-a-cat.gif[/IMG]

Here you go. For the record, I tried like hell to get a good grip-n-grin with an ibex. Damn things just woulddn't cooperate!

Gus,

Those goats are truely something!! That looks like just south of the Little Florida's, correct?

Watts

From: Watts
11-Jun-11
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9wAqNN-Dic&feature=player_detailpage

Let's try this again.

From: Watts
11-Jun-11
Oh, just cut and paste the above link. Fricken computers! :^(

From: city hunter
12-Jun-11
gus congras but do tell about your hunt how far the shot etc etc etc any other opps ,,

From: Gus
12-Jun-11
a small herd was climbing up the canyon to get away from some other hunters and they came across the area I was in. The billie I ended up killing, jumped off the cliff face above me and landed on the ledge I was on. he landed on the other side of a juniper bush about 6 feet away. the dust from his landing surrounded me. I had heard them coming and so I had an arrow nocked already. he tried looking through the juniper bush at me and then started to walk out on the ledge we were both on to look at the other hunters that had spooked him and the other ibex. as he looked down the canyon, he was quartering away at about 4 or 5 yards. I came to full draw but he picked up the movement (it's like they have eyes on the back of their head) and he jumped off the cliff face.

when he jumped off that cliff, he landed about 25 yards below but to get out of the area, he had to climb the opposite face. I had ranged every thing on that face and when he paused by a rock that I had ranged at 35 yards, I shot him. He was quartering away and the arrow entered behind the last rib and exited behind the far shoulder.

he ran up the cliff face and died at the top and got stuck in a crevass in the face. it was about 10 stories straight up and no way to retrieve him. I had to hire a rock climber with all the safety gear to lower him down the cliff face for me the next day.

From: 2NOLANS
12-Jun-11
Well looks like Gus beat me to it,couldn't find my pics.Bim Blake is who I was referring to.

From: midwest
12-Jun-11
Wow, Gus, what a story. Congrats again.

From: OregonArcher
12-Jun-11
nice story. I also drew a tag this winter. pretty stoked. nice pics. ibex are just impressive

From: DonVathome
13-Jun-11
Oryx with bow is doable, but time limit hurts, bad. I bowhunted 1-1/4 days and came really close then tagged out rifle.

From: city hunter
13-Jun-11
Gus great shot wow it would be safe to say these mountains are nasty .

From: elkmtngear
13-Jun-11

elkmtngear's Link
Gus, that is an amazing story!! What an adventure!

Best of Luck, Jeff

13-Jun-11
That's a fantastic story and an awesome animal Gus!

-Matt n Cheryl

13-Jun-11
Way to go Gus...

01-Mar-16

nvbowhuntress's embedded Photo
nvbowhuntress's embedded Photo
Here is my brother Riley Manzonie's record archery Ibex

From: HDE
01-Mar-16
The best way to get an oryx with a bow is to do the off range hunt, either public land draw or private OTC. You have a month that way...

I agree, they are pretty wild, but it would be neat to get one with a bow. I thought about it this year on my Feb hunt, but opted to just take the easy way out. Their meat is too good to worry about a bow kill.

From: bradbear
01-Mar-16
My Ibex was with muzzleloader, I actually ate my Oryx tag. Drew them both my first year applying

From: flyingbrass
01-Mar-16
kill rate on NM oryx isn't as high as you think with rifle, look at the odds!

From: flyingbrass
01-Mar-16
and Ibex is way way worse!

From: JacobNisley
02-Mar-16
Just wondering why everyone calls them oryx in the states while the same people would call them gemsbok in Africa. Is it simply because that's what the game commission calls them?

From: midwest
02-Mar-16
Congrats to Riley! Wow!

From: bradbear
02-Mar-16
No real excuse for me on the Oryx. Think I drew it too early in my hunting learning process.....lots of mistakes.

I have not posted any Ibex photos as not bow. But here you go if you want https://picasaweb.google.com/115516601528181241557/Ibex?authkey=Gv1sRgCILiwqu5ioS6tgE

From: HDE
02-Mar-16
Kill rates may not be as high on oryx, but the opportunities to do so are way higher than one would think as well.

Out of 13 oryx hunts I've been on, 11 kills and two no kills. On the two, opportunities were presented but resulted in misses.

From: TeamWarrior
02-Mar-16
A buddy of mine from 2015

From: TeamWarrior
02-Mar-16

TeamWarrior's MOBILE embedded Photo
TeamWarrior's MOBILE embedded Photo

A buddy of mine from 2015

From: BTM
02-Mar-16
"I don't think you will see any! Just saying. I shot a nice oryx in NM with a gun and there ain't no way in hell you could kill one there in 2 days with a bow especially since there is absolutely no pre-scouting! They are alot wilder than you think."

I did the White Sands oryx hunt 6-7 years ago. I didn't like the two-day limit, high tag cost, Oklahoma Land Rush atmosphere, etc. To each his own, I suppose. Did manage to rifle kill one at long range.

From: flyingbrass
02-Mar-16
Don't forget the fee to the US Guberment to hunt! Is it $200 or $250 for that fee?

From: bentstick
02-Mar-16
here's mine from 2011:

From: bentstick
02-Mar-16

bentstick's embedded Photo
bentstick's embedded Photo

From: bentstick
02-Mar-16

bentstick's embedded Photo
bentstick's embedded Photo
and here's one from 2015

02-Mar-16
Very nice, Lance! That would definitely be a hunt I'd love to do!

From: jims
02-Mar-16
It's obvious from the pics above that it's possible to harvest an ibex w/bow...although a tough chore. We haven't seen 1 photo of a NM oryx harvested during the short 2 or 3 day base hunts! I was fortunate to harvest a whopper oryx with rifle on one of these hunts but I would have to agree with the majority of those that have said that an on base oryx would be super tough with bow.

From: arctichill
02-Mar-16
I know one guy who arrowed an oryx with a bow and then the oryx entered a "closed area" and although the shot was good, the area was 100% off limits and even military personnel would not enter the area....animal lost.

I know another guy who successfully harvested and recovered a very nice oryx with a bow on a "badge hunt".

I believe ibex require more luck than oryx to get with a bow. My good friend "smarba" [his handle on this site] has taken two gorgeous ibex with his bow....very impressive!

From: midwest
03-Mar-16
Outstanding, bentstick! Great pics and fantastic trophies!

From: HDE
03-Mar-16
JacobNisley

Africa calls them Gemsbok which is a Danish word for "tan buck" or something like that.

We call them Oryx in NM because of the taxonomy of 'Oryx Gazella'

From: flyingbrass
03-Mar-16
I didn't say tough. I said "Almost impossible to kill an oryx in a place you can't scout, an animal you never hunted, and it's a once in a lifetime hunt and you are limited to only 2 days"

From: bentstick
03-Mar-16
I'll give it a go if I can ever draw.

  • Sitka Gear