Summit Treestands
Will he make PY?
Whitetail Deer
Contributors to this thread:
Big-Al 30-Oct-18
Michael 30-Oct-18
Duke 30-Oct-18
Dirk Diggler 30-Oct-18
JohnMC 30-Oct-18
Big-Al 30-Oct-18
WV Mountaineer 30-Oct-18
JohnMC 30-Oct-18
APauls 31-Oct-18
Big-Al 31-Oct-18
Big-Al 31-Oct-18
JohnMC 31-Oct-18
BigOk 31-Oct-18
rattling_junkie 31-Oct-18
Franklin 31-Oct-18
Quinn @work 31-Oct-18
pav 31-Oct-18
Trial153 31-Oct-18
Mule Power 31-Oct-18
cnelk 31-Oct-18
dakotaduner 31-Oct-18
arlone 31-Oct-18
Deerplotter 31-Oct-18
Skippy 31-Oct-18
Ollie 31-Oct-18
InRut-KB-Bowhunter 31-Oct-18
Jack Harris 31-Oct-18
BIG BEAR 31-Oct-18
Big-Al 31-Oct-18
Franzen 31-Oct-18
ROUGHCOUNTRY 31-Oct-18
BIG BEAR 31-Oct-18
Shawn 31-Oct-18
From: Big-Al
30-Oct-18

Big-Al's embedded Photo
Big-Al's embedded Photo
Missing his left G4, will he make the 125" minimum?

From: Michael
30-Oct-18
Short answer is no. Nice deer but not 125.

From: Duke
30-Oct-18
Gross 125, but not P&Y. Nonetheless, great buck!!!

From: Dirk Diggler
30-Oct-18
I'll play. I'm a yes vote. Lookin forward to a peak at that score sheet.

From: JohnMC
30-Oct-18
Will be close but deduction will hurt net score. Bring up p&y scoring sheet and follow and you should be able to get close.

From: Big-Al
30-Oct-18
Lack of antler hurt a bit, but the net deductions were only 3 2/8....

30-Oct-18
No. Unless that picture is misleading. 115 range at best from what I can tell.

From: JohnMC
30-Oct-18
There more than 3 2/8” deductions. All of the G4 is a deduction since he only has a right one.

From: APauls
31-Oct-18
I can't see it. You essentially get to "keep" his smaller side G1, G2, G3, then the G4 which is what makes that side nicer to look at is a deduction. On the other side you have more height but it doesn't matter in a net score. Sorry, don't think it will make it but who cares. Congrats on a nice buck!

From: Big-Al
31-Oct-18
I didn't realize that was a deduction. He grosses 132 3/8.

From: Big-Al
31-Oct-18
123 3/8 with deductions as far as I can tell. Still proud of this of him and he'll be a nice addition to my euor-wall.

From: JohnMC
31-Oct-18

JohnMC's Link
Follow this step by step.

From: BigOk
31-Oct-18
Either way, Nice deer

31-Oct-18
Great buck, who cares about score.

From: Franklin
31-Oct-18
Nice buck....regardless. If he doesn`t have a broken tine he is a 130 class deer. He grew it to be able to break it off....so he`s a "130 class deer".

From: Quinn @work
31-Oct-18
Won't make P+Y due to the broken tine. Nice buck though so who cares. Great bow kill to be proud of.

FWIW it looks like a really young deer looking at it's face. Can't see it's body but he's probably only a 3.5 year old at most. Goes to show great genetics in the area you got him. He would of been a 140" deer next year since he was so young.

Nice job. Be proud, Will eat well.

From: pav
31-Oct-18
Without the broken G4....absolutely P&Y. With the broken G4....he's still knocking on the door, but as already pointed out, the deductions really hurt the net score.

From: Trial153
31-Oct-18
Nice buck for sure. Congrats

From: Mule Power
31-Oct-18
Would have made it for sure with the missing tine. 114 :-)

From: cnelk
31-Oct-18
How big were the backstraps? Thats what counts

From: dakotaduner
31-Oct-18
Beautiful deer congratulations. Lots of good eating. I like the picture too

From: arlone
31-Oct-18
Great buck! I guess I could care less if it was mine, but the missing point will probably keep it out of the book. Congratulations and thanks for the picture.

From: Deerplotter
31-Oct-18
Give the buck credit for what he did grow. Very nice- good job!

From: Skippy
31-Oct-18
Nets are for fishing, great buck. Congrats!

From: Ollie
31-Oct-18
I think he will be a few inches short. As an intact 5x5 he would probably just make it.

31-Oct-18
mids 130's yes

From: Jack Harris
31-Oct-18
I'll play. 17' spread, 28" mass, 20 inch beams. That's 85" so far.

Right side Gs… 6, 7, 8, 5... - 26".

Left side Gs 7, 9, 8.... - 24"

total G's - 50"

50 plus 85 = 135" gross.

Deductions in order -1, -2, -0, -5 = -8 deductions. (assuming non for mass or beams, but there probably are some minor).

NET = 127", or possibly less, but it just might squeak in. Would need more pics to get closer.

From: BIG BEAR
31-Oct-18
I killed a 9 pointer that grossed P&Y but netted just under. Mine had shorter tines but maybe a tad more mass. I think yours will make it.

From: Big-Al
31-Oct-18
Grossed 132 4/8 and netted 123 2/8. Young deer but he was a bruiser. Ripped and healed left ear and had a puncture wound in his right outer thigh.

From: Franzen
31-Oct-18
I had him at 126", very similar to Jack's numbers. Close, but too close. Off by less than 3", but that keeps him out.

From: ROUGHCOUNTRY
31-Oct-18
"Hope and Young"

From: BIG BEAR
31-Oct-18
A dandy for sure.... congrats !!!

From: Shawn
31-Oct-18
I would think he is close, mass measurements are tough to tell. I say he grosses over 125"s and may make 125"s net!! Nice buck either way!! Shawn

  • Sitka Gear