Black Gold Sights - Pure Gold
want to take a guess...
Whitetail Deer
Contributors to this thread:
Ty 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
EmbryOklahoma 30-Nov-18
Zbone 30-Nov-18
JohnMC 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
greg simon 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
APauls 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
sticksender 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
Brotsky 30-Nov-18
deerhunter72 30-Nov-18
Grunter 30-Nov-18
molsonarcher 30-Nov-18
cnelk 30-Nov-18
molsonarcher 30-Nov-18
Beav 30-Nov-18
Zbone 30-Nov-18
Will 30-Nov-18
Bake 30-Nov-18
stealthycat 30-Nov-18
BullBuster 30-Nov-18
Kodiak 30-Nov-18
INDBowhunter2 30-Nov-18
Ole Coyote 30-Nov-18
Michael 30-Nov-18
BigOk 30-Nov-18
Hawkeye 30-Nov-18
Treeline 30-Nov-18
Kodiak 30-Nov-18
Ty 30-Nov-18
Kodiak 30-Nov-18
T Mac 30-Nov-18
t-roy 01-Dec-18
deerslayer 01-Dec-18
Treeline 01-Dec-18
Paul@thefort 01-Dec-18
standswittaknife 01-Dec-18
LINK 01-Dec-18
Dirk Diggler 01-Dec-18
Dirk Diggler 01-Dec-18
Zbone 02-Dec-18
JayZ 02-Dec-18
Shawn 02-Dec-18
ELKMAN 02-Dec-18
Rock 02-Dec-18
WV Mountaineer 02-Dec-18
SBH 02-Dec-18
dirtclod Az. 02-Dec-18
Corn bore 02-Dec-18
Ty 02-Dec-18
Zbone 03-Dec-18
jdbbowhunter 03-Dec-18
midwest 03-Dec-18
njbuck 03-Dec-18
Hancock West 03-Dec-18
Mark Watkins 03-Dec-18
buc i 313 03-Dec-18
Duke 03-Dec-18
Ty 08-Dec-18
Ty 08-Dec-18
Franklin 08-Dec-18
Franklin 08-Dec-18
stealthycat 08-Dec-18
Shug 08-Dec-18
Elkhorn 09-Dec-18
BullBuster 09-Dec-18
Simple 09-Dec-18
Ty 11-Mar-19
Deerplotter 11-Mar-19
Zbone 11-Mar-19
Duke 11-Mar-19
wildwilderness 12-Mar-19
Hancock West 12-Mar-19
ohiohunter 12-Mar-19
JSW 12-Mar-19
ROUGHCOUNTRY 14-Mar-19
Jack Harris 16-Mar-19
Boone 18-Mar-19
Junior 18-Mar-19
BullBuster 19-Mar-19
Ty 24-Jun-19
Kurt 24-Jun-19
INDBowhunter2 24-Jun-19
Ty 24-Jun-19
Bou'bound 24-Jun-19
Dirk Diggler 24-Jun-19
Kurt 24-Jun-19
t-roy 24-Jun-19
pipe 25-Jun-19
Ty 25-Jun-19
t-roy 25-Jun-19
APauls 26-Jun-19
t-roy 26-Jun-19
From: Ty
30-Nov-18
Score Me
Score Me
What is you guess? I don't know that answer yet...

From: Ty
30-Nov-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo

From: Ty
30-Nov-18
I can tell you he has 18 points. he is a main frame 12 point, and has a 17.5" inside spread.

30-Nov-18
Hmm... let's see those kill photos. :)

From: Zbone
30-Nov-18
Goooood buck... Best of luck...

From: JohnMC
30-Nov-18
Post up a dead pic with different angles. He looks like a 10 point in that pic.

From: Ty
30-Nov-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo

From: greg simon
30-Nov-18
I'd guess 180"

From: Ty
30-Nov-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo
for refferance, I am 6'3" 265lbs.

From: Ty
30-Nov-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo

From: APauls
30-Nov-18
Absolute Giant! Congrats to whoever killed it! Throwing some real fast guesses together I "only" saw 17 scorable points so take that into consideration I got a "gross non typical" score of 189. Now I know such a score doesn't exist, but go from there. What a stud.

From: Ty
30-Nov-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo

From: sticksender
30-Nov-18
A monster, congrats to you!

Would love to hear more about your hunt for that whopper.

From: Ty
30-Nov-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo

From: Brotsky
30-Nov-18
What an awesome buck! I don't care about the score, he's a stud! Congrats!

From: deerhunter72
30-Nov-18
Now that is a heart stopper!! Congratulations on a beautiful trophy. I'll take a wild stab and go with a gross of 188". Let us know when you get the tape on him.

From: Grunter
30-Nov-18
High 170's-180's. Awesome buck!!

From: molsonarcher
30-Nov-18
He scores, Dead. Happy hunter. Lots of sausage. Guessing 187”

From: cnelk
30-Nov-18
Shooter

From: molsonarcher
30-Nov-18
Also one of the better bucks ive seen from Ohio this year. Im in central Ohio, what area did you kill him in if you dont mind sharing?

From: Beav
30-Nov-18
Has to gross close to 190. APauls there is such a score as gross non-typical. Still deductions off of the typical frame. What a buck!

From: Zbone
30-Nov-18
Damn, that was quick...8^) Congrats!

BTW, Ohio buck and what date?... He was cruising during daylight hours on the 15th and 18th... Would like to add to the Rut Report thread... I bought the thread to the top...

From: Will
30-Nov-18
AWESOME. He scores AWESOME!

From: Bake
30-Nov-18
I got 177 with my calculator. I wouldn't be surprised to be 10 inches low. But I would bet $20 I'm within 8 inches :)

Awesome buck!

From: stealthycat
30-Nov-18
186

helluva buck

From: BullBuster
30-Nov-18
182 gross

From: Kodiak
30-Nov-18
Some real monsters taken by bowsiters this year. Wow.

Dream buck right there. Congrats.

30-Nov-18
193", guessing about 175-178 gross typical, then additional 15"ish+ of extra. Probably not even close....

From: Ole Coyote
30-Nov-18
AW Shucks someone already got 187 oh well fun to look at, a good one for sure!

From: Michael
30-Nov-18
Nice deer!! Congrats to the hunter.

High 180’s

From: BigOk
30-Nov-18
Heck of a Buck!!!

From: Hawkeye
30-Nov-18
Wow!

From: Treeline
30-Nov-18
He definitely scores more than enough! Great deer! Congratulations!

From: Kodiak
30-Nov-18

Kodiak  's embedded Photo
Kodiak  's embedded Photo
Turn this one...

From: Ty
30-Nov-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo
bout as good as I can do

From: Kodiak
30-Nov-18

Kodiak  's embedded Photo
Kodiak  's embedded Photo

From: T Mac
30-Nov-18
Wow! Great buck.

From: t-roy
01-Dec-18
186 2/8ths. Great buck. Congrats!

From: deerslayer
01-Dec-18
That is a legit giant.... wow....

From: Treeline
01-Dec-18
Very cool buck!

From: Paul@thefort
01-Dec-18
You were lucky. I passed up that same buck last year. Anyway, glad you got him.

Nicely done!. :) my best, Paul

01-Dec-18
Yes... “Shooter” for sure

From: LINK
01-Dec-18
182” gross. Congrats on a nice buck

From: Dirk Diggler
01-Dec-18
194 gross.

From: Dirk Diggler
01-Dec-18
Helluva buck!

From: Zbone
02-Dec-18
Ty - You going to give us date and score?

From: JayZ
02-Dec-18
How old do you think he is? In that trail cam picture his antlers dwarf his body. Maybe it’s just the angle too.

From: Shawn
02-Dec-18
172 gross a lot depends on mass measurements. Shawn

From: ELKMAN
02-Dec-18
Assuming it's free range that buck/experience scores a 10 in my book!

From: Rock
02-Dec-18
Great Buck, score depends on if he has enough NT points to go NT. If not then there is a lot of deductions.

02-Dec-18
His score is: "Flippin' Big!"

Awesome deer man. I'm guessing around 180-185

From: SBH
02-Dec-18
Congrats on killing an incredible deer. I think he's in the high 180s low 190s. Nets are for fish! Lets hear how many inches of bone that deer has.....

From: dirtclod Az.
02-Dec-18

From: Corn bore
02-Dec-18
178 gross

From: Ty
02-Dec-18
Yes he is/was free range; I am REALLY against even caging a wild animal, let alone "hunting" one. I got him on Thanksgiving Day at 3:50 pm. It is going to be a bit before I can score him though, I had to leave the rack with my Dad when blizzard came. I will make sure to post it though.

From: Zbone
03-Dec-18
Cool Ty, thanks for the update, and again - Congrats!!! Once in a lifetime bucks don't happen very often...8^)

From: jdbbowhunter
03-Dec-18
179 5/8

From: midwest
03-Dec-18
wowzer!

From: njbuck
03-Dec-18
An amazing animal, congrats.

From: Hancock West
03-Dec-18
181 gross

From: Mark Watkins
03-Dec-18
Congrats on a giant!!!!!

Mark

From: buc i 313
03-Dec-18
TYLER,

Congratulations on a "magnificent 114" buck.

From: Duke
03-Dec-18
That is a really cool deer with a lot going on. Congratulations. I came up with 187 for my eyeball score.

From: Ty
08-Dec-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo
Thought you guys may think this was neat too. IMO this could be his baby brother or son. The One side of his rack has some of the same characteristics. What do you think?

From: Ty
08-Dec-18

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo

From: Franklin
08-Dec-18
That is some nice tine length for a deer that age.

From: Franklin
08-Dec-18
That is some nice tine length for a deer that age.

From: stealthycat
08-Dec-18
what was the score ?

From: Shug
08-Dec-18
Beautiful!!

From: Elkhorn
09-Dec-18
192 gross Beauty

From: BullBuster
09-Dec-18
What the heck does it score??!! I’m losing interest.

From: Simple
09-Dec-18
That is a FANTASTIC buck. Well done! You have to love it when a plan comes together.

From: Ty
11-Mar-19
Still have not got him scored, but the lab results just came back and he was 7.5 years old.

From: Deerplotter
11-Mar-19
188. What a stud! Congrats!

From: Zbone
11-Mar-19
7.5 years old buck in this state with all the pressure, gawd, that has to be a record...

From: Duke
11-Mar-19
"She's a beaut, Clark!" Very nice!!!

12-Mar-19
“Still have not got him scored, but the lab results just came back and he was 7.5 years old.”

Just post the measurements here!!!! Put a tape on and take a couple pics, if you can.

From: Hancock West
12-Mar-19
172", maybe 174" max. Regardless he's a stud that no one should pass up. Congratulations

From: ohiohunter
12-Mar-19
184

From: JSW
12-Mar-19
That is a great buck. Congratulations. It's always hard to tell from pictures but I'm getting around 190 total gross score. I'm also not seeing 15" of abnormal points, which is the current minimum to qualify for non typical P&Y. If there are enough NT then upper 180's NT. If it doesn't qualify as NT then probably about 165 net typical.

When are you going to have him measured officially? Regardless of the final number, a deer like that deserves to be in the book.

From: ROUGHCOUNTRY
14-Mar-19
Looks like a 175-180 inch typical frame and around 10 inches of non typical points...…..So, I'm guessing 185 to 190 inches gross.

From: Jack Harris
16-Mar-19
everyone seems to be in the 180s with gross, i will concur. "gross -non-typical" to me is a real score, it's just scoring everything and adding it up with zero deductions which should land this buck somewhere in the 80s. . Then there is gross-typical and net typical.

Congrats on a buck of a lifetime. Lots of character there - hard to beat!

From: Boone
18-Mar-19
Great buck, congrats!

From: Junior
18-Mar-19
183...circumference throws me on this one.

From: BullBuster
19-Mar-19
Ty, put a dam tape on him!

From: Ty
24-Jun-19
I finally got the tape on the rack. 194.25 gross 187.375 net 7.5 years old

From: Kurt
24-Jun-19
Hell of a buck!! Congratulations! Scored as a typical or non-typical? How much non-typical score did he have? Main beam lengths? Obviously a giant!

24-Jun-19
Finally I am close on judging a big whitetail! Helluva buck Ty, congrats

From: Ty
24-Jun-19

Ty's embedded Photo
Ty's embedded Photo

From: Bou'bound
24-Jun-19
Congrats

From: Dirk Diggler
24-Jun-19
Damn, missed it by .25 inches. I suck at this game!??

From: Kurt
24-Jun-19
Thanks for posting the score sheet....I am always interested in beams, mass, tines, NT, etc. What a buck!!!!!

From: t-roy
24-Jun-19
Great buck, Ty! How long ago did you have it measured? It would be interesting to know how much shrinkage occurred from the day of harvest until you had it scored.

From: pipe
25-Jun-19
Congrats on your huge buck!

From: Ty
25-Jun-19
t-roy, 7 months passed before I got to measure it, so I never got a green score. I am not sure how much they shirk???

From: t-roy
25-Jun-19
Thanks Ty.

I killed a similarly scoring buck in January of ‘17 that ended up (officially) scoring 191 & 2/8ths” gross, when I had him scored 14 months after I killed him. I green scored him the day after I shot him right at 195”, and my taxidermist buddy (who used to be an official P&Y scorer) taped him out at 195 & 3/8ths” a few days later. He basically lost approximately 4” in that timeframe. I wish I would have kept my sheet that day to compare it to the official scoresheet and see where the shrinkage occurred. Would be interesting to see if it occurred more in tine length, mass, or a combo of both.

From: APauls
26-Jun-19

APauls's embedded Photo
APauls's embedded Photo
Depends if it goes in the pool

From: t-roy
26-Jun-19
“Like a frightened turtle”!

  • Sitka Gear