Summit Treestands
Which magazine for best tech articles?
Equipment
Contributors to this thread:
Too Many Bows Bob 22-Dec-18
altitude sick 22-Dec-18
x-man 22-Dec-18
vmang 22-Dec-18
wyobullshooter 22-Dec-18
Trial153 22-Dec-18
ELKMAN 22-Dec-18
ground hunter 22-Dec-18
Trial153 22-Dec-18
drycreek 22-Dec-18
nvgoat 22-Dec-18
sdkhunter 22-Dec-18
Buffalo1 22-Dec-18
bow_dude 23-Dec-18
midwest 23-Dec-18
DMTJAGER 23-Dec-18
Curt Wells 26-Dec-18
ELKMAN 26-Dec-18
x-man 26-Dec-18
SaltyB 26-Dec-18
Curt Wells 26-Dec-18
Ambush 26-Dec-18
nvgoat 26-Dec-18
x-man 26-Dec-18
wacem 26-Dec-18
12yards 26-Dec-18
Scoot 26-Dec-18
RD in WI 30-Dec-18
Olink 30-Dec-18
smarba 31-Dec-18
Scar Finga 31-Dec-18
x-man 31-Dec-18
Scar Finga 31-Dec-18
Native Okie 01-Jan-19
IdyllwildArcher 01-Jan-19
Boris 01-Jan-19
wild1 01-Jan-19
Bou'bound 01-Jan-19
SaltyB 01-Jan-19
22-Dec-18
I'm kind of new at compound shooting and was wondering which magazine seems to have the best technical articles? I've been getting Bowhunter for the past year or so, but they mostly have hunting stories-which I enjoy- but don't do much for increasing my knowledge in the new found area.

Thanks,

TMBB

22-Dec-18
Western hunter

From: x-man
22-Dec-18
I'm being completely honest when I say this.

Bowsite has the best technical advise.

When I started out in the bowhunting world as a teenager I bought as many magazine subscriptions as I could find. I read every single issue cover to cover and took most of it as gospel. As I grew older and wiser and became the best bow tech I could be, I realized that well over 90% of the tech articles written and published were/are wrong. Much the same way that TV hunters are poor representations of archery, so too are magazine writers.

Your money would be better spent buying a good book rather than a magazine. "Idiot-Proof Archery" would be a good start. The best published tuning aid is "The Nuts and Bolts of Archery".

Just one mans honest opinion.

From: vmang
22-Dec-18
Bowhunting Magazine has articles every month on tech. They also have articles on improving your shooting accuracy. They have been helpful to me over the years.

22-Dec-18
x-man X 2

From: Trial153
22-Dec-18
The internet will get you more and better tech advise in an afternoon then you will get from any magazine in a year. The only bowhunting specific magazine I still get is bowhunter, I cut everything else out as they were mostly BS product pimps. Bugle from RMEF, P&Y ethic, WSF are the only actual print magazines I read, none which provide and technical archery info.

From: ELKMAN
22-Dec-18
I know it's taboo to say it on here, but AT has faaar more technical information than this site. I would look there before any magazine. You can PM me any specific questions/details also if you need some tips.

22-Dec-18
Whatever the one Joe Bell writes for, he writes some good stuff, had learned a lot by reading him

From: Trial153
22-Dec-18
Elkman you are, there are couple guys on AT that top shelf with bow tuners thats four sure.

From: drycreek
22-Dec-18
What ground hunter said.

From: nvgoat
22-Dec-18
I have learned more from Bowsite and Archery Talk than all the magazines.

The old search function was a great resource for tech topics but doesn't work too well anymore.

From: sdkhunter
22-Dec-18
I agree with various forums being great resources but I will also say one of the problems with the internet is “everyone’s an expert”... I’ve seen good advice but I’ve also seen advice that ranges from bad to downright dangerous - so just take any suggestions with a grain of salt if u don’t know the source that well...

From: Buffalo1
22-Dec-18
My go to’s are Bowsite and AT for tech questions or problems. They both have reputable, knowledgeable techies.

Randy Ulmer articles are all I’m interested in magazine-wise.

From: bow_dude
23-Dec-18
I also am a Randy Ulmer fan. I have learned a lot about shooting from his small tips and tricks. They have added some polish to my shooting skills. Someone once described him as a "shooting machine". When he gives a tip, I take note.

From: midwest
23-Dec-18
Check out the Nock On YouTube channel with John Dudley.

I agree on AT having the best tech advice but I can't stand filtering through all the garbage.

From: DMTJAGER
23-Dec-18
Here, Archery Talk and You Tube combined with a decent set or archery tools and you should be able to tackle 90-95% of all your archery needs. I had to become a competent bow tech as I had less than positive experiences at the only two pro shops less than an hours drive from my home. I concur 100% with x-man as I own both books he recommends and they are as good as is currently available.

From: Curt Wells
26-Dec-18
"As I grew older and wiser and became the best bow tech I could be, I realized that well over 90% of the tech articles written and published were/are wrong. Much the same way that TV hunters are poor representations of archery, so too are magazine writers."

x-man,

Wow. That is some serious generalization right there. You must be quite the expert. Maybe you should send me something technical so we can help you share your skills with the rest of the bowhunting community.

Curt Wells, Editor, Bowhunter Magazine

From: ELKMAN
26-Dec-18
I actually don't think Xman is far off with that generalization from what I've seen, and read. If you have a technical question feel free to ask me. I'm not scared...

From: x-man
26-Dec-18
Curt,

I'm not interested in fame or fortune, but feel free to send me any tech articles for proof-reading prior to publishing. I'm not on anyone's payroll, my Bowsite advise is free and 99% of the time correct. If I don't know the answer, I don't post. If I post, you can take it to the bank.

I'm sorry if the truth hurts your feelings. That was not my intention.

From: SaltyB
26-Dec-18
Not that Curt needs defending, but I'm a pretty dang good bow tech and everything I've seen in Bowhunter has been good info. There is definitely an advertisement twist to it, but that pays the bills. Bowhunter was was my go to for archery long before the internet existed and I'll keep subscribing as long as they are around.

From: Curt Wells
26-Dec-18
x-man, Your so-called "truth" certainly didn't hurt my feelings because I don't consider it to be the truth. You're the one that chose to disparage every bowhunter who has written for a magazine or hunted on camera with your condescending, stereotypical comment, which is based on your opinions and assumptions, not truth. To illustrate that, I challenge you to document a single instance where you read something in Bowhunter Magazine, or watched something on Bowhunter TV, that was not the truth. You can't make unsubstantiated claims (like every other "internet expert") unless you can back it up with facts. And if you tell me you're much too smart to read a magazine or watch outdoor television, then how would you know that "well over 90%" of articles written and published are wrong? Take your best shot. Curt

From: Ambush
26-Dec-18
I'd still be getting Bowhunter and EBJ if the postage to Canada didn't cost way more than the subscription. But the internet is very fast and subject specific when you want an answer now. Got a funny clicking noise in your Code Red rest? Two minutes will find multiple results and very often give the right answer.

And just like gold mining, sometimes you got to move a lot of gravel to find the nugget you're looking for. You just have to know what gold looks like.

From: nvgoat
26-Dec-18
To expand on my comments above esp in light of the pissing match which has started-

I still get and read multiple bowhunting magazines including their tech articles. Usually the topics covered are ones I have already seen online. Of the magazine articles the authors I have faith in are Randy Ulmer, Darin Cooper, Curt Wells, John Dudley, Bill Winke, and Dwight Schuh. Many of the magazine articles simply mention names of sponsors and do little to help evaluate different equipment and techniques.

From: x-man
26-Dec-18
Wow,

From: wacem
26-Dec-18
I agree on the Joe Bell statement, best information I have read.

From: 12yards
26-Dec-18
I ain't gonna lie, I've learned more (enough to be dangerous, lol) on AT than on Bowsite about working on bows. The problem is you need to learn who to learn from over there. There are some really sharp guys over there. There are bow brand specific forums there too that you can learn and ask questions about your specific bow.

From: Scoot
26-Dec-18
12yards, that's a skill that applies to any area you want to learn about via the internet. Learning who has "been there, done that" and who "knows their crap" is super important. Otherwise, how can you tell the difference between the guy who did it once and decided he has it all figured out vs. a guy who's got a good head on his shoulders and has tons of good experience? When sitting behind a computer you can't, unless you get to know the characters who post there frequently and you have to discern the informed from the uninformed BSer (that's not bowsiter, BTW). There are people on AT and bowsite who anyone wanting to learn something should pay serious attention when they post and there are some whose posts shouldn't even be read due to the waste of time it will assure you.

From: RD in WI
30-Dec-18
I stopped reading archery magazines when two events were detailed within their pages. One incident described an editor purposely shooting a mule deer in the hindquarter, then harrying the animal until it succumbed to blood loss. The other detailed an editor shooting a bull moose that was not of legal size for harvest. If magazines employ these types of persons, what guarantee do I have that they don't fudge their equipment reports to benefits various advertisers. Since there is no such guarantee, I no longer purchase their publications.

From: Olink
30-Dec-18
The late Norb Mullaney's (Bowhunting World) articles were the gold standard. Unfortunately I've never seen anything close to Norb's articles since he retired.

From: smarba
31-Dec-18
Um...I've read a LOT of advice from x-man thru BS over the decades (and received direct responses from him for many of my own questions) ...and I've read a fair amount of articles and tech articles in various magazines...and I'm sticking with x-man...

Curt: x-man referred to 90% of magazine tech advice being rubbish. Perhaps your magazine accounts for the 10% that's all good all the time? Relax man.

From: Scar Finga
31-Dec-18
Perhaps X-man needs to relax. I think his attack on most if not all mags was BS! I have a lot of respect for him, but I call it as I see it! I actually think Curt was right, and X was wrong. He is very smart, and I am not taking anything away from him on that, but I think his approach was uncalled for and out of line... GO Ahead, Fire Away!

From: x-man
31-Dec-18
I didn't "attack" anyone. Please re-read my posts. Please point out where I said "most if not all".

There are and have been some very good tech writers over the years. Len, Norb, John and as of late Joe Bell is very good. The reason I suggested the OP to buy a good book is because it would take a couple years worth of magazines to answer all ones questions about tech and tuning. Why not buy a good book instead? Magazines are a good source of entertainment, but I'll stand by my advise that they are not a good source for tech.

"and that's all I have to say about that"

From: Scar Finga
31-Dec-18
Fair enough, sometimes it's better jus to drop it. God Bless,

Scar

From: Native Okie
01-Jan-19
I wouldn’t take “advice” from anyone who can’t spell it correctly.

01-Jan-19
"I ain't gonna lie, I've learned more (enough to be dangerous, lol) on AT than on Bowsite about working on bows. The problem is you need to learn who to learn from over there."

This is true. Still, AT has an incredible amount of nonsense to wade through and is poorly moderated.

As far as x-man, I've taken his advice and he's been spot on. The guy knows his shit and he's right, he doesn't post if he doesn't know.

That said, I subscribe to Bowhunter Magazine and it's the only one I read besides the periodicals from the non-profits I'm a member of and it's got really good stuff as well. X-man's claim that a lot of what's in print is worthless, is true. But I'd exclude Bowhunter Magazine from that lump.

When Chuck Adams, Dwight Schuh, Curt Wells, and the like speak, I listen, and it's made me a better bowhunter.

From: Boris
01-Jan-19
I have been shooting archery since I started in Boy Scouts. An that has been over 50 yrs ago. About the last 30 yrs. I have been doing one, taking my bow to the archery shop, let them do the work. My job is to shot the equipment and best I can be.

From: wild1
01-Jan-19
Youtube.

From: Bou'bound
01-Jan-19
Both xman and bowhunter magazine being invaluable resources need not be mutually exclusive concepts.

From: SaltyB
01-Jan-19
"When Chuck Adams, Dwight Schuh, Curt Wells, and the like speak, I listen, and it's made me a better bowhunter."

Same here.

  • Sitka Gear