Sitka Mountain Gear
Score this elk
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
JohnMC 05-Feb-19
JohnMC 05-Feb-19
JohnMC 05-Feb-19
Branden 05-Feb-19
LINK 05-Feb-19
Kurt 05-Feb-19
Ucsdryder 05-Feb-19
THP 05-Feb-19
Dirk Diggler 05-Feb-19
Billyvanness 05-Feb-19
altitude sick 05-Feb-19
IdyllwildArcher 05-Feb-19
JohnMC 05-Feb-19
JohnMC 05-Feb-19
Duke 05-Feb-19
BullBuster 05-Feb-19
ohiohunter 05-Feb-19
IdyllwildArcher 05-Feb-19
Nick Muche 05-Feb-19
TrapperKayak 05-Feb-19
TrapperKayak 05-Feb-19
otcWill 05-Feb-19
Jaquomo 05-Feb-19
Reid 05-Feb-19
Treeline 05-Feb-19
SD BuckBuster 05-Feb-19
JohnMC 05-Feb-19
Kurt 05-Feb-19
wyobullshooter 05-Feb-19
Dirk Diggler 05-Feb-19
WV Mountaineer 05-Feb-19
LINK 05-Feb-19
Scoot 05-Feb-19
Dirk Diggler 05-Feb-19
Schmitty78 05-Feb-19
Brun 05-Feb-19
Norseman 05-Feb-19
SBH 05-Feb-19
ELKMAN 06-Feb-19
WYelkhunter 06-Feb-19
320 bull 06-Feb-19
Dirk Diggler 07-Feb-19
Dirk Diggler 08-Feb-19
JohnMC 08-Feb-19
jcurri 08-Feb-19
JohnMC 10-Feb-19
IdyllwildArcher 10-Feb-19
Duke 10-Feb-19
JohnMC 10-Feb-19
HUNT MAN 10-Feb-19
Nick Muche 10-Feb-19
Boris 10-Feb-19
Jaquomo 10-Feb-19
pirogue 10-Feb-19
Royboy 10-Feb-19
Jaquomo 10-Feb-19
Jaquomo 10-Feb-19
Treeline 10-Feb-19
BigOk 10-Feb-19
From: JohnMC
05-Feb-19

JohnMC's embedded Photo
JohnMC's embedded Photo
With all the guess the score going around I thought I would post this. I am dropping this head off today to be scored and will pick up hopefully later in week and will post gross and net score then.

From: JohnMC
05-Feb-19

JohnMC's embedded Photo
JohnMC's embedded Photo
...

From: JohnMC
05-Feb-19

JohnMC's embedded Photo
JohnMC's embedded Photo
...

From: Branden
05-Feb-19
280”

From: LINK
05-Feb-19
Im no expert but I’ll guess 285” gross.

From: Kurt
05-Feb-19
260” net

From: Ucsdryder
05-Feb-19
260-265. Dave says 180”.

From: THP
05-Feb-19
282 gross 277 net

From: Dirk Diggler
05-Feb-19
I think links close, 285.

05-Feb-19
Really quick 16”, 8”, 7”, 16””, 8” for point length 38” beam 7”,6”,6”,5” mass 117” x 2 -234” Plus spread maybe 40” 274”

05-Feb-19
250-260”

05-Feb-19
280 gross. Less than 6-7 inches of deductions most likely.

From: JohnMC
05-Feb-19

JohnMC's embedded Photo
JohnMC's embedded Photo
Also having this whitetail scored and a bear skull. So guess on whitetail if you want.

From: JohnMC
05-Feb-19

JohnMC's embedded Photo
JohnMC's embedded Photo

From: Duke
05-Feb-19
I'd guess it's a 285" gross bull. Very nice.

From: BullBuster
05-Feb-19
293 bull gross. pretty wide i think. buck gross 137

From: ohiohunter
05-Feb-19
Dave’s guide: “340in.... shoot!”

05-Feb-19
I'd say the buck is 135 with 6ish inches of deductions.

From: Nick Muche
05-Feb-19
270 bull, 138 deer

From: TrapperKayak
05-Feb-19
325

From: TrapperKayak
05-Feb-19
140 on the buck

From: otcWill
05-Feb-19
285 bull;. 145 WT

From: Jaquomo
05-Feb-19
282 bull, 138 whitetail. Gross scores. Both great animals. The left antler on the whitetail will goof the net score.

Dave's team of guides are arguing over the bull's score, but all three agree he's over 300.

From: Reid
05-Feb-19
430 combined - I got the bull closer to 300 than everyone else.

From: Treeline
05-Feb-19
Bull at 290, buck at 135 gross

05-Feb-19
I think guys are missing the length of the main beams of that Whitetail..

148

From: JohnMC
05-Feb-19
We will soon find out but if my do it myself scoring is on. Most are closer on elk than deer.

From: Kurt
05-Feb-19
124-3/4” net on the whitetail (if I shot him).

05-Feb-19
278 gross on the bull.

From: Dirk Diggler
05-Feb-19
160 gross on whitey.

05-Feb-19
270' ish on the Bull. 145' ish on the whitetail. Gross scores.

From: LINK
05-Feb-19
139” on the buck

From: Scoot
05-Feb-19
288 and 143

From: Dirk Diggler
05-Feb-19
Whiteys width steals his mass and length from your eye.

From: Schmitty78
05-Feb-19
280” on elk, and 141” on the whitetail

From: Brun
05-Feb-19
280 gross on elk, I've never hunted whitetail, so I have no clue, but he looks like a dandy to me. Congrats.

From: Norseman
05-Feb-19
I’m with treeline

From: SBH
05-Feb-19
274" and 140" both gross

Great animals! Congrats, they should both make pope. Well done.

From: ELKMAN
06-Feb-19
If you had a good time, made a good shot, recovered all of your meat I would score that bull or any other a solid 10. Your memories and adventure won't change by pulling a tape on him... JMHO

From: WYelkhunter
06-Feb-19
285 elk, 142 deer gross scores

From: 320 bull
06-Feb-19
Bull somewhere near 290. I think they are hard to judge from pictures. A main beam length would really help. He might scratch 300 but I think he will fall short. Wild guess on the whitetail at 140

Both great specimens I hope you enjoyed the hunts

From: Dirk Diggler
07-Feb-19
Paul Harvey?

From: Dirk Diggler
08-Feb-19
C'mon John, solve the puzzle.

From: JohnMC
08-Feb-19
I am picking them up on Sunday. I don't know the answer until then. But my guess on elk is low 280s gross and net low to mid 270'. On whitetail I am guess gross to push 150 and net to be about 140. He has a broke g1 and g4 that will hurt each. Bear that I did not post pic of to be around 19''

From: jcurri
08-Feb-19
Buck is 136. I'm from IL so no idea on elk

From: JohnMC
10-Feb-19
Here official numbers:

Elk: 279 3/8 Gross - 272 4/8 Net

Deer: 148 4/8 Gross - 139 5/8 Net

Bear was 19 3/8

10-Feb-19
Only off by 1/2 inch on the bull, but wow did I miss the mark on the buck. I guess looking at him now I underestimated the lengths of his G2s and G3’s.

From: Duke
10-Feb-19
Thanks for sharing and congrats on the fine critters

From: JohnMC
10-Feb-19

JohnMC's embedded Photo
JohnMC's embedded Photo
Three together

From: HUNT MAN
10-Feb-19
Very nice

From: Nick Muche
10-Feb-19
Off 2” on the bull and 1” on the buck, not bad. Great animals and the euros look great!

From: Boris
10-Feb-19
310 and 136

From: Jaquomo
10-Feb-19
Boris! Wake up!

From: pirogue
10-Feb-19
Thanks for sharing

From: Royboy
10-Feb-19
Nice animals

From: Jaquomo
10-Feb-19
Got close on the bull. I should've known on the buck - I have one with very close configuration, wide with a broken G3, with almost identical inches.

Nice critters, John.

From: Jaquomo
10-Feb-19
I did guess the bear exactly right, though!

:-O

From: Treeline
10-Feb-19
Great set! Congratulations on 3 very good archery trophies!

From: BigOk
10-Feb-19
Congrats!!

  • Sitka Gear