Mathews Inc.
How Old?
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
Branden 07-Feb-19
Branden 07-Feb-19
LKH 07-Feb-19
IdyllwildArcher 08-Feb-19
Overland 08-Feb-19
BULELK1 08-Feb-19
Treeline 08-Feb-19
Jake 08-Feb-19
ELKMAN 08-Feb-19
cnelk 08-Feb-19
Treeline 08-Feb-19
Moons22 08-Feb-19
Shiras42 08-Feb-19
LINK 08-Feb-19
320 bull 08-Feb-19
goelk 08-Feb-19
Branden 08-Feb-19
IdyllwildArcher 08-Feb-19
Branden 08-Feb-19
Treeline 08-Feb-19
APauls 08-Feb-19
Branden 08-Feb-19
320 bull 08-Feb-19
Brun 08-Feb-19
Branden 08-Feb-19
From: Branden
07-Feb-19

Branden's embedded Photo
How old am I?
Branden's embedded Photo
How old am I?
So we have a lot of guess the score. How about a guess the age on this bull? You can guess the score also if you would like.

From: Branden
07-Feb-19
Yes I got the age from the bio after sending teeth in.

From: LKH
07-Feb-19
The tops almost look like a Roosevelt?????

08-Feb-19
I like Dirk's guesses. I'd say the bull is 340ish gross due to that left antler and has a lot of deductions if measured as a typical that would net him closer to 315.

From: Overland
08-Feb-19
Clearly a fake. There's no way you killed an elk without a camo bow.

From: BULELK1
08-Feb-19
Damn nice!

My guess, You--- 31

Da bull 7-8 years old

Ya done good

Good luck, Robb

From: Treeline
08-Feb-19
I’m guessing you’re 35, 8 1/2 on the bull, 375 on the bull.

From: Jake
08-Feb-19
Nice trophy! It has deductions. I am going with 338.

From: ELKMAN
08-Feb-19
No way to even guess the age with a that photo.

From: cnelk
08-Feb-19
No idea of age of either you or the bull. But by the looks, neither one has any gray hair.

From: Treeline
08-Feb-19
Sure you can guess! Of course there is no way to accurately tell age of a critter from a picture.

Or score either!

It’s all in fun!

In a wildlife biology class in college we had a test where we aged deer based on tooth wear after a lot of practice and could even use “cheat teeth”. Each of the deer had been aged in the lab. Out of about 100 students, the average score was around 70% and the best was mid 80’s%. The professor told us that when they did the same test with PHD’s and Professional Wildlife Biologists, the scores were not any better.

From: Moons22
08-Feb-19
You, 63. The bull, 8.5.

From: Shiras42
08-Feb-19
32 yo, 165lbs, 8 yo, 370 in

From: LINK
08-Feb-19
Tough picture. I’ll say the bull is 9.5 and 354” gross. Nets are for fish.

From: 320 bull
08-Feb-19
I like these threads.. How much meat did you put in your freezer and what state was it shot in?

From: goelk
08-Feb-19
In your thirty something and bull over 8 years old and between 360 to 370 score.

From: Branden
08-Feb-19
"The tops almost look like a Roosevelt?????" It actually had another outrigger that he broke off before I could kill him.

"Clearly a fake. There's no way you killed an elk without a camo bow." Haha when I bought it black was all the rage

"My guess, You--- 31 Da bull 7-8 years old" Can't get much closer then that.

"32 yo, 165lbs, 8 yo, 370 in" I lost some weight on the hunt but not that much ha. I'm 6' 2" for reference.

08-Feb-19
Did you have the bull officially measured by a P&Y or B&C measurer?

From: Branden
08-Feb-19

Branden's embedded Photo
Branden's embedded Photo
"I like these threads.. How much meat did you put in your freezer and what state was it shot in?" Not sure on the meat. Never weighed it. I killed a mature bull in a neighboring unit and weighed what we packed out. Everyone would probably call me a liar so I'm not going to post it :) WA

Here is the only other pic I have on this computer. Kinda sucks for body reference but it was tough to get pics. Steep hill and lots of brush where he died.

From: Treeline
08-Feb-19
Great bull! Might have been short on my earlier guess for score! Can I bump it up a few inches?

From: APauls
08-Feb-19
You 30, bull 7, pants, 10, and shirt 5

From: Branden
08-Feb-19
"Did you have the bull officially measured by a P&Y or B&C measurer?" No I never did. I care what stuff scores but not enough to get it done officially. A few years before I killed this bull I passed on a nice 7x7 because I didn't like the looks of it. It was probably a 370"ish bull. I killed a 350" bull on that hunt that I liked the looks of better.

This bull was my second choice bull on this hunt. There was another bull that was a little smaller that I liked better but another hunter killed it. So yea score matters but to me looks matter a little more if that makes sense?

From: 320 bull
08-Feb-19
I am going to say 8 or 9. Looks can be deceiving though. I think a good year in terms of rain, grass and food in general can make a big difference in antler size. Likely predator populations as well.

From: Brun
08-Feb-19
Great bull, congrats. Do you mind telling us what state?

From: Branden
08-Feb-19
Brun Wa

  • Sitka Gear