Mathews Inc.
Sitka Noisy?
Equipment
Contributors to this thread:
Nomad 24-Jan-20
Bou'bound 24-Jan-20
nchunter 24-Jan-20
Nomad @ work 24-Jan-20
DConcrete 24-Jan-20
ND String Puller 24-Jan-20
kota-man 24-Jan-20
Busta'Ribs 24-Jan-20
APauls 24-Jan-20
Treeline 24-Jan-20
Hawkeye 25-Jan-20
Sawpilot75 25-Jan-20
caribou77 25-Jan-20
Charlie Rehor 25-Jan-20
kakiat kid 25-Jan-20
M.Pauls 25-Jan-20
TNRAMBLINMAN 25-Jan-20
Blue Buck 25-Jan-20
stagetek 25-Jan-20
Bou'bound 25-Jan-20
Lovehunt11 25-Jan-20
Mr. Whitetail 26-Jan-20
Jack Whitmrie jr 26-Jan-20
Scrappy 26-Jan-20
Grey Ghost 26-Jan-20
Russell 26-Jan-20
Grey Ghost 26-Jan-20
bowslinger 2 14-Feb-20
Sawpilot75 15-Feb-20
Tdvorak 15-Feb-20
Nomad 15-Feb-20
Boreal 15-Feb-20
Boreal 15-Feb-20
Busta'Ribs 15-Feb-20
midwest 15-Feb-20
Grey Ghost 15-Feb-20
Pop-r 15-Feb-20
Nomad 15-Feb-20
goyt 16-Feb-20
Stekewood 16-Feb-20
From: Nomad
24-Jan-20
Just bought the Sitka Fanatic jacket last years model i believe. I find it a bit noisy right out of the box. The time of year I'll be wearing it the deer are on high alert by then, the woods are quiet, & most of my shots can be 10 yards or less. Those of you who own them do they seem noisy to you? Do they quiet down over time? Seriously considering sending it back if this is just how they are.

From: Bou'bound
24-Jan-20
Sitka fleece is noisy?

From: nchunter
24-Jan-20
The pieces I own with the fleece are not noisy at all. Grabs seeds but not noisy.

From: Nomad @ work
24-Jan-20
Yes noisy. I believe the windstopper material is making the noise when I move my arms. My wife could clearly hear it too. If we can hear it the deer can hear it.

24-Jan-20
Mine is completely silent.

From: DConcrete
24-Jan-20
Yes noisy.

24-Jan-20
Wasn’t the Fanatic series designed by the “King of Quiet” Jim Hole JR. Maybe with time or a few washes it will get quieter. But for what it costs you’d hate to be wrong.

I use Cabelas Berber or Wooltimate in the late season. Too bad Bass pro turned that into a sh!t show. God forbid the day I wear out all my old cabelas and have drop a thou on Sitka. There really isn’t much of an option out there anymore.

From: kota-man
24-Jan-20
The new version (Jim Hole, Jr version -2019), is quieter than the previous version by quite a bit. IMO it is silent. Previous versions you can definitely hear the Windstopper.

From: Busta'Ribs
24-Jan-20
You should definitely send it back and buy the current “Jim Hole Approved” version. And if you already have the new stuff and still think it’s too noisy, you’re just gonna have to hunt naked and freeze ur sack off bro.

From: APauls
24-Jan-20
Huh, I have the Gen 1 stuff in the dark blue camo and its pretty dang quiet. New stuff is quieter yet

From: Treeline
24-Jan-20
My old King of the Mountain stuff is silent. Probably not as warm as the new fangled stuff but have sat in some darn cold conditions with the right layers.

If you want silent, wool is the best.

From: Hawkeye
25-Jan-20
+1 Kota

From: Sawpilot75
25-Jan-20
I sold mine but it was the 2018 stuff. I just had the Bibbs but way too noisy. I have hunted with Jim Hole jr. Great guy. I prefer the old Cabelas Berber fleece with the outfitter camo.

From: caribou77
25-Jan-20
I havent been around the newest version but always found the previous models louder than my cabelas berber windstopper fleece. Pricer too.

25-Jan-20
You may not have the Fanatic? In the early years noisy Sitka could be wire brushed quiet but I still use the pre 2019 Fanatic and it is plenty quiet. Something is not right?

From: kakiat kid
25-Jan-20
Old Cabelas Berber fleece Outfitter camo with Windstopper was the best. I lost quite a bit of weight and was forced to get some new gear...nothing compared to it until I dropped some coin on the new Sitka gear...and I'm glad I did....the new Fanatic gear is quiet and warm. No buyers remorse here.

From: M.Pauls
25-Jan-20
Matter of opinion I guess. I find last years model a little noisy, as did I the first gen (Forest camo) as well. I used the forest stuff since inception until this last year, and it got quieter with use, but far from perfect. This years model is a lot quieter, and getting dang near fleece quiet. But if you want to stay warm and quiet, what you have is pretty awesome, with the only move in my mind being, the new fanatic, or going fleece or wool and you won’t be as warm

From: TNRAMBLINMAN
25-Jan-20
My Sitka parka was purchased in 2016. Yes, it is too noisy. It is warm but on a very quiet cold morning drawing the bow it is simply makes an unacceptable amount of noise. Very very poor given what I paid. Not sure if I will every buy any more SITKA gear for that reason. Looking hard at First Lite. Starting with bibs first to see if they are quiet.

From: Blue Buck
25-Jan-20
I have the 2017 Fanatic and it is too noisy. If there is a decent wind it is OK but if the wind goes down as it often does towards sunset, it is too noisy.

From: stagetek
25-Jan-20
The newer version of the Fanatic jacket is not noisy. The older ones were. Scheels has a sale on Sitka Gear going on and I just bought the newer version of the Fanatic coat. Very quiet and very warm.

From: Bou'bound
25-Jan-20
DOES the new version come in a hockey tape pattern too?

25-Jan-20
I hunted with Sitka fanatics last 3 years. I loved it, it is warm and silent. I killed 3 big buck with this clothes.

26-Jan-20
I am very pleased with the fanatic with one exception. Does anyone else find the forearm area of the jacket extremely tight? With just a base layer and one shirt, I have a hard time getting it on and off, and find it somewhat uncomfortable in that area.

26-Jan-20
Ok if it has wind blocker inside of it get rid of it, NOW! I have bought several different brands with wind blocker in it and they seem silent in the store. Then sound like a tin can full of marbles in the field.

From: Scrappy
26-Jan-20
I have the 2018 bib and 2019 fanatic jacket. I guess I'm extremely lucky to be really hard of hearing as well as all the deer I hunt.

If your not seeing and killing deer it's not the noise that your clothes are not making.

Like others have stated the only way your going to be quieter is to go buck naked.

From: Grey Ghost
26-Jan-20
With the exception of the 70% Jacket (or whatever it was called) all the Sitka pieces I have are too noisy for the type hunting I do. I haven't bought any of it recently, though.

Matt

From: Russell
26-Jan-20
I have Day One fleece camo with wind blocker. It is silent and over 10 years old.

From: Grey Ghost
26-Jan-20
I think some guys just aren't aware of how much noise their cloths make. My best hunting buddy wears the lightweight Sitka pants for early season elk hunting. On calm days I can hear every move he makes from 20 yards away when we hunt together. It drives me nuts! Don't even get me started on his noisy-ass Tenzing fanny pack....

Matt

26-Jan-20
I remember Pat intentionally tried to make noise with his while a buck was under his stand, and the buck did not hear it.

I documented a late season hunt and had deer within 7 yards, no wind, and I was filming them. I will admit the Celsius without wind breaker is quieter than the Fanatic, but I have no noise concerns with either.

Makes me wonder how much movement is taking place by those that have noise concerns? Admittedly, I am a stand or blind hunter so movement is limited.

From: bowslinger 2
14-Feb-20
Just bought the new Fanatic jacket 2019 Dec. Only thing I found noisy was the caller . A little bit of whisker stubble sounds like sand paper on hard wood. I might try a turtle neck. It's going down to -11 tonight maybe I'll try it in the morning.

From: Sawpilot75
15-Feb-20
X2 on The Day One gear. Great clothing, dead silent and not the mark up of Sitka.

From: Tdvorak
15-Feb-20
Different people have different definitions of “noisy” and “quiet”. Some guys “think” they sit still in the woods but compared to other people they are fidgety. It might be same deal. There’s a big value in being able to put your hands on the gear before you buy it...one of the great things about brick and mortar stores.

From: Nomad
15-Feb-20
I sit pretty still especially by late season. I don't hear all that well but use "hearing aids" when bow hunting. My wife on the other hand hears exceptionally well. I put the jacket on & had her turn her back to me. I started about ten feet behind her & simply raised my arms & drew my arm back just like raising your bow & drawing. Nothing more. She clearly heard it. I went out to ten yards & she still clearly heard it. If she can hear it facing away from me then a deer can hear it. I called them up to send it back. She asked why so I told her. No problems. Great customer service. High marks for that.

Everything is subjective. It was just to noisy for me in the environment I hunt at that time of year when I would need this. To be honest I'm disappointed as it seemed like a nice jacket overall otherwise. Thanks for everyone's input.

15-Feb-20

Habitat for Wildlife's embedded Photo
Habitat for Wildlife's embedded Photo
Late season, dead calm, within 7 yards. Fanatic coat, Stratus bibs.

From: Boreal
15-Feb-20
Yesterday was the first day cold enough to wear my Fanatic bibs and jacket. Quiet enough to pull my phone out of the right thigh pocket and take pictures of these does at 15 yards without them being tipped off.

From: Boreal
15-Feb-20

Boreal's embedded Photo
Boreal's embedded Photo

From: Busta'Ribs
15-Feb-20

Busta'Ribs's Link
“The Science of Sound”

Hard to believe Gore goes to these lengths and still can’t make a quiet jacket?

From: midwest
15-Feb-20
cool Busta

From: Grey Ghost
15-Feb-20
I checked out the newest Sitka offerings at Cabelas a few weeks ago. It's still way too noisy for my tastes and style of hunting.

Matt

From: Pop-r
15-Feb-20
It depends on the piece. I have several Sitka pieces that are loud as hell and one or two that are silent. Even with the wind stopper the mountain jacket is dead silent although it's not near the jacket the fanatic is.

From: Nomad
15-Feb-20
Busta.........What I saw was an advertisement to sell me something.

Like the guy said......Most fishing lures are designed to catch fishermen not fish.

For the guys it works for more power to you. It's too noisy for me plain & simple.

From: goyt
16-Feb-20
I hunted WI and then Ohio a lot. In those two states I sometimes did not wear my outer jacket because it was to noisy until I switched to fleece. Then I hunted Iowa and I quickly went to Cabelas it get clothing with a wind liner because the wind was blowing right through me and I was freezing. The wind liner was fine in Iowa where the wind always seemed to blow but was too noisy in Ohio. I noticed that people from MN, WI and OH seem to think that the Sikta gear is too noisy whereas the people from Iowa and other plains states think that it is just fine. Maybe everyone is right for their needs.

From: Stekewood
16-Feb-20
Fanatic too noisy? These threads crack me up.

  • Sitka Gear