Summit Treestands
Score this deer
Mule Deer
Contributors to this thread:
Tony 08-Mar-20
BigSkyHntr 08-Mar-20
whipranger 08-Mar-20
creed 08-Mar-20
Ambush 08-Mar-20
Tony 09-Mar-20
Shawn 09-Mar-20
TrapperKayak 09-Mar-20
BULELK1 09-Mar-20
Two Feathers 09-Mar-20
Jaquomo 09-Mar-20
Tony 09-Mar-20
LKH 09-Mar-20
Thornton 09-Mar-20
splitlimb13 09-Mar-20
BOHNTR 09-Mar-20
Ambush 10-Mar-20
Copperhead 10-Mar-20
wildwilderness 10-Mar-20
Tony 10-Mar-20
Bowboy 10-Mar-20
Kurt 10-Mar-20
Ambush 10-Mar-20
gil_wy 15-Mar-20
wildwilderness 15-Mar-20
Treeline 15-Mar-20
Tony 15-Mar-20
Tony 15-Mar-20
From: Tony
08-Mar-20

Tony 's embedded Photo
Tony 's embedded Photo
Tony 's embedded Photo
Tony 's embedded Photo
Tony 's embedded Photo
Tony 's embedded Photo
Was just reminiscing about last hunting season and this deer I put an arrow just over for the second year in a row. What do you guys think he gross scores? He is a huge bodied SK buck as well.

From: BigSkyHntr
08-Mar-20
187 3/8” Love that mass!

From: whipranger
08-Mar-20
182”

From: creed
08-Mar-20
upper 180's

From: Ambush
08-Mar-20
I think the mass will carry him to 190”. Might not be as short as he looks because of the mass. Super buck!!

From: Tony
09-Mar-20

Tony 's embedded Photo
Tony 's embedded Photo
Ya his mass is insane. 2019 was the 1st year he put a front on one side. I think he was 7.5 yrs last year probably. This was him back in 2015

From: Shawn
09-Mar-20
114"s Shawn

From: TrapperKayak
09-Mar-20
Somewhere in the 180s Beauty.

From: BULELK1
09-Mar-20
Heck yeah, luv that Mass!

Sure, add me to the 180 list

Robb

From: Two Feathers
09-Mar-20
Big beer belly to go with his big rack.

From: Jaquomo
09-Mar-20
The mass is super, but with no brows, average G3s and short mains, 21" inside spread, I think mid 170s is more realistic. Without the extra mass he's a 160 buck, and I don't see 20" of extra scorable mass.

But who cares, he's an awesome buck! Why don't you kill him this year and tell us for sure. :-)

From: Tony
09-Mar-20
Jaquomo that's the plan

From: LKH
09-Mar-20
I think you need to carry a small bottle of booze with you. That way the next time you shoot over him you can drown your sorrows. Love the mass!!

From: Thornton
09-Mar-20

Thornton's embedded Photo
Thornton's embedded Photo
180"s buck for reference

From: splitlimb13
09-Mar-20
"The mass is super, but with no brows, average G3s and short mains, 21" inside spread, I think mid 170s is more realistic. Without the extra mass he's a 160 buck, and I don't see 20" of extra scorable mass."

I agree

From: BOHNTR
09-Mar-20
I agree with Lou.....but a buck that score really doesn’t matter much!

From: Ambush
10-Mar-20
I agree with Lou about the no brows costing him a few inches. But looking at him again on a computer screen rather than the phone, I'm more convinced that he is quite a bit longer on all his measurements than it looks at a quick glance because of the mass. And he has the big head of an older buck. I'll stick with saying he's pushing 190".

From: Copperhead
10-Mar-20
BIGENUF4ME

10-Mar-20
It’s as big as you want it to be until you ground check it! Go find the sheds and let us know!!!

To me it’s not over 180 because the fronts aren’t there. You need big fronts to score high. The spread isn’t huge either so the main beams aren’t long either. But I love mass so that buck is awesome.

From: Tony
10-Mar-20

Tony 's embedded Photo
Tony 's embedded Photo
Thanks for all the guesses. I'm hoping to get another chance this year. I was guessing low 180s. In 2018 I watched him standing next to this guy who went 178, and he had a much bigger frame but no fronts. 2019 he put on one front. Regardless of score he has become a bit of a legend to me and I'd love to take him

From: Bowboy
10-Mar-20
I'd be shooting! Good luck!

From: Kurt
10-Mar-20
Great buck (both of them)! Good luck this fall!

From: Ambush
10-Mar-20
OK, my bad and good thing I'm not a mule deer guide!! I enlarged the pics after Tony saying that the buck grow a front on one side and realized that the buck only has one G4 My new guess is 183" gross. But that's as low as I'm going :)

From: gil_wy
15-Mar-20
I’d be surprised if he grossed under 190”...

15-Mar-20
It will absolutely gross UNDER 190. A crab claw 3x4 with NO brows doesn’t stand a chance. That nice 178 buck has brows AND good fronts, even if the frame is bigger that might add a couple inches, but you are going to loose 20” from the fronts and brows! I’m with Lou and say 160s-170 max.

I’ve scored a few old 3x4s with mass. They are awesome deer but don’t score well.

From: Treeline
15-Mar-20
Low 180's gross. Net will be hurt by the weak front end. Will finish around 170.

Score be damned! That is a shooter anywhere! Love the mass! Definitely an older age class buck and a worthy trophy. I would be hunting him hard....

From: Tony
15-Mar-20
Wild wilderness. Defintly agree with your points. Keep in kind though the 178 only had 12 inch G2s. I'm totally confident he is well over 160though. His G2s are strong and his mass is crazy. I agree not 190 but he has a frame that I can instantly recognize at a half mile with only binos it's so huge. Defintly hoping to get another chance next year and find out what he goes

From: Tony
15-Mar-20
Tree line yes his mass and my history with him makes him a huge trophy to me. I only have 3-5 days a year to hunt mulies but this will be my target for sure next year.

  • Sitka Gear