Mathews Inc.
Best guess on score....
Whitetail Deer
Contributors to this thread:
beemann 23-Jul-21
beemann 23-Jul-21
Hancock West 23-Jul-21
Hancock West 23-Jul-21
Shug 23-Jul-21
Kydeer1 23-Jul-21
Hancock West 23-Jul-21
MDcrazyman 23-Jul-21
Thornton 23-Jul-21
Rocky D 23-Jul-21
JohnMC 23-Jul-21
Rocky D 23-Jul-21
brettpsu 23-Jul-21
BigEight 23-Jul-21
Old School 23-Jul-21
Norseman 23-Jul-21
Kurt 23-Jul-21
buckhammer 23-Jul-21
MA-PAdeerslayer 23-Jul-21
Pop-r 23-Jul-21
wildwilderness 23-Jul-21
powder 23-Jul-21
BullBuster 23-Jul-21
Screwball 23-Jul-21
maxracx 23-Jul-21
Bake 23-Jul-21
RK 23-Jul-21
BigOk 23-Jul-21
t-roy 23-Jul-21
nowheels 23-Jul-21
beemann 23-Jul-21
Kurt 23-Jul-21
Hancock West 24-Jul-21
GF 24-Jul-21
BullBuster 25-Jul-21
From: beemann
23-Jul-21
Score Me
Score Me
Buck form last year curious to see what guys think he scores....

From: beemann
23-Jul-21

beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
Here are a few more pics. I was after him last year, another guy got him. We use the same Taxidermist so I was able to see him. Ill share the score later. Thanks for looking.

From: Hancock West
23-Jul-21
147

From: Hancock West
23-Jul-21
i didn't see the 3rd pic. Might be 144 too

From: Shug
23-Jul-21
Seeing the 140+ guesses I’m embarrassed to say low 60’s

From: Kydeer1
23-Jul-21
164ish

From: Hancock West
23-Jul-21
Nice G3's but i think his mass & his G1's & G2's are keeping him in the 140s

From: MDcrazyman
23-Jul-21
162

From: Thornton
23-Jul-21
I see 140"s frequently and he looks quite a bit bigger. I wouldn't be surprised if he was high 150"s at least or bigger.

From: Rocky D
23-Jul-21
I feeling that Thornton is leaning in the right direction.

From: JohnMC
23-Jul-21
153

From: Rocky D
23-Jul-21
I’m going 166 3/8ths, maybe seeing more than there is there.

From: brettpsu
23-Jul-21
154

From: BigEight
23-Jul-21
If that deer is in the 140's then I'm really off on guessing inches. Wait? Forget I said that. I think he has more mass than we think. Look at the side profile and his mass compared to his ear. Definitely not a long and skinny guy. Now I can't wait for the OP to prove me wrong. HEHE

From: Old School
23-Jul-21
158

From: Norseman
23-Jul-21
162 5/8ths

From: Kurt
23-Jul-21
150

From: buckhammer
23-Jul-21
He has really good beam length. That will get him to 158

23-Jul-21
I shot a 138” 8 point few years ago he’s bigger for sure. 156

From: Pop-r
23-Jul-21
Mid 150's.

23-Jul-21
What State? What is the average body weight of Deer There?

not knowing that info makes pictures harder to judge.

I guess its over 150, and under 180....

From: powder
23-Jul-21
147

From: BullBuster
23-Jul-21
156 gross

From: Screwball
23-Jul-21
155

From: maxracx
23-Jul-21
168 3/8 gross

From: Bake
23-Jul-21
That buck is closer to 170 than 140. I’m guessing he’s in the 160s somewhere

From: RK
23-Jul-21
High 150s but I suck at this

From: BigOk
23-Jul-21
156 3/8

From: t-roy
23-Jul-21
156”

From: nowheels
23-Jul-21
157 1/4

From: beemann
23-Jul-21

beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
beemann's embedded Photo
Well most of you are way closer than I was. This deer just screamed 170 to me. Every now and then Id think 150's, then Id get another pic and Id be right back to 170. I knew there was the possibility that he was thin horned but he looked so dam good. Anyway they taped him at 152 I don't know how long the main beams are but when you get the rack in your hands you kinda think yeah 150's. Still a great deer for my part of the world. Thanks for looking....

From: Kurt
23-Jul-21
Bryan, is that gross or net...either way a heck of an impressive typical!!!! There are a few inches of deductions on him for sure...I'd guess 5".

From: Hancock West
24-Jul-21
Nice buck beeman. He's very symmetrical. Congrats

From: GF
24-Jul-21
I would’ve said that it depends what state you’re in… But I don’t know beans about these scoring systems… LOL

All I can tell you is that the biggest deer I ever shot wouldn’t score for squat because of the deductions…. and I don’t care. Although it’s kinda useful to have some idea of what the numbers mean when people start tossing them around….

From: BullBuster
25-Jul-21
Dang it! I knew with those short brows my 156 was 4” too big. Lol

  • Sitka Gear