onX Maps
ST Broadhead Disappointment
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
Willcz 01-Aug-22
spike78 01-Aug-22
Buffalo1 01-Aug-22
Aspen Ghost 02-Aug-22
Guardian hunter 02-Aug-22
Jethro 02-Aug-22
carcus 02-Aug-22
cnelk 02-Aug-22
LINK 02-Aug-22
Inshart 02-Aug-22
Goat 02-Aug-22
Willcz 02-Aug-22
[email protected] 02-Aug-22
LINK 02-Aug-22
Willcz 02-Aug-22
WV Mountaineer 02-Aug-22
Michael 02-Aug-22
Jethro 02-Aug-22
Lost Arra 02-Aug-22
Twinetickler 03-Aug-22
bowhunt 03-Aug-22
fisherick 03-Aug-22
APauls 03-Aug-22
LINK 03-Aug-22
air leak 03-Aug-22
From: Willcz
01-Aug-22
After shooting ST's for at least the past 12 years I am totally disappointed. Going on an elk hunt in Sept. I have shot the Easton AXIS arrows for all of those 12 years and never had a problem. Simple, I just can't screw the heads into the sharrow. Bought 8 BH's and all were different. Some easy some took a lot of force, 2 were not screwing in at all. What the heck happened to ST. I have been reading a lot of good reviews for the Exodus and will be using those in September if my accuracy tests work out next week. Any thoughts on the QAD Exodus Full would be appreciated. Going to a NO BARB state.

From: spike78
01-Aug-22
I shoot STs but can’t get the Exodus to shoot well I’m guessing maybe hand torque but the Tricks always shot well.

From: Buffalo1
01-Aug-22
Are you sure you don’t have an insert problem ?

From: Aspen Ghost
02-Aug-22
Try all 8 on the same arrow.

02-Aug-22
Big fan of exodus heads here. Took them to Africa in June. Great result. Fan of magnus black hornets as well. Solidly built.

From: Jethro
02-Aug-22
I can't comment on the full blade. But this Spring I switched from ST to Exodus swept blade. They have same point of impact as the ST. No adjustment was needed. Can't imagine you'll have any issues with the full blade.

From: carcus
02-Aug-22
I have both, never hunted with the ST cause they just didn't fly as good as the exodus swept

From: cnelk
02-Aug-22
Run a tap into the inserts, spin a die over the threads of the BH.

A tap & die set is cheap and should be in your tool box at home anyway

From: LINK
02-Aug-22

LINK's Link

From: Inshart
02-Aug-22
LINK, that one looks just like the Muzzy.

From: Goat
02-Aug-22
I joke that I have shot every BH known to man. But I have settled on the Exodus. I shoot the swept blades where legal but have noticed little if any flight difference with the full. Most importantly they are absolutely devastating. I won't shoot anything else. Just my 2 cents.

From: Willcz
02-Aug-22
Thanks for the help everyone. I expect to get the Exodus Full delivered this week. I will certainly do some shooting. I am going to a Barbless BH state in September so I need to stick with the Full. What the heck did ST do to their design. I must have 20 deer down with them and now I have to wear steel gloves to turn on a BH.

02-Aug-22
Odd issue unless you have epoxy in the insert threads from installation.

From: LINK
02-Aug-22

LINK's embedded Photo
LINK's embedded Photo
LINK's embedded Photo
LINK's embedded Photo
LINK's embedded Photo
LINK's embedded Photo
Inshart it is a muzzy.

From: Willcz
02-Aug-22
I have a dozen or more older ST's that fit perfectly without any issues. Lots of practicing etc so I had to replace. It is the new design that I just can't get to fit.

02-Aug-22
Sounds like an insert problem. Not the broadhead.

From: Michael
02-Aug-22
I agree it sounds like an insert/glue problem. Not a broadhead problem.

From: Jethro
02-Aug-22
A guy buys new broadheads. Unscrews his field points and practice broadheads and then the new ones won't thread in. How does that point to insert problem?

Its not a secret that ST has been having issues. Couple years now. Some are perfect and fly great. But this is not the first person to buy new ST and have them not thread in.

From: Lost Arra
02-Aug-22
I had the same problem but with only one of the heads in the package . It was not the insert. It was the head but if I had Brad's die it might have been a just a thread problem.

From: Twinetickler
03-Aug-22
There was a whole thread on this last year as well. Tge new design is garbage.

From: bowhunt
03-Aug-22
I have run into a similar issue a few times the last few years.

I shot the broadhead into my block target one time and then they always screwed in the rest of the way. The washers fit tight around the base of broadhead and blades, so maybe just a tiny difference in washer size, or a Thick spot in the coating on the Ferule.

After that one shot they never failed to screw in all the way, and spin straight once tightens all the way.

From: fisherick
03-Aug-22
Buy yourself an 8/32 tap and die to clean up the threads.

From: APauls
03-Aug-22
I'm sorry but if you need to tap and die your broadheads I'm far too concerned about quality to continue from there. With the plethora of good choices out there why buy a head and then get to work machining on it when a ready to use option exists for the same price? Where else have they cut corners if they can't even get a simple thread right?

From: LINK
03-Aug-22
I loved my old slick tricks but I’m with APauls.

From: air leak
03-Aug-22
FWIW.. I have killed a bunch of deer with ST Mags, made in USA. A few years ago, I tried Exodus Full blade. CT is a no Barb state. Extremely accurate, blows through a deer, excellent blood trail. Every deer dropped within 60 yards.

  • Sitka Gear