Moultrie Products
Wyoming folks
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
Sivart 14-Aug-22
cnelk 14-Aug-22
Jordan 14-Aug-22
Mule Power 14-Aug-22
cnelk 14-Aug-22
Bowboy 14-Aug-22
Inshart 14-Aug-22
Inshart 14-Aug-22
TGbow 14-Aug-22
Sivart 14-Aug-22
Jaquomo 14-Aug-22
Firsty 14-Aug-22
darktimber 14-Aug-22
Sivart 14-Aug-22
Woods Walker 14-Aug-22
JohnMC 14-Aug-22
wytex 14-Aug-22
stringgunner 15-Aug-22
LONEBULL 15-Aug-22
goaliemike25 15-Aug-22
Dpat 15-Aug-22
Grasshopper 16-Aug-22
Woods Walker 16-Aug-22
Jims 16-Aug-22
Jordan 16-Aug-22
Sivart 17-Aug-22
Treeline 17-Aug-22
Bowboy 17-Aug-22
JohnMC 17-Aug-22
From: Sivart
14-Aug-22
My wife and I are planning to relocate from Neb to WY this winter. We have narrowed it down to two areas, as we have to stay fairly close to the Eastern side.

It's either the Saratoga area, or Wheatland area.

Of the two, which has better hunting opportunities? I realize that elk tags are nearly impossible in unit 7. But what about mule deer, antelope, turkey, and grouse?

Prefer one area over the other? Thanks in advance.

From: cnelk
14-Aug-22
Of those two choices, definitely Saratoga

From: Jordan
14-Aug-22
Agreed

From: Mule Power
14-Aug-22
Wheatland is such a boring area. Definitely Saratoga.

From: cnelk
14-Aug-22
I drove thru Wheatland today. Sure glad the speed limit was 80 ;)

From: Bowboy
14-Aug-22
Saratoga would be my choice. There’s more public land around. Antelope is a a little tougher because you have to draw. You’ll have to go some place else for turkeys since Saratoga doesn’t have any that I know of. Housing will be cheaper in Wheatland but Saratoga is better for deer and elk. There’s also great fishing in the area around Saratoga.

From: Inshart
14-Aug-22
You might want to go to (areavibes.com) good info and Saratoga looks very good.

From: Inshart
14-Aug-22
You might want to go to (areavibes.com) good info and Saratoga looks very good. Not much for sale around there tho.

From: TGbow
14-Aug-22
I think I'd like it in Wyoming. Good luck with your move.

From: Sivart
14-Aug-22
It's not the town of wheatland that appeals to me. It's the public hunting just West of town that's appealing.

From: Jaquomo
14-Aug-22
Only a 2.5 hour drive from Saratoga to Wheatland.

From: Firsty
14-Aug-22
Idaho. Seriously!

From: darktimber
14-Aug-22
Depends. If you like wind…Wheatland has it. Wheatland also wins on goose hunting and Grayrocks Res. is great for walleye and bass. If you like trout fishing…Saratoga all day. Saratoga also wins for Forest Service access. I moved up WY from NE 21 years ago. No plans to ever move back!

From: Sivart
14-Aug-22
Have to stay close to Neb. Kids

From: Woods Walker
14-Aug-22
Saratoga would be my pick also. Besides the hunting and the gorgeous country, the headwaters of the North Platte run right by it, and when I lived in Laramie we'd raft it.

But that said, I had a friend who was from Chugwater, which is near Wheatland, and we did a bunch of Mule deer hunting in those canyons and it was awesome. But then again, the WHOLE STATE is awesome!!!

It was on one of those Chugwater hunts that I ate my first rattlesnake......tastes like chicken!

From: JohnMC
14-Aug-22
Torrington then!

From: wytex
14-Aug-22
Not really tons of public hunting just west of Wheatland other than Laramie Peak area. Area 6 elk is hard access, mostly private. The NF between Laramie and Cheyenne is LQ for elk and deer. Some scattered public sections west of Wheatland along 34 but they get hunted hard by locals and some NRs. Saratoga can be isolated in winter. No big box shopping. Folks are great, some money in town. Better public access for hunting I think. No turkeys but they can be hunted within 2 hrs of Saratoga or so.

From: stringgunner
15-Aug-22
Torrington over Wheatland for sure. But likely hard to beat Saratoga. The wind in Wheatland drive my wife and I nuts when we lived near there many years ago.

From: LONEBULL
15-Aug-22
Saratoga!!!!!! Not even close

From: goaliemike25
15-Aug-22
Saratoga all day everyday. Plenty of opportunities to fish, hunt antelope, deer and general elk nearby when you don't hit the limited elk draw. Not sure how far you need to go in Nebraska, but Saratoga is about 3 1/2 hours from Sidney. A bit farther in the winter when WY130 is closed.

From: Dpat
15-Aug-22
So is the wind worse in Wheatland or Torrington? They seem fairly close to one another.

From: Grasshopper
16-Aug-22
Grew up in Casper, the wind in wyoming will drive you nuts after awhile. Some tolerate it longer then others, but it will happen.

I don't know how hard it is to draw unit 7 or others for elk as a resident, but they issue a boatload of tags. You might look into that.

Towns - Saratoga, hands down.

From: Woods Walker
16-Aug-22

Woods Walker's embedded Photo
Woods Walker's embedded Photo

From: Jims
16-Aug-22
Even though Saratoga is a nicer town and area it is pretty darn isolated for shopping. It's probably about an hour drive to Rawlins if the weather is good. Wheatland would have pretty much everything you need in town and it's not too terribly far to Cheyenne. If you don't mind a tiny town that is fairly remote I'd pick Saratoga. Wheatland is around 3,800 people while Saratoga only has around 1,800. If you like to be closer to civilization you may want to go with Wheatland.

You may want to take a look at real estate? I doubt if there is much to choose from in Saratoga?

In regard to hunting, there is great hunting and fishing around both towns.

From: Jordan
16-Aug-22
Bella's Bistro in Saratoga is reason enuf

From: Sivart
17-Aug-22
Jims,

My thoughts exactly. I would be fine with a town like Saratoga. But the wife and kids will want more stuff to do in town. Which is why Wheatland comes to mind. I won't live in Cheyenne.

From: Treeline
17-Aug-22
Look at Centennial. Not much for sale there but close enough to Laramie for town and far enough away to have elbow room. The snowy range is nice and lots of fishing around.

From: Bowboy
17-Aug-22
I know of a builder who I helped build the road for 6 new lots above Centennial.

From: JohnMC
17-Aug-22
Casper is not a bad town.

  • Sitka Gear