Sitka Gear
Finished ARROW WEIGHT for deer ???
Equipment
Contributors to this thread:
Bou’bound 01-Nov-23
fdp 01-Nov-23
JTreeman 01-Nov-23
t-roy 01-Nov-23
Dino 01-Nov-23
WV Mountaineer 01-Nov-23
Charlie Rehor 01-Nov-23
greg simon 01-Nov-23
molsonarcher 01-Nov-23
Bow Bullet 01-Nov-23
Nick Muche 01-Nov-23
buckeye 01-Nov-23
Jaquomo 01-Nov-23
Willieboat 01-Nov-23
bowhunt 01-Nov-23
Corax_latrans 01-Nov-23
Ollie 01-Nov-23
StickFlicker 01-Nov-23
Guardian hunter 01-Nov-23
Ambush 01-Nov-23
shooter 01-Nov-23
Matt 01-Nov-23
HoytHntr4 01-Nov-23
midwest 01-Nov-23
Husker 01-Nov-23
Grunt-N-Gobble 01-Nov-23
JohnMC 01-Nov-23
Hondolane 01-Nov-23
Bowaddict 01-Nov-23
Supernaut 01-Nov-23
ahunter55 01-Nov-23
MA-PAdeerslayer 02-Nov-23
longspeak74 02-Nov-23
wv_bowhunter 02-Nov-23
M.Pauls 02-Nov-23
xtroutx 02-Nov-23
Groundhunter 02-Nov-23
HUNT MAN 02-Nov-23
fuzzy 02-Nov-23
Jeff Durnell 02-Nov-23
Murph 02-Nov-23
Lewis 02-Nov-23
Bowbender 02-Nov-23
carcus 02-Nov-23
Joe Holden 02-Nov-23
Bake 02-Nov-23
drycreek 02-Nov-23
njbuck 02-Nov-23
boobowmen 02-Nov-23
BOWNUT 02-Nov-23
x-man 02-Nov-23
RD in WI 02-Nov-23
Blood 02-Nov-23
Michael 02-Nov-23
patience2spare 02-Nov-23
Lost Arra 02-Nov-23
Stubbleduck 02-Nov-23
HDE 02-Nov-23
GFL 02-Nov-23
goelk 02-Nov-23
Gus 02-Nov-23
westgak 02-Nov-23
GLP 02-Nov-23
Lee 02-Nov-23
TREESTANDWOLF 02-Nov-23
skull 02-Nov-23
bowhunter55 02-Nov-23
Hoytman2 02-Nov-23
Errorhead 02-Nov-23
Corax_latrans 02-Nov-23
Coondog 03-Nov-23
fuzzy 03-Nov-23
six 03-Nov-23
kota-man 03-Nov-23
carcus 03-Nov-23
Scoot 03-Nov-23
12yards 03-Nov-23
Highlife 03-Nov-23
ND String Puller 03-Nov-23
Will 03-Nov-23
Blood 03-Nov-23
ND String Puller 03-Nov-23
Bentshaft 03-Nov-23
Corax_latrans 03-Nov-23
Vonfoust 03-Nov-23
PAOH 03-Nov-23
WhattheFOC 03-Nov-23
Copperman 09-Nov-23
MoBowhunter 10-Nov-23
Bowboy 10-Nov-23
SteveB 10-Nov-23
bowwild 10-Nov-23
Juancho 12-Nov-23
Ziek 13-Nov-23
kota-man 13-Nov-23
WV Mountaineer 14-Nov-23
Blood 14-Nov-23
Highlife 14-Nov-23
Bou'bound 14-Nov-23
Blood 14-Nov-23
Coondog 14-Nov-23
Nick Muche 14-Nov-23
Bou’bound 15-Nov-23
TGbow 15-Nov-23
Rock 20-Nov-23
hunt'n addict 23-Nov-23
Buffalo1 25-Nov-23
Brotsky 27-Nov-23
From: Bou’bound
01-Nov-23
What is your finished arrow weight for deer and do you shoot mechanical heads with it?

Looking for a three digit number and a two or three letter word. No need to go into detail on the components, etc.

From: fdp
01-Nov-23
525'ish, No

From: JTreeman
01-Nov-23
485ish, Yes Mech

From: t-roy
01-Nov-23
450ish yes & no

From: Dino
01-Nov-23
435 100gr Mechanical

01-Nov-23
445. No

01-Nov-23
465, hybrid

From: greg simon
01-Nov-23
505, No

From: molsonarcher
01-Nov-23
428 grains Mech and fixed

From: Bow Bullet
01-Nov-23
510 gr, no

From: Nick Muche
01-Nov-23
385 yes

From: buckeye
01-Nov-23
450 give or take a few, mechanical

From: Jaquomo
01-Nov-23
430, no

From: Willieboat
01-Nov-23
445 shoot both

From: bowhunt
01-Nov-23
395 yes

01-Nov-23
420-550, depending on the bow. No mechs.

From: Ollie
01-Nov-23
625. No.

From: StickFlicker
01-Nov-23
Was shooting 408 and 440 off and on, and yes with exp. with no issues. Have recently changed to 464, yes.

01-Nov-23
428 yes

From: Ambush
01-Nov-23
465 or 490 depending on the head. Yes.

From: shooter
01-Nov-23
500, no

From: Matt
01-Nov-23
Bou, you have really elevated your idiot-proofing skills. We will see if they adapt.

425 grains, yes

From: HoytHntr4
01-Nov-23
465, both

From: midwest
01-Nov-23
420 gr, hybrid.

From: Husker
01-Nov-23
450ish, yes

01-Nov-23
470 yes

From: JohnMC
01-Nov-23
Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.

Now we are engaged in a great civil war, testing whether that nation, or any nation so conceived and so dedicated, can long endure. We are met on a great battle-field of that war. We have come to dedicate a portion of that field, as a final resting place for those who here gave their lives that that nation might live. It is altogether fitting and proper that we should do this.

But, in a larger sense, we can not dedicate -- we can not consecrate -- we can not hallow -- this ground. The brave men, living and dead, who struggled here, have consecrated it, far above our poor power to add or detract. The world will little note, nor long remember what we say here, but it can never forget what they did here. It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us -- that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion -- that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain -- that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom -- and that government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth.

From: Hondolane
01-Nov-23
425 and hell yes rage

From: Bowaddict
01-Nov-23
430 and no

From: Supernaut
01-Nov-23
500

No

From: ahunter55
01-Nov-23

ahunter55's embedded Photo
ahunter55's embedded Photo
500+ 3 blade fixed for over 50 years now. 1st Deer in 1958 & a 3 blade too

02-Nov-23
405 yes

565 no

From: longspeak74
02-Nov-23
385 yes

From: wv_bowhunter
02-Nov-23
540, No

From: M.Pauls
02-Nov-23
480 yes

From: xtroutx
02-Nov-23
420-yes

From: Groundhunter
02-Nov-23
Vertical bow. 470 Crossbow. 570

From: HUNT MAN
02-Nov-23
430 and yea

From: fuzzy
02-Nov-23
No 540

From: Jeff Durnell
02-Nov-23
650 gr hickories, and take a guess.

From: Murph
02-Nov-23
460 yes

From: Lewis
02-Nov-23
525 no

From: Bowbender
02-Nov-23
~470gr, Rage Hypo's, 272fps

From: carcus
02-Nov-23
Axis 340, regular inserts, 100gr mech, total arrow weight is 420gr, its going 280fps, very happy with the speed out of the fortis 30

From: Joe Holden
02-Nov-23
420 - 475, yes

From: Bake
02-Nov-23
450ish and yes

From: drycreek
02-Nov-23
Mine usually wound up 450 to 465 depending on shaft, and no mechs for deer.

From: njbuck
02-Nov-23
420 and shoot both fixed and mechanical.

From: boobowmen
02-Nov-23
375 yes

From: BOWNUT
02-Nov-23
465

From: x-man
02-Nov-23
420ish yes and no (both)

From: RD in WI
02-Nov-23
462, no

From: Blood
02-Nov-23
575gr. 283 fps. No

From: Michael
02-Nov-23
475 grains and yes I shoot mechanicals.

02-Nov-23
530ish, Yes

From: Lost Arra
02-Nov-23
430 yes and no (both)

From: Stubbleduck
02-Nov-23
419 Yes

From: HDE
02-Nov-23
400. Yes.

From: GFL
02-Nov-23
435 for all animals. Big or small.

From: goelk
02-Nov-23
570 NO

From: Gus
02-Nov-23
515. yes.

From: westgak
02-Nov-23
420. Yes

From: GLP
02-Nov-23
450 - no

From: Lee
02-Nov-23
550, no

02-Nov-23
445. Fixed

From: skull
02-Nov-23
400 yes

From: bowhunter55
02-Nov-23
480ish and yes and no

From: Hoytman2
02-Nov-23
457/Yes

From: Errorhead
02-Nov-23
475ish, NO

02-Nov-23
“650 gr hickories, and take a guess.”

You mean they don’t make mechanicals in glue-on????

From: Coondog
03-Nov-23
536. No.

From: fuzzy
03-Nov-23
Corax they do make threaded adapters that glue on tapered shafts

From: six
03-Nov-23
450 gr no mech.

From: kota-man
03-Nov-23
410 - yep

From: carcus
03-Nov-23
"Axis 340, regular inserts, 100gr mech, total arrow weight is 420gr, its going 280fps, very happy with the speed out of the fortis 30" Oh and yes a mech, always for deer, and this set up got it done on a nice buck yesterday mid day, the deer was dead in 10 seconds, he went maybe 20 yards. IMO a fixed blade is putting you at a disadvantage when it comes to whitetail hunting

From: Scoot
03-Nov-23
456. Yes.

From: 12yards
03-Nov-23
443, Steelhead 421, no 384, Steelhead

Yup, I have three bows I've been hunting with. Shot a doe with the first arrow above.

From: Highlife
03-Nov-23

03-Nov-23
436, No

From: Will
03-Nov-23
410, doing 320fps. Yes, to mechs. Normally they stick in the ground beyond the deer. Once in a while the dont.

From: Blood
03-Nov-23
Finish your data collection yet Bou?

03-Nov-23
Should have added the broadhead model/diameter to the survey.

From: Bentshaft
03-Nov-23

Bentshaft's embedded Photo
Bentshaft's embedded Photo
485 grain. 150 grain broadhead. Axis arrow

03-Nov-23
“they do make threaded adapters that glue on tapered shafts”

I know - I’ve destroyed several! LOL

Just funnier to imagine one purpose-built.

I guest a fixed-blade head is a “disadvantage” or not depends on the shots you’re willing to take….

From: Vonfoust
03-Nov-23
505 not currently.

From: PAOH
03-Nov-23
570 NO

From: WhattheFOC
03-Nov-23
Treestand - 600 No Spot and stalk - 475 No.

From: Copperman
09-Nov-23
475 yes but only on turkeys

From: MoBowhunter
10-Nov-23
417 gr, yes

From: Bowboy
10-Nov-23
410 finished weight broadhead Magnus Buzzcut.

From: SteveB
10-Nov-23
480gr with Exodus swept 100 gr included and just had complete passthrough at 42 yds on a bull . Only shooting 60lbs.

From: bowwild
10-Nov-23
400, no

From: Juancho
12-Nov-23
750, no

From: Ziek
13-Nov-23
550 gr. for everything. No. (except turkey).

From: kota-man
13-Nov-23
431…yes

14-Nov-23
ttt

From: Blood
14-Nov-23
Bou, did you get your data? And what have you surmised from all this?

From: Highlife
14-Nov-23

From: Bou'bound
14-Nov-23
Blood l,

my takeaway is a fair number of guys are using lighter arrows than I thought and many are using them with mechanicals. Granted it is just for smaller deer size game but still interesting. My current set up is 535 for both fixed and mechanical but that had been used for moose elk musk ox and bear as well as deer.

I can go lighter flatter for deer and likely will. Can for bear too but at known short ranges for baited bear the heavy arrows are fine.

From: Blood
14-Nov-23
Gotcha. Just keep in mind - an arrow isn’t heavy if you shoot it fast.

From: Coondog
14-Nov-23
^

From: Nick Muche
14-Nov-23
Those light arrows with a mechanical work well on more than just deer…

From: Bou’bound
15-Nov-23
for what else Nick other than bear, pronghorn, smaller hogs?

From: TGbow
15-Nov-23
450-500 No

From: Rock
20-Nov-23
525-530 for all animals I hunt, COC 4 blade Magnus I, 150 grain.

23-Nov-23
505 no

From: Buffalo1
25-Nov-23
500 gr - 2-blade COC Shooting 46# Elite @ 28”

From: Brotsky
27-Nov-23
455 Both

  • Sitka Gear