Sitka Gear
Another Monster Buck Kill Investigation
Whitetail Deer
Contributors to this thread:
Zbone 31-Dec-23
Bou'bound 31-Dec-23
BoggsBowhunts 31-Dec-23
Missouribreaks 31-Dec-23
Iowa Rut Nut 31-Dec-23
LBshooter 31-Dec-23
Catscratch 31-Dec-23
csalem 31-Dec-23
Pat Lefemine 31-Dec-23
Shug 31-Dec-23
Zbone 01-Jan-24
nchunter 01-Jan-24
BowJangles 02-Jan-24
Zbone 02-Jan-24
BowJangles 02-Jan-24
Iowa booner hunter 02-Jan-24
Brotsky 02-Jan-24
Highlife 02-Jan-24
scentman 02-Jan-24
Iowa booner hunter 02-Jan-24
sitO 02-Jan-24
t-roy 02-Jan-24
Lee 05-Jan-24
bigswivle 05-Jan-24
Zbone 05-Mar-24
Buckdeer 05-Mar-24
Zbone 05-Mar-24
Iowa booner hunter 05-Mar-24
From: Zbone
31-Dec-23

Zbone's embedded Photo
Zbone's embedded Photo

Zbone's Link
"Virginia hunter accused of illegally killing 'one in a million' buck in Richmond"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gnyzEcCSkaw

"This Richmonder was familiar with the Hollywood buck. He says he 'couldn't believe' it was killed"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbgCb_o8Bug

From: Bou'bound
31-Dec-23
How will they ever confirm that deer is the same one? Very common rack structure in that area.

31-Dec-23
Good karma that he got busted after trying to brag about it on social media. The lengths people will go to in order to get likes and comments is sad. I wonder what percentage of poaching cases are rooted in the fact that they want to get clicks and notoriety by exploiting a dead animal. Another example of why hunting social media is bad for hunting.

31-Dec-23
No wonder more and more non hunting voters do not support hunting.

From: Iowa Rut Nut
31-Dec-23
I'm on the TIP board in Iowa and a lot lot poaching cases are made by people posting on FB.

From: LBshooter
31-Dec-23
Well I guess his genes were never put out their and this deer could be a off spring. Can the dnr prove where the deer was killed? Is it not possible the deer left the property and roamed during the rut? Lots to prove other than a pic and if the suspect shuts his mouth I don’t see how they convict. Without his version they can’t prove it was a illegal kill , can they?

From: Catscratch
31-Dec-23
Lots of guys lie about where they shoot big bucks. Way too easy to loose hunting permissions, leases, encourage line sitters, and poachers. Seen all of these happen. As long as the tag is filled out properly it doesn't matter much what is posted of fb. With that said I'd imagine the department has already checked it out before going public with media.

From: csalem
31-Dec-23
Cat you have to be right. The wildlife police would never release that stuff only speculation

From: Pat Lefemine
31-Dec-23
Csalem x2

31-Dec-23

Ricky The Cabel Guy's embedded Photo
Ricky The Cabel Guy's embedded Photo
there appears to be a lot of private land around hollywood cemetary in richmond va. some of it even appears to be crop land. who knows where the buck was and where hunter had permission to be.

should be an interesting investigation.

From: Shug
31-Dec-23
I don’t have photos of it but early if not even pre internet days a famous giant 8 point was taken in NJ.

The buck lived in Bergen county in a ritzy unhuntable area… movie stars- professional athletes- captains of industry etc. It was easily identifiable always had a red coat even in winter and it carried a near 170” 8 point rack with 14/15” brow tines.

So guy kills the buck and someone dimes him out…

When the CO comes to the house to check it out the guy brings him to freezer and shows him the deer. All neatly packaged venison.

When the warded asked to see the antlers the guy responded he didn’t keep them… Did I legally have to keep them he asked..

Check and mate

From: Zbone
01-Jan-24
That's a good one Shug...

From: nchunter
01-Jan-24
I know its doubtful but I would love to find out it was legally taken

From: BowJangles
02-Jan-24
Bou this was a mega popular buck in the area. Folks routinely took photos of him and they had pics of him in the cemetery the day before he was killed. The guy alleged he killed him 70 miles from the cemetery along with 2 other deer that were regularly seen in that buck's company......and this bozo couldn't post them on the internet fast enough! I mean you have to TRY to be that stupid. lol

From: Zbone
02-Jan-24
"The guy alleged he killed him 70 miles from the cemetery away along with 2 other deer that were regularly seen in that buck's company"

Wow, hadn't heard that before...

From: BowJangles
02-Jan-24
Yep! In the post he made about killing Hollywood he mentioned it was his 3rd wall hanger of the season and posted them both to the Star City Whitetails page. They were big but very "standard" racks. Once he posted pics Hollywood it took about .3990059828 seconds for folks to put 2 and 2 together. He's gonna get hammered!

02-Jan-24
Some bucks have been tracked with radio collars over 70 miles, so it could be legit

From: Brotsky
02-Jan-24
Anything for the 'gram! Keep hammered guys!

From: Highlife
02-Jan-24

From: scentman
02-Jan-24
I'm of the belief one way or another your going to get caught... you have to think of the shame it would bring to your family, no less the shame to your reputation from there on. I have lost some good friends because of hunting ethics and lying... I may not have as many deer under my belt, but I have no trouble sleeping at night or enjoying my hard earned table fare. scentman

02-Jan-24
I was joking about that distance traveled, people are idiots trying to get away with this shit in the age of trail cameras. With the most recent big deer that have been poached, makes you wonder how many of the ones in the book from decades ago were poached, bc “before cameras”

From: sitO
02-Jan-24

sitO's Link
Just look at his hat in the pics at bottom of this link, that's really all you need to see.

From: t-roy
02-Jan-24
I don’t doubt that this buck traveled 70 miles overnight. Just too bad it was in the bed of this dipshit’s truck. Never ceases to amaze me, the sheer stupidity of some people.

From: Lee
05-Jan-24
Dumbass

From: bigswivle
05-Jan-24
What an idiot

From: Zbone
05-Mar-24

Zbone's Link

This guy has all kinds of pix and video at the end of this buck...

From: Buckdeer
05-Mar-24
I really doubt any buck traveled 70 miles in one direction.

From: Zbone
05-Mar-24
He'd of had to travel it overnight, he was filmed the day before near the cemetery and showed dead in the shooter's social media page in hero pictures the next day...

05-Mar-24
A deer could easily jog 70 miles overnight, so the idiot only needs to get 12 jurors to believe that

  • Sitka Gear