Moultrie Mobile
WY unit 54 type 9
Elk
Contributors to this thread:
DonVathome 05-Jan-24
DonVathome 05-Jan-24
Murph 05-Jan-24
Murph 05-Jan-24
Willieboat 05-Jan-24
DonVathome 05-Jan-24
Murph 05-Jan-24
Junior 05-Jan-24
Straight Shooter 05-Jan-24
Nyati 05-Jan-24
Bowfreak 05-Jan-24
Jethro 05-Jan-24
pirogue 05-Jan-24
KHNC 05-Jan-24
BLH 05-Jan-24
RonP 05-Jan-24
Murph 05-Jan-24
Charlie Rehor 05-Jan-24
Brotsky 05-Jan-24
Recurve Man 05-Jan-24
midwest 05-Jan-24
Junior 05-Jan-24
thedude 05-Jan-24
cnelk 05-Jan-24
Bowfreak 05-Jan-24
Steve Leffler 05-Jan-24
Tracker 05-Jan-24
RonP 06-Jan-24
cnelk 06-Jan-24
Franzen 06-Jan-24
DonVathome 06-Jan-24
RonP 06-Jan-24
Bowfreak 06-Jan-24
wytex 06-Jan-24
WapitiBob 06-Jan-24
KHNC 08-Jan-24
Bake 08-Jan-24
400 Elk @Home 08-Jan-24
midwest 08-Jan-24
Brotsky 08-Jan-24
Straight Shooter 08-Jan-24
GFL 08-Jan-24
wytex 08-Jan-24
Orion 08-Jan-24
midwest 08-Jan-24
Z Barebow 08-Jan-24
IdyllwildArcher 08-Jan-24
KsRancher 08-Jan-24
Recurve Man 08-Jan-24
Firsty 09-Jan-24
KHNC 09-Jan-24
KsRancher 09-Jan-24
Fulldraw 11-Jan-24
From: DonVathome
05-Jan-24
I could apply, and draw this tag but I would have to pay for 2 special elk tags. I have been putting in someone since points started that no longer wants to elk hunt. I can apply with them and draw but it will cost $4k for the tag. I now LO tags sell for a lot more in other states. I am debating applying for this hunt. I have hunted the area in November for deer. I know the lay of land, private property issues etc.

What are your thoughts? This will cost a lot, and loose a max point chance down the road................

From: DonVathome
05-Jan-24
Resident draw odds near 100%..................

From: Murph
05-Jan-24
I’m not following, you both have the same amount of points or not, what’s the need to buy 2 tags

From: Murph
05-Jan-24
I re read your post I think I’m following you your gonna average your points with a max holder and get into a good LE unit

From: Willieboat
05-Jan-24
Curious why draw attention to a unit you are trying to draw ?

From: DonVathome
05-Jan-24
Good point Willieboat, I debated it, I would rather get the input. There is so much info online now there are not many secrets left, and I do not think 54 is a secret. It is highly unlikely I am dropping $4k so not a huge deal. Murph, your 2nd post was correct.

From: Murph
05-Jan-24
My dad contacted an outfitter last year about a rifle hunt going into this fall with 13 nonresident elk points, the outfitter stated his hunt area only takes about 4 to draw he offered a half price discount to use my dads points to piggy back with a couple other clients that must have had little to no points, he didn’t do it

From: Junior
05-Jan-24
Don, How many points do you have by yourself?

05-Jan-24
Here we go…..

From: Nyati
05-Jan-24
I have max elk points and was contacted by an outfitter to use my points with his clients so they could draw. I was offered a free lodge based elk hunt. I know a guy that hunted there last year. It’s a huge ranch , big lodge, very high success rate but bulls all were 260-280. Lots of big 5x5s. He said there were 13 bulls killed the week he was there with the biggest maybe 290.

It was a nice and extremely generous offer but with max points I’m hoping to get a bigger bull. 18 years is a long time to wait for a 270 bull

From: Bowfreak
05-Jan-24
Don,

I think the point is that you are nuking a spot to some extent, regardless of what you think. I don't even like to discuss the private land I hunt for whitetails with friends I can trust just in case they were to mention it in passing to someone I can't trust. My bet is you know quite a few people on Bowsite that you could have contacted by PM for input. if they didn't know they would know who to tell you to contact.

From: Jethro
05-Jan-24
Agree Bowfreak. Hopefully anyone that decides to discuss it with Don has the courtesy to do it with a PM.

From: pirogue
05-Jan-24
So who knew, back when WY went to points, that down the road, a max point holder could probably hunt free, just by sharing his points?

From: KHNC
05-Jan-24
If anyone is looking to use 15pts or more to draw a primo area, I can offer some input. I personally saw 30-35 branch antler bulls in one evening this past november, along with a crazy number of cows and spikes. At least 6 of these bulls were 330+ 6pts. This area would be a phenomenal hunt, especially with an outfitter. It was just one evening on BLM for me DIY.

From: BLH
05-Jan-24
I did...and so did anyone else that saw what was going on in other states that already had point systems. Exactly why I don't like point systems and in particular point averaging.

I've been offered having my tags paid for, cash, private access etc. for sharing points. Never have done it.

From: RonP
05-Jan-24
i would ask myself what other hunt(s) can i do for my $4K +/- budget that i would be satisfied with as i build more pp's.

if nothing satisfies, since you know the lay of the land and feel pretty good about killing an elk, i'd execute the plan and not look back.

From: Murph
05-Jan-24
How is saying your thinking about applying LE unit 54 that takes 9-10 preference points for type 9 ruining the unit

05-Jan-24
So from your post above, if you’re “highly unlikely” to do this why are you soliciting opinions? Curious.

From: Brotsky
05-Jan-24
Scorched earth policy for everyone I guess Charlie...."I'm just curious so I'll post an exact area and tag type. Screw all you guys that have been applying there."

The exact question could have been asked without listing an area or tag type.

From: Recurve Man
05-Jan-24
If I had the points I’d be looking at 126, 6, or 3 units. Sleeper units that most guys drive through to hunt elk.

From: midwest
05-Jan-24
^^^How to ruin sleeper units and screw the guys that "had the points"^^^

From: Junior
05-Jan-24
Lol..I wouldn't call them sleeper units. General units for 2 of them and all 3 can wadd your panties when the elk run to the private ranches!

From: thedude
05-Jan-24
This topic just added 100 applicants to that area.

From: cnelk
05-Jan-24
There is a big hunting forum that will nuke any thread that lists units or areas

What a concept.

From: Bowfreak
05-Jan-24
Exactly Brad.

05-Jan-24
I will side with Don. Not sure how saying you might apply for a unit makes 100 others apply. DonV is a good hunter but doesn't have the name recognition of Chuck Adams or Fred Eichler or something. He didn't name a drainage or specific town. I cant imagine someone with 6-8 points reading the above and saying ”thats it, I am applying to unit 54.

From: Tracker
05-Jan-24
$4000 to kill a good bull these days is cheap and it is a hunt you can do this year. I have a friend that has aged out of his elk hunts and I plan on doing the same things as you. WY is only going to get worse with the increase in the Special Draw tag fee. Also 300+ bulls are getting more difficult to kill each year and having a good hunt and killing a 280 might be "The great hunt" going forward. I hunted 38 Type 9 6 years ago and it was an amazing hunt. Last year hunted with friends only one of 3 tagged out and that was with a reputable guide. I have 17 NR deer points in WY and will not hesitate to share them with an Outfitter for a good hunt in return.

From: RonP
06-Jan-24
"There is a big hunting forum that will nuke any thread that lists units or areas." Whether this has had an effect is not measurable but safe to say it is doubtful based on the data and field reports. Numerous other hunting forums and companies are in business that allow it and promote it.

"This topic just added 100 applicants to that area." If true that's good for those that are applying elsewhere. Maybe it is a strategy because after all, you can't believe everything you read especially on hunting forums.

From: cnelk
06-Jan-24
“ Whether this has had an effect is not measurable but safe to say it is doubtful based on the data and field reports. Numerous other hunting forums and companies are in business that allow it (posting of unit numbers) and promote it.”

RonP - Go ahead and post your areas and unit numbers you hunt then. ;)

From: Franzen
06-Jan-24
So all the guys on here that ruined WY in general are okay? What BS.

From: DonVathome
06-Jan-24
If I am going to burn $4k on an elk tag I am going to do my research. I was not able to find a lot of CURRENT info on 54 type 9. I looked on MM, Rokslide, hunt talk, google etc. Almost nothing. I reached out to several hard core WY hunters and still no new data so I posted here. Yes I could have attracted a few new apps, I am sorry if that hurts anyone but I learned over a decade ago there are almost no more well kept secrets.

It is rare that I post what unit I apply for before I draw. This time I did. I usually post after my hunt so I can help out future hunters - unless I plan to return then I might not.

If asking about a specific unit, before I burn 19 points and $4k tag fees, $1.5k past point fees, airfare, rental truck etc, is all it takes to get other hunters attacking me then I feel sorry for what we have come to as hunters.

From: RonP
06-Jan-24
"RonP - Go ahead and post your areas and unit numbers you hunt then. ;)"

B K - in wyoming units 110 and 10. in oregon it is mainly the grizzly, ochoco, maury, and silvies units. now that corner hopping is legal in wyoming, the hunting has gotten even better. all public land, have at it.

thanks for being an admirer and follower. ;)

From: Bowfreak
06-Jan-24
Good on you Don. Make sure you get yours. Once you burn your points it won’t matter anymore, right?

From: wytex
06-Jan-24
Good grief, good luck Don. I would contact an outfitter and see what deal they would make with you to share your PPs. Tons of folks do this, and some even share with total strangers imagine that !

If he posts areas and that makes it harder for NRs to draw that is a good thing for us residents, lol. Spreads them out from general areas. When did this forum turn into Rokslide?

From: WapitiBob
06-Jan-24
54 has had a boundary change for '24, and a new hunt area 64.

From: KHNC
08-Jan-24
Rokslide has properly addressed this type of thing. No info on a certain unit is very good. It shows progress is being made on spot burning and hopefully point creep. And yes Wyotex, you are correct , it does help the residents more. We know how Wy residents feel about NR's coming to their state to hunt their elk and deer.

From: Bake
08-Jan-24
Don has been posting hunt unit numbers for years on this site. Most recently with a sheep thread. I asked (very respectfully I thought) on that thread why he would post a unit number, and he ignored my question entirely. Frankly, I don't get it.

If you google "[don's sheep unit] sheep montana", Don's Bowsite post is the 4th result. So anyone looking at harvest numbers or doing research who google's the unit, has that resource right there, with lots of pictures. So it's no doubt going to raise the applications for that unit. Yet the post doesn't share any details about where in the unit sheep were found, etc. So I question how it "helps other hunters"

Now I'm all for sharing information. Let's just be a little mindful of how it's done.

08-Jan-24
So,

You have been building points in someone else’s name and now plan on using their points to draw a tag without them hunting. I would be willing to bet Wyoming Game and Fish would be interested in this thread. My guess, this would not be legal and is a terrible idea to post on the internet…but what do I know.

From: midwest
08-Jan-24
100% legal....he's not using the other guy's tag. Many guys are buying points for their wives, kids, friends, etc. so they can use them to average with their own down the road.

From: Brotsky
08-Jan-24
How many points does Buddy have now Nick? :)

08-Jan-24
400 Elk- nothing wrong with combining points it’s been going on for years. He’d have his tag allocated to him and have to “burn” the other.

From: GFL
08-Jan-24
My group has been doing this for years in Wyoming for elk. We just apply for NR general units and go hunt elk most years. Point creep is finally ending the fun of us going every year now. No way I would wait 15 years to go hunt elk there.

From: wytex
08-Jan-24
KHNC I've been helping NR come hunt Wyoming for years, not all Rs look at NR as the plague. They have tags allocated why not help them fill those licenses? Lots of us feel this way. All this info is out there online now, no taking it all back. Does no good to chastise folks for posting area numbers, they have all been posted.

From: Orion
08-Jan-24
I see Don VonDouche is still burning spots on the internet. I'm sure he won't even hunt there since he is afraid of grizzlies. He's also been run off of monstermuleys for burning spots and he couldn't take the razzing for sleeping in his truck and eating a Wyoming sheep tag because he was scared of the bears.

From: midwest
08-Jan-24
"How many points does Buddy have now Nick? :)"

The bastard won't share them, Justin! He says he wants a primo unit for himself!

From: Z Barebow
08-Jan-24
Smart dog!

08-Jan-24
Don, I support what you're doing so long as you clear your units with me before posting :)

From: KsRancher
08-Jan-24
Thread hijacking here. As a NR is there really much sense in starting to build points in WY. The first time I went elk hunting in Colorado OTC 12yrs or so ago. I thought it was going to be a one and done trip. Now I am hooked. Would love to hunt other states if there is a reasonable chance of actually drawing. Currently hunting Co limited entry low point units. Having a blast doing it but wouldn't mind trying other states.

From: Recurve Man
08-Jan-24
I’m the guy who’s always giving out information at my camp. You stop by my camp and I’ll give ya all kinds of intel where they’re bugling and stuff. Sometimes it works great to see trucks parked where you want them instead of in your spot. The old reverse physiology works on hunters just like it does kids.

How many guys you talk to that aren’t seeing or hearing anything. I’m not that guy. I’m a free talker if you meet me in the elk woods. This approach has worked well for me for years.

Shane

From: Firsty
09-Jan-24
The best was DonZ unit 76 debacle from years back........

From: KHNC
09-Jan-24
Ks, if you dont have points in Wyoming, you are looking at 7-8 years to get a tag

From: KsRancher
09-Jan-24
Thanks KHNC. I will look into it. Not sure if I am interested in chasing that

From: Fulldraw
11-Jan-24
Rusty- for $50 you aren’t out much..7 years from now when you don’t have the points to go, you’ll kick yourself. I have been buying points for many years, and gonna use them for Wyoming…maybe Utah also. Not a unit in Wyoming that won’t rival the best OTC Colorado units

  • Sitka Gear