Gaia Privacy Settings
General Topic
Contributors to this thread:
cnelk 01-Sep-24
cnelk 01-Sep-24
Stix 01-Sep-24
midwest 01-Sep-24
DanaC 02-Sep-24
Jethro 02-Sep-24
WapitiBob 02-Sep-24
DanaC 03-Sep-24
cnelk 03-Sep-24
Orion 03-Sep-24
smarba 03-Sep-24
cnelk 03-Sep-24
cnelk 03-Sep-24
cnelk 03-Sep-24
WapitiBob 03-Sep-24
DanaC 03-Sep-24
Tilzbow 03-Sep-24
WV Mountaineer 03-Sep-24
DanaC 04-Sep-24
jordanathome 04-Sep-24
cnelk 04-Sep-24
TEmbry 04-Sep-24
Tilzbow 04-Sep-24
DanaC 04-Sep-24
smarba 04-Sep-24
jordanathome 04-Sep-24
Orion 05-Sep-24
WapitiBob 05-Sep-24
Orion 05-Sep-24
WapitiBob 05-Sep-24
Orion 05-Sep-24
WapitiBob 05-Sep-24
cnelk 05-Sep-24
Orion 05-Sep-24
From: cnelk
01-Sep-24

cnelk's Link
If you use Gaia, they decided to make everyone’s profile public. Not cool.

I just saw that Gaia is automatically opting all users into a public profile through outsideonline.com, meaning that all activity will be publicly shared. To change to a private account, you have to log in and update your privacy settings via the link.

01-Sep-24
OnX shares it also

01-Sep-24

Altitude Sickness 's Link
Pretty much every app. Every site you visit. Your gps location Even when the phone is off. Is sold to entities that sell it to the 3 letter agencies.

From: cnelk
01-Sep-24
Apparently you don’t have Gaia

From: Stix
01-Sep-24
That's why I use the free version. They know nothing about me other than my spam email address.

From: midwest
01-Sep-24
Used to like Gaia better than OnX. I've since dumped it.

02-Sep-24
Stix, read the article I posted. And look into this topic.

Advertisers and companies track you by many different tactics.

In your cell phone contract it states you give permission for these companies to gather any and all information about you. They then sell that data.

The government realized, instead of gaining a warrant they could just buy that data too.

Your phone dumps all the data every day. usually about 2:00 AM

This is not tinfoil hat stuff it’s a fact.

From: DanaC
02-Sep-24

DanaC's embedded Photo
DanaC's embedded Photo
Funny, but true...

From: Jethro
02-Sep-24
Has been reports of people changing their account to private. Then a day or 2 later they find it has changed back to public. So monitor your account closely if this applies to you.

From: WapitiBob
02-Sep-24
Big difference between phones giving the Gov some data and Gaia publishing your waypoints and tracks to everybody that has the app.

From: DanaC
03-Sep-24
Just curious, has anyone here been able to access 'somebody else's' data? You know, just to find 'scenic' spots.

From: cnelk
03-Sep-24
Yes. There are lots of tracks that people have made public.

From: Orion
03-Sep-24
This all came out on the corner crossing case. All you ONX points are public information ONX provided them in court. There is also been some threads circulating that ONX employees are using peoples waypoints and info for certain units

03-Sep-24
It’s well known. You signed the agreement for your cell phone contract and OnX stating your aware they own and sell your data.

Unless you own the cell phone brand called (UNPLUGGED) it does not store then sell your data

From: smarba
03-Sep-24
Building on what some have stated, has anyone experienced more people showing up in areas you didn't expect that could "likely" be traced to access to online data points (e.g. OnX)? Are any of you paranoid enough to have stopped using online data, or changed your point naming strategy to be less useful to those who may have access to it?

From: cnelk
03-Sep-24

cnelk's embedded Photo
cnelk's embedded Photo
I’ll turn on ‘Public Tracks’ and post a few screenshots. Stay tuned.

From: cnelk
03-Sep-24

cnelk's embedded Photo
cnelk's embedded Photo
I selected a spot just east of the Platte River Wilderness in Wyoming - see the coords.

These are the listed public tracks in that area.

From: cnelk
03-Sep-24

cnelk's embedded Photo
cnelk's embedded Photo
Here’s one place of many in the Wyo Bighorns that has Public Tracks

From: WapitiBob
03-Sep-24
"This all came out on the corner crossing case. All you ONX points are public information ONX provided them in court. There is also been some threads circulating that ONX employees are using peoples waypoints and info for certain units"

The OnX data was provided after a subpoena, it's not public data.

From: DanaC
03-Sep-24
" The OnX data was provided after a subpoena, it's not public data. "

If it's available by any means, it might as well be. I always assumed that data was stored on your phone - like a GPS - not in 'the cloud'. Yet another reason not to upgrade ;-)/2

(and just now realized that all my Google maps 'favorite places' are not stored here but 'out there'.)

From: Tilzbow
03-Sep-24
Assuming the information was public, how would you know some total stranger’s waypoints and data are worth a damn for the purpose of hunting? I mean you could be using some random woke hiker’s information who marked a spot where they took a dump or saw a special bird or rock or something having nothing to do with hunting. In fact that’s what you’d most likely be doing by using some unknown person’s waypoints.

03-Sep-24
Welp, I checked my GAIA and my settings were on private. I hope that my pocket dialing prowess has keep it that way from day one.

I know one thing, my on phone date will be transferred onto my gps chips manually, then it’s coming off my phone. And my subscription to Gaia will be reevaluated if it’s worth having on my phone at all.

From: DanaC
04-Sep-24
"" how would you know some total stranger’s waypoints and data are worth a damn for the purpose of hunting? ""

You wouldn't be looking for a random strangers' waypoints. However, if you could search by name for, let's say, guys who post trophy pictures from a state you were thinking about hunting, it could be a 'useful starting point.'

(Obviously, the ethics of doing this is a whole other discussion!)

From: jordanathome
04-Sep-24
Hell Brad....I've been using your Gaia waypoints for years......... lmao....just fibbing.

From: cnelk
04-Sep-24
Well Jordan, if you had you would have killed an elk by now ;)

From: TEmbry
04-Sep-24
Publicly visible waypoints and profiles from an app you use to track your hunting spots is vastly different than the government secretly knowing where you are. I’ve never used GAIA but I promise I’ll delete every single waypoint and then the app if OnX ever tried this route.

I don’t care if the government gets my data, I always assume they have it whether they admit it or not. I don’t want the public to see my hunting spots. Crazy concept.

From: Tilzbow
04-Sep-24
“You wouldn't be looking for a random strangers' waypoints. However, if you could search by name for, let's say, guys who post trophy pictures from a state you were thinking about hunting, it could be a 'useful starting point.'“

Call me a skeptic but that seems like a reach, not impossible, but go ahead and worry about it if you want.

From: DanaC
04-Sep-24
Not 'worried' about it, just pondering how the technology might be use - or abused.

If you read any contemporary science fiction, (Cory Doctorow for instance) you know there are people pondering far more advanced privacy issues than this one.

From: smarba
04-Sep-24
If someone makes a point with "elk" symbol in an out-of-the-way location, it could be very useful info. Or if dozens of points all show up one particular valley, that could also be helpful. So I don't buy the "who knows if the point is where someone saw a bird or took a dump" theory. Sure, there may be lots of shrapnel, but I guarantee if I had access to every Bowsiter's points for a particular unit I could find plenty of useful info.

So back to my question, is anyone paranoid enough to mark points with "pig" symbols instead of "elk" or "house" instead of "deer" in case their data is being seen by someone else?

I do believe the EASE of sharing points thru OnX, and the ease of seeing access points or small accessible areas has ruined more spots than back when it was harder to use GPS, paper maps, etc.

From: jordanathome
04-Sep-24
BURN!!!! damn you brad....LOLOLOL

From: Orion
05-Sep-24
Thanks for making my point Bob that ONX employees can look up any individuals account and access all their way points. Smarba I never mark my points with elk or any other symbol. Especially after my buddy who guides for a renowned Utah and Arizona outfitter that is known for putting big animals on the ground. Let's just say he ran into a go hunt founder in Arizona in a very secluded spot they had never seen anyone before. The go hunt member may or may not have admitted of getting waypoint info from ONX for his hunt

From: WapitiBob
05-Sep-24
I was covered in Bulls on Saturday and made a cpl waypoints. If you can get the coords from an OnX employee, I'll venmo each of you $1,000.

From: Orion
05-Sep-24
Your right bob it doesn't happen I'm sure no onx employee has ever looked at anyone's profile for some waypoints on a unit they have drawn. Your kidding yourself if you do not think they are sharing info with HUSH, go hunt or any other of their big time collaborates. Your also foolish if you don't think they are looking at super successful outfitters accounts to get some Intel on units, especially on hard to draw Arizona and Utah elk tags

From: WapitiBob
05-Sep-24
You really think the owner of Onx is going to risk his entire business by letting an employee access a clients data? Clearly you've never owned a business.

From: Orion
05-Sep-24
It says your info and data is public right on their policy so why does it matter who accesses it? How are you 100% sure it has never happened? Lots of people own businesses who do shady stuff everyday. You think Zuckerberg gives two shits who is employees are giving Facebook and Instagram data to? You think the head of the IRS gave two shits when agents were illegally auditing Republicans awhile back?

From: WapitiBob
05-Sep-24
“The personal content you submit to the Service (waypoints, tracks, etc.) belongs to you, and you may choose to share it with other users through the Service. onXmaps does not disclose individual account data with other users or third parties unless we’re legally compelled to do so.“

Doesn’t sound like it’s very public.

From: cnelk
05-Sep-24
Become good acquaintances with the data base administrator of a large company, ask a few questions and you’ll get some answers.

While it may be against company policy, it happens. I’ve seen it happen.

From: Orion
05-Sep-24
Nice to avoid all the other questions Bob. Your kidding yourself if you don't think some intern or other person in the company has never shared info. Your naiveness is commendable.

  • Sitka Gear