Sitka Gear
change of plans
Mule Deer
Contributors to this thread:
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Stoneman 08-Sep-24
Yttails 08-Sep-24
molsonarcher 08-Sep-24
Supernaut 08-Sep-24
Rgiesey 08-Sep-24
Rgiesey 08-Sep-24
JB 08-Sep-24
drycreek 08-Sep-24
cnelk 08-Sep-24
sitO 08-Sep-24
Scoot 08-Sep-24
BillyD 08-Sep-24
TMac 08-Sep-24
HUNT MAN 08-Sep-24
Bowfinatic 08-Sep-24
Quinn @work 08-Sep-24
EmbryOklahoma 08-Sep-24
Treeline 08-Sep-24
JohnMC 09-Sep-24
BC 09-Sep-24
APauls 09-Sep-24
Beav 09-Sep-24
In2dmtns 09-Sep-24
Michael 09-Sep-24
bowhunter24 09-Sep-24
iceman 09-Sep-24
pav 09-Sep-24
Al Dente Laptop 09-Sep-24
njbuck 09-Sep-24
Buckdeer 09-Sep-24
VAMtns 09-Sep-24
BOWNBIRDHNTR 09-Sep-24
WV Mountaineer 09-Sep-24
Stoneman 09-Sep-24
WhattheFOC 10-Sep-24
Jaquomo 10-Sep-24
Stoneman 11-Sep-24
Insheart 11-Sep-24
Bowboy 19-Oct-24
Kurt 19-Oct-24
t-roy 19-Oct-24
Wymuley 19-Oct-24
Ron Niziolek 19-Oct-24
Paul@thefort 19-Oct-24
Stoneman 19-Oct-24
From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24
This is my second-year hunting in Wyoming and this year I would be missing opening day for elk. I had prior commitments that were going to keep me away until the 1st of September at least. Since I have the whole month off to hunt, I wasn’t overly concerned but there’s just something about the lead up and preparation that I look forward to each year.

So, change of plans. I still had a deer tag, and this was the first year I was able to put in for pronghorn and I drew a tag close to home.

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Plus, I have seen some mule deer in the area, so I had options.

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24
I set a blind up in August and was able to sit a few hours on a couple different days. Being in no rush I passed on several small bucks wanting to see what else this area might hold. From all my scouting the majority of the bucks were just average with a few that might make 70”. Either way, I had options.

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
I got back early afternoon on the 1st and while it was too late to sit in the blind, I could go look for deer. There was one or two nice ones in the area I was hunting so that was the plan and tomorrow I would spend time in the box.

Optimistically I grabbed my gear and bow and headed out to make the loop above and around the main drainage. I got some exercise, bumped several pronghorn and made a stalk on a pair of mule deer does so not a complete waste of time. On the way back over the last ridge I saw movement, 4 of the bucks I had been seeing were together. One was better than the others but his little brother wasn’t bad either. I watched them crest the ridge and disappear. Seeing them sparked my interest so for tomorrow, change of plans.

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Looking at the weather it was going to be overcast with some rain off and on. Knowing this it was unlikely I would catch the deer bedding where I had hoped, still I would check though. Mid-morning and after not seeing the bucks I was second guessing my decision to hunt deer, even on overcast days pronghorn need to drink.

One more scan of the valley and I pick up one of the 4 amigos. I find a place to glass and start finding his 3 buddies either bedded or browsing in the thick bushes on the valley floor. One is better than the others.

I had good wind but until they all bedded It would be impossible to get close. I watched until they were all laying down and devised a plan to come in from above. I remember talking to another Bowsite member about how this plan rarely works, but I had to give it a try. Just about then they all get up and decide to relocate. Being overcast with some light rain they didn’t need to stay bedded in the shade but could be up and feeding around mid-day.

I watched them as they worked around the valley towards another draw that would take them back to the main drainage. I quickly gathered my gear and took off to intercept them if possible. Keeping tabs on them as best they could I came around the north side of the point to see if they were still on the same path… nothing. So, I hurried around the hill as quietly as possible only to find a herd of pronghorn feeding and bedding at the base of the draw. Not wanting to blow them out and take the deer with them I showed them just enough to get them nervous and leave. Now I need find some cover if the md bucks stay on course. I was just about to move below a swell 20 yards in front of me and one of the 4 amigos pops up 80 yards out and I hit the dirt. All good as he didn’t see me. First him then 2 others came into view. Where was their big brother? They were feeding right towards me putting them on a path that would be inside 10 yards with no cover this would not end well. The 4th one comes around the point and catches up, now all are around 40 yards out. I’m eating dirt…

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
The buck is bedded below me about 30 yards, you can see the tops of his back tines.
Stoneman's embedded Photo
The buck is bedded below me about 30 yards, you can see the tops of his back tines.
There is a shelf to my left and just below the swell I was trying to get to. They are all hard horned except the one I’m focused on. He beds below the shelf about 30 yards away and slightly to my left. He’s completely hidden except for a couple of back tines. The rest bed in front or slightly to my right all within about 35 yards or so.

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
I think they call this a Mexican standoff. For the next 35 to 45 minutes, I slowly get my day pack bino harness off, still eating dirt! I can’t even pick my nose without 2 of the amigos getting nervous, standing up, staring, then repositioning and bedding again.

From: Stoneman
08-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
I decide enough is enough and slowly grab my bow keeping it horizontal I unclip an arrow, eyes are on me now so it’s go time!

I raise my bow and nock my arrow, everyone comes unglued and time stops as I focus on the velvet buck. He’s looking at the 3 amigos trying to figure out what happened since he was completely blocked from seeing me until he jumped out of his bed. I was already sitting up with my bow drawn, as I was trying to settle my pins the lower cam was caught on some scrub! Shit! I pushed forward and settled my pin, the arrow on the way. It buried just in front of his left shoulder as he was slightly quartering towards me. He jumped and mule kicked and I knew I had him.

I stood up and it was dead quiet. I didn’t even see where the other bucks went. I walked to where he was standing expecting to see him somewhere to the left in the valley below me. Nothing, dang, I even took a pan with my binoculars. So, I turned around to find blood. Which wasn’t hard, about 5 steps to my right was a good trail and just a few yards past that the buck was down. What a rush. I felt very fortunate to pull off a stalk on this mule deer buck with nothing but luck on my side.

From: Yttails
08-Sep-24
Awesome hunt! Congratulations on a good looking buck!

From: molsonarcher
08-Sep-24
Congrats! Good looking deer. Great write up

From: Supernaut
08-Sep-24
Great hunt, write up and pics. Thanks for sharing with is.

Congrats on a beautiful buck!

From: Rgiesey
08-Sep-24
Good looking buck! Congratulations!!

From: Rgiesey
08-Sep-24
Good looking buck! Congratulations!!

From: JB
08-Sep-24
Beautiful buck! Great job!!

From: drycreek
08-Sep-24
Sometimes it’s better to be lucky than good. It’s an old cliche, but true. Nice buck Stoneman !

From: cnelk
08-Sep-24
Congrats Dave

From: sitO
08-Sep-24
Cool hunt, congrats and thanks for sharing here!

From: Scoot
08-Sep-24
Awesome- WTG!

From: BillyD
08-Sep-24
This is great! Congrats, Dave. Very nice buck. Thanks for sharing with us.

From: TMac
08-Sep-24
Great write up and deer congrats.

From: HUNT MAN
08-Sep-24
Awesome buck!!

08-Sep-24
That's a great hunt! Well done on a pretty buck

From: Quinn @work
08-Sep-24
Congrats Dave. Great looking buck!

08-Sep-24
Congratulations, Dave! Nice work!

From: Treeline
08-Sep-24
That change of plans worked out beautifully! Congratulations on a great mule deer done the hard way! Damn tough to keep your composure in those kind of situations! Well done!

From: JohnMC
09-Sep-24
Great buck!

From: BC
09-Sep-24
Good going. Nice buck

From: APauls
09-Sep-24
Heck yeah man - congrats!!!!

From: Beav
09-Sep-24
Congrats on a beautiful buck!

From: In2dmtns
09-Sep-24
Congratulations

From: Michael
09-Sep-24
Congratulations on a great buck!

From: bowhunter24
09-Sep-24
Well done sir awesome buck! Thanks for taking us along to eat some dirt!

From: iceman
09-Sep-24
Congrats!

From: pav
09-Sep-24
Great buck! Congrats!!!

09-Sep-24
Congratulations.

From: njbuck
09-Sep-24
Congrats on a nice buck!

From: Buckdeer
09-Sep-24
great buck

From: VAMtns
09-Sep-24
WTG Good Work

From: BOWNBIRDHNTR
09-Sep-24
Sometimes the best made plans are the ones you didn't plan on! Congrats!!

09-Sep-24
Heck yeah!!!!!! I love it.

From: Stoneman
09-Sep-24

Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Stoneman's embedded Photo
Thanks everyone! I’m not going to lie it felt really good to pull off a spot and stalk in open country. The hardest part was trying to get a decent picture with this buck.

I was a little concerned on how a mule deer from this area would taste. To a large extent “you are what you eat”. He had a slab of fat on his back and rump that reminded me of an early November buck getting ready for the rut. First I sautéed some of the hind trim and since grilled loin steaks, unbelievably delicious! Like he’s been eating ag all summer. Bonus!

From: WhattheFOC
10-Sep-24
Awesome!! My buddy used to guide in BC - he said early season muley was great eating … but the November version was ‘an acquired taste’. Congrats.

From: Jaquomo
10-Sep-24
Great job, David! Now on to the next challenge!

From: Stoneman
11-Sep-24
GG I’ve had a few early season high mountain deer and several Co plains deer both mulies and white tails taken in November, all were great eating. Like I’ve said “you are what you eat” and that couldn’t be more true with mule deer.

High country deer feed primarily on alpine grass and browse. Plains deer normally have access to ag; corn, wheat, oats, etc which makes up most of their browse and largely accounts for their great table fare. imo

I do agree all that changes to some extent when a mature buck is rutting. All the more reason for the best field care you can achieve but that’s no guarantee.

From: Insheart
11-Sep-24
Very nice, congratulations.

From: Bowboy
19-Oct-24
Congrats

From: Kurt
19-Oct-24
Good story, photos and congratulations on a nice mulie!!!!

From: t-roy
19-Oct-24
Missed this the first time. Congrats on a nice buck, Stoneman!

From: Wymuley
19-Oct-24
Beautiful buck SM. Of course, you will have to p.m. me the grid coordinates to make the story more believable. ??

From: Ron Niziolek
19-Oct-24
I missed this back in September. Congrats on a great buck!

From: Paul@thefort
19-Oct-24
Dave, Nice, I also missed this story in early Sept as I was out and about. Good for you. When are you going to move back to Colorado? :) My best, Paul

From: Stoneman
19-Oct-24
Paul, that ship has sailed! Moving to Wyoming has been great.

However I wouldn’t miss a Co. Bowsite get together especially if moose was on the menu! I figure between you and Brad there should be some leftover moose burger ; )

Congratulations on completing your Co. Big 9, well earned and well deserved!

  • Sitka Gear