Mathews Inc.
Was your biggest on camera?
Whitetail Deer
Contributors to this thread:
Bou'bound 31-Dec-24
Shug 31-Dec-24
HunterR 31-Dec-24
milnrick 31-Dec-24
t-roy 31-Dec-24
SBH 31-Dec-24
Stekewood 31-Dec-24
Robear 31-Dec-24
redneck hunter 31-Dec-24
Lone Wolf 31-Dec-24
Lewis 31-Dec-24
njbuck 31-Dec-24
Bowhunter09 31-Dec-24
12yards 31-Dec-24
Charlie Rehor 31-Dec-24
caribou77 31-Dec-24
SD 31-Dec-24
Basil 31-Dec-24
Basil 31-Dec-24
Overland 31-Dec-24
Norseman 31-Dec-24
hdaman 31-Dec-24
WV Mountaineer 31-Dec-24
MA-PAdeerslayer 31-Dec-24
Scott/IL 31-Dec-24
Iowa booner hunter 31-Dec-24
HUNT MAN 31-Dec-24
yeager 31-Dec-24
fastflight 31-Dec-24
Dave B 31-Dec-24
Brian M. 31-Dec-24
pav 31-Dec-24
Candor 31-Dec-24
Recurve Man 31-Dec-24
boobowmen 31-Dec-24
Bowfinatic 31-Dec-24
BIGOK2 31-Dec-24
StickFlicker 01-Jan-25
Marty 01-Jan-25
BillyD 01-Jan-25
BillyD 01-Jan-25
Corax_latrans 01-Jan-25
deerhunter72 01-Jan-25
Cazador 01-Jan-25
Mark Watkins 01-Jan-25
Steve Leffler 01-Jan-25
Ahawkeye 01-Jan-25
M.Pauls 01-Jan-25
dnovo 01-Jan-25
Bou'bound 01-Jan-25
kakiatkids 01-Jan-25
Pyrannah 01-Jan-25
The Big Easy 01-Jan-25
Ironbow 01-Jan-25
TEmbry 01-Jan-25
Schmitty78 01-Jan-25
Pat Lefemine 01-Jan-25
T-rex 02-Jan-25
Joe Holden 02-Jan-25
APauls 02-Jan-25
TonyBear 02-Jan-25
TREESTANDWOLF 02-Jan-25
Shiras42 02-Jan-25
Rock 02-Jan-25
Don K 02-Jan-25
WhattheFOC 02-Jan-25
Bou'bound 02-Jan-25
Bou'bound 02-Jan-25
SteveB 02-Jan-25
Gun 02-Jan-25
drycreek 02-Jan-25
TREESTANDWOLF 02-Jan-25
Hans 1 05-Jan-25
Fulldraw1972 05-Jan-25
Beav 05-Jan-25
carcus 05-Jan-25
Bou'bound 05-Jan-25
drycreek 05-Jan-25
goyt 06-Jan-25
greenmountain 06-Jan-25
Bou'bound 06-Jan-25
FORESTBOWS 06-Jan-25
iceman 06-Jan-25
mattandersen 07-Jan-25
Nick Muche 14-Jan-25
Two Dogs 14-Jan-25
Bou'bound 14-Jan-25
Brotsky 14-Jan-25
Tater 14-Jan-25
Bou'bound 14-Jan-25
badlander 15-Jan-25
Shug 16-Jan-25
From: Bou'bound
31-Dec-24
Was the largest white tail, you ever killed present on a trail camera picture that you saw before killing it.

You can just say yes or say no but for those that say yes also add the year that you killed the big boy

31-Dec-24
no

From: Shug
31-Dec-24
Yes

From: HunterR
31-Dec-24

From: milnrick
31-Dec-24
Yes, 2013 (167 P&Y)

From: t-roy
31-Dec-24
Yes. 2017

From: SBH
31-Dec-24
Yes. 2017

From: Stekewood
31-Dec-24
No

From: Robear
31-Dec-24
No

31-Dec-24
No.

From: Lone Wolf
31-Dec-24
Yes

From: Lewis
31-Dec-24
Not yet

From: njbuck
31-Dec-24
In this day and age of trail and cell cams, I don’t think there are many bucks that aren’t on at least someone’s cam.

From: Bowhunter09
31-Dec-24

Bowhunter09's embedded Photo
Bowhunter09's embedded Photo
Yes 2023

From: 12yards
31-Dec-24

12yards's embedded Photo
12yards's embedded Photo
No, but I have killed a few that were on camera. This is a picture of the buck I killed this year within seconds of me shooting him. He's about to paw at a scrape that is right in front of him.

31-Dec-24
Maybe that’s a factor as to why there are less now? Ya think?

From: caribou77
31-Dec-24

caribou77's embedded Photo
caribou77's embedded Photo
Sorta? I don’t run trail cams but 3 days after killing, my neighbor showed me pics

From: SD
31-Dec-24

SD's embedded Photo
SD's embedded Photo
Bowbender, here's the inverse twin of yours! Did you happen to measure yours?

From: Basil
31-Dec-24
No for me. I rarely see the biggest bucks that wander in front of my cameras.

From: Basil
31-Dec-24

From: Overland
31-Dec-24
Nope.

From: Norseman
31-Dec-24
No, she was before cell phones.

From: hdaman
31-Dec-24
No

31-Dec-24
Nope.

31-Dec-24
Yes, 2020 but no picture where I killed him. Killed him over a mile away as the crow flies and across a road from where I had all his pictures.

From: Scott/IL
31-Dec-24
Yes, 174 1/8”.

Killed him this year and I had pictures of him the last 3 years. I shot him on 11/11 and I had not had pictures of him since 10/16, but I used the previous years pictures to set myself in an area that he eventually would show up in during the rut. I know of at least 4 other properties that were actively hunting him.

31-Dec-24
I only have one picture of my top 5, the smallest one of the top 5. I was running 3-5 cameras per year back then and was always mystified why I never was able to get a picture even though I was seeing em from the stand

From: HUNT MAN
31-Dec-24

HUNT MAN's embedded Photo
HUNT MAN's embedded Photo
Yes

From: yeager
31-Dec-24
Nope, didn’t have a camera then.

From: fastflight
31-Dec-24
No

From: Dave B
31-Dec-24
Yes, 2020. Had a couple years of pics, gross 163. Funny, I didn't know it was him that I killed until I sent the 'as he lay' pic to my brother. Happened too fast, just grabbed my bow and shot.

From: Brian M.
31-Dec-24
No. Not on my camera. After I killed my biggest recurve buck, a guy in MA sent me a pic of it. It was killed in CT.

From: pav
31-Dec-24
Yes, only one photo ever, checking a scrape this past Halloween night. Arrowed the buck while chasing a doe at daybreak on November 3rd.

Later learned there were multiple trail cam photos of that buck showing up for years (mostly at night) on another farm... a few miles SE of the farm I hunt.

From: Candor
31-Dec-24
No.

I do not run trail cameras materially though. I have one out this year.

From: Recurve Man
31-Dec-24
No

From: boobowmen
31-Dec-24
No

31-Dec-24
Yes 2011

From: BIGOK2
31-Dec-24
No but i later learned deer was on camera over 2 miles away.

From: StickFlicker
01-Jan-25
Ask again when we're talking mule deer!

From: Marty
01-Jan-25
no

From: BillyD
01-Jan-25
Yes. 2018.

From: BillyD
01-Jan-25
Yes. 2018.

01-Jan-25
Nope.

Don’t own one.

From: deerhunter72
01-Jan-25
Yes, 2021. Had pics of him from the year before as well and the amount of antler he put on is still hard to believe.

From: Cazador
01-Jan-25
No, just bought a camera last year, going back to no cameras.

From: Mark Watkins
01-Jan-25
Yes. 2016

Mark

01-Jan-25
No

From: Ahawkeye
01-Jan-25
No

From: M.Pauls
01-Jan-25
Yes, 2012

From: dnovo
01-Jan-25
No, but unknown to me he was on a camera my neighbor had. There was 16 pics of him in less than a week and this was the week I killed him. Nobody had looked at the camera to see the pics until after I got him. 14 point non typical 159 1/8'"

From: Bou'bound
01-Jan-25
26 no 16 yes to this point

From: kakiatkids
01-Jan-25
Yes, I saw him in pics the evening of 11/10/2019. I got him the next morning 7:00 am. It was the first time I had ever seen this particular buck on any of my cameras.

From: Pyrannah
01-Jan-25
No

01-Jan-25
No

From: Ironbow
01-Jan-25
Yes 2009. Found the picture 2 days after I killed him. Old camera had a 4 second delay time!

From: TEmbry
01-Jan-25
Yes 2010. Small edge of urban 10 acre piece and was opening morning. With limited places to hunt I’d have been in that stand either way (eager college kid foaming at the mouth to hunt)… but my trail cam gave me extreme confidence I’d see him that evening too.

From: Schmitty78
01-Jan-25
Largest buck, no. Killed him with a rifle before cameras were popular. My largest with a bow I did have on camera though

From: Pat Lefemine
01-Jan-25
Yes, my 191 in Kansas was on cam for a week before I killed him. Same with my 187 is Saskatchewan.

From: T-rex
02-Jan-25
Yes - 2021

From: Joe Holden
02-Jan-25
No. For what it's worth, took a picture of him through binoculars scouting a beanfield in August. Killed him in November.

From: APauls
02-Jan-25

APauls's embedded Photo
APauls's embedded Photo
Yes 2021

From: TonyBear
02-Jan-25
No but I have the pics of the biggest one on the property being killed by someone else. 2023 and 2024.

02-Jan-25
Yes. Iowa.

3 days before I killed him.

From: Shiras42
02-Jan-25
Yes

From: Rock
02-Jan-25
Not my biggest but a good one that I killed several years ago. At the time I did not use or even have a game camera. There was another guy hunting the property where I was hunting but he was supposed to be hunting a mile south of me. He had bait piles and camera's not far from my stand although he did not know where my stand was. I tried to work with him so we could both have a good hunt but he would have no part of that. So in desperation I talked to the landowner to see if he had another place I could hunt without interference. He was not happy that the other hunter was there without letting him know so he sent me to a new spot and made the other guy leave the area I had been hunting.

I really liked the spot I had been hunting so I decided to stay there and the next morning I had it all to myself. That morning a really good Buck came by close but I did not like the shot thru small saplings and he was moving faster than I wanted. So I passed and then tried to call him back after he got out a ways, which he would have none of but did look. He left headed west, that evening with just 20 minutes of shooting light left I could see a Buck working a scrape east of me but could not tell what he was until he came down my best trail at 9 yards. It was the same buck so I shot him.

I day or 2 later I was reading a Bowsite about trail camera pictures with pictures of bucks on it. One picture caught my interest, and I showed it to my friend who's house I was staying at. Asking him to look at the trees in the background and if he thought those were the trees by my stand. He tells me he had no idea but that the Buck in the picture was the one I just shot. Turns out the other hunter on that property had posted the picture.

From: Don K
02-Jan-25
No

From: WhattheFOC
02-Jan-25
No.

On more than one occasion, we’ve seen THE big buck, in person, skirting a bait site. Not one pic of him on the camera. He’s not willing to step in front of it, day or night - from sep to Xmas. Sometimes all the technology still doesn’t pay off.

From: Bou'bound
02-Jan-25
35 no

24 yes

From: Bou'bound
02-Jan-25

From: SteveB
02-Jan-25

SteveB's embedded Photo
SteveB's embedded Photo
SteveB's embedded Photo
SteveB's embedded Photo
SteveB's embedded Photo
SteveB's embedded Photo
Yes, and I had him at 42 yards broadside on opening day and let him walk. My son shot him in Ohio gun season. 210 3/8 gross

From: Gun
02-Jan-25

Gun's embedded Photo
Yes
Gun's embedded Photo
Yes

From: drycreek
02-Jan-25
Lord, I hope not ! It was over forty years ago, I was drinking, and I don’t think anybody saw us.

02-Jan-25
Yes. Iowa.

3 days before I killed him.

From: Hans 1
05-Jan-25
Yes all of my highest scoring deer I had pictures Top 5 we’re taken 2007,2010,2015,2017 and 2024

From: Fulldraw1972
05-Jan-25
No

From: Beav
05-Jan-25
No

From: carcus
05-Jan-25
nope

From: Bou'bound
05-Jan-25
39 no 28 yes

From: drycreek
05-Jan-25
No, I had never even hunted that place before.

From: goyt
06-Jan-25
No. I was not using many cameras if any, at the time. I had seen him work an area three times the previous year and was in place when he did it the next season.

I had the last 3 bucks I shot on camera before I shot them.

06-Jan-25
No. I did get three bucks on camera before I shot them. The average distance from the camera and where I shot them was 0.8miles

From: Bou'bound
06-Jan-25

06-Jan-25

FORESTBOWS 's embedded Photo
FORESTBOWS 's embedded Photo
Yes a few.

From: iceman
06-Jan-25
Yes. 2022

From: mattandersen
07-Jan-25
yes 2016

From: Nick Muche
14-Jan-25
Yes

From: Two Dogs
14-Jan-25
No

From: Bou'bound
14-Jan-25
43 no 32 yes

From: Brotsky
14-Jan-25
No 2019

From: Tater
14-Jan-25
Yes. 2024

From: Bou'bound
14-Jan-25
43 no 32 yes

From: badlander
15-Jan-25
yes, 2024

Pretty rare anymore that we don't have a whole stack of trail camera pics of the bucks we shoot.

From: Shug
16-Jan-25

Shug's embedded Photo
Shug's embedded Photo
I said yes before but just found a pic.

  • Sitka Gear