onX Maps
Scarface
Ohio
Contributors to this thread:
Pat Lefemine 30-Oct-22
Old Reb 30-Oct-22
btnbuck 31-Oct-22
CAS_HNTR 31-Oct-22
Zbone 31-Oct-22
ultimag 06-Nov-22
Pat Lefemine 26-Jan-23
goyt 26-Jan-23
mattandersen 27-Jan-23
Zbone 28-Jan-23
Pat Lefemine 28-Jan-23
Zbone 29-Jan-23
CAS_HNTR 29-Jan-23
Pat Lefemine 30-Jan-23
BUCKeye 30-Jan-23
TMac 31-Jan-23
From: Pat Lefemine
30-Oct-22

Pat Lefemine's embedded Photo
Scarface
Pat Lefemine's embedded Photo
Scarface
This is the buck I call Scarface. I am pretty sure he's 5.5, and am guessing he was injured and blinded in his left eye two years ago while fighting with the buck I killed last year. They both lived on my ground and fought constantly. When I killed that 5.5 eight last year, this guy became the dominant resident. He's running around all over the place in daylight now. He's not the best scoring buck I have, but he's my favorite.

From: Old Reb
30-Oct-22
He's got nice brow tines for sure.

From: btnbuck
31-Oct-22
I passed on a similar buck a few years ago. Big bodied mature buck and blind in one eye. When he came in the other bucks attitudes changed. He wouldn’t have scored well either but I still regret not taking him home. This was in Carroll co. also. Good luck this year!

From: CAS_HNTR
31-Oct-22
Good looking buck Pat. I think we have 3-4 deer that dont have eyes anymore on our property. Night pics and 'no glow' in one eye is a dead giveaway.

This buck is more beat up, but he looks healthy!

From: Zbone
31-Oct-22
A smooth 4x4.... Hmmmm...8^)

Nice...

From: ultimag
06-Nov-22
pretty deer

From: Pat Lefemine
26-Jan-23

Pat Lefemine's embedded Photo
Redemption after 42 hunts
Pat Lefemine's embedded Photo
Redemption after 42 hunts
Quick story. The day after I posted the starting thread I shot Scarface and hit him in the shoulder. Not one drop of blood. I was sick.

A week later I got a video of him. He was limping really bad.

I spent 42 days hunting him. He was incredibly smart, 5.5 year old. He was almost entirely nocturnal. I passed up some really good bucks but I was obsessed with him. So I stayed disciplined.

On Tuesday afternoon, after almost 3 months of trying, scarface limped in. It was hard to watch. He was still limping as bad as ever.

I took a 28 yard shot and killed scarface. As it turned out, I didn’t hit the shoulder after all. I had dead centered the joint where the shoulder connects to the front leg. The joint was shattered. The leg was useless. The buck had probably lost 50lbs.

So happy I held out and got him. He’s a damn good buck, but I’m really happy that I was able to kill him before nature did.

From: goyt
26-Jan-23
Congratulations on a great buck. Way to grind it out. It is surprising that he did not shed considering the condition his was in.

From: mattandersen
27-Jan-23
Damn way to go Pat!

From: Zbone
28-Jan-23
WOW, yeah way to go Pat, CONGRATS!!!

Crippling weight loss like that, it's a wonder he hadn't shed his rack....

Curious, first shot bone shattering, Muzzy broadhead? Was there penetration past the joint?

From: Pat Lefemine
28-Jan-23

Pat Lefemine's embedded Photo
Pat Lefemine's embedded Photo
Z,

Slick Trick 3-blade standard. Broadhead.

Freak hit. Was actually well-placed. Broadhead busted the joint and stopped.

From: Zbone
29-Jan-23
Wow, thanks for the photo and info...

From: CAS_HNTR
29-Jan-23
Pat...that is pretty awesome that you were able to get the buck down in the end. Congrats.

I assume you got in on him coming into food? Curious how you helped pinpoint him to get on him again?

From: Pat Lefemine
30-Jan-23
Craig, I kept moving trail cams to hone in on his habits after thanksgiving.

I noticed a trend in December where he would limp into a staging area south of my kill plot and East of my bean field. He generally showed up after midnight and would leave around 4-5 am.

During Christmas week I got one pic in daylight and another the 2nd week of January. Both times when I was away from the land.

By mid January I decided to do something I rarely do; hunt the same stand every evening regardless of wind and weather. I only had 3 daylight pics in 60 days but they were consistently from the same stand where I get 80% of my night pics. So decided to hunt this stand pretty much every day until I killed him or the season closed.

Last Tuesday he limped in at last light and I shot him just before that snowstorm we had. I think the low pressure and bad weather got him moving earlier than normal. Luck= 40%, skill=10%, OCD=50%. :-)

From: BUCKeye
30-Jan-23
Persistence pays off. Congrats Pat

From: TMac
31-Jan-23
Wow, very nice Pat! Great Buck congrats!

  • Sitka Gear